3 ms·
That's the important element in the "Moral" vs "Prgamatic" scenario - how much are we spending in time, energy, collateral damage in trying to be "right." In t
by ghshephard 15y ago
That's the important element in the "Moral" vs "Prgamatic" scenario - how much are we spending in time, energy, collateral damage in trying to be "right." In the case of the bathroom (war on drugs, anti-piracy, etc..) - not only are we now spending money on a camera, monitoring it, following-up, firing people - we are also invading people's privacy, impacting employee morale. Yes - it's true, taken to the logical conclusion - all of these moral victories can be one, should we be willing to go to extremes to demonstrate we are "right" - but at the end of the day, what did it that moral victory end up costing us?
So - in Portgual, and British Columbia - Heroin Addiction is now treated as a health issue. Government actually supports safe injection sites in Vancouver. They might have lost the "Moral" victory, but drug overdoses have effectively ceased. Giving in to all those employees in the bathroom who are lazy, might have been ceding the moral victory, but for the price of a move of the garbage can, the paper issue was handled.
We are, of course, actually talking about intellectual property, and the mechanism by which the media industry can extract maximal profits, without regard to their own moral position - iTunes Match is a nice first step - recognize that yes, their may be some people with illegitimately acquired content - so, give them the highest quality version of it, and charge them $25/year for the service.
Once you realize the actual goal is not moral superiority, but the pragmatic end-game, all sorts of opportunities open up.