2 ms·
Speaking as a programmer, I'd love to provide feedback as to why potential employees weren't thought to be a good fit. Speaking as an employer, responding to s
by ColinWright 15y ago
Speaking as a programmer, I'd love to provide feedback as to why potential employees weren't thought to be a good fit.
Speaking as an employer, responding to such a request opens one up to all sorts of legal challenges.
Net result: on the advice of our legal consultants we never provide feedback.
I personally think this is a tragedy, but it's a direct result of the litigious nature of today's society, and the aggressive nature of some people.
But consider this. If it's a small company and they responded so swiftly to code that you (and others) thought was fine, would you be happy working there anyway?
Of course, if you don't ask, you don't get. Why not phrase it carefully to show that you accept that you haven't got the job, but you are keen to learn from the experience, and would welcome any comments about your code, understanding that this cannot form the basis of any kind of action against them.
- jdas 15y agoThanks for the thoughts. How about something like: Hey Guys: Thank you very much for the opportunity to interview with <COMPANY>. While I understand that you don't view me as a good fit to work with you guys, I would greatly appreciate knowing what was incorrect about my submission, such that I can continue developing my skills to ultimately attain a point where we are a good fit for each other. Thank you very much,
- ColinWright 15y agoThat sounds fine. I'd make a few small adjustments, but it has to be your words. Here I've tried to make it clear that their decision has been accepted, and acknowledge that there's nothing in it for them to provide the feedback: Hey Guys: Just wanted to say thanks for the opportunity to interview with you. I recognize and understand that for whatever reason you decided I'm not a good fit, and accept that. I was wondering, though, if there'd be any chance of some feedback about my submission. I know that this would take some time and effort on your behalf for no real return, but I'd really appreciate anything you'd care to tell me about my submission. I'm always eager to learn and develop my skills, and perhaps you can help me become a better programmer, and possibly become a good fit for the future. Yours etc