11 ms·
It's a weird interaction with Section 230 if Reddit can say "these posts are not ours, they are the posters" and yet the poster cannot edit/delete them. Of cou
by bombcar 3y ago
It's a weird interaction with Section 230 if Reddit can say "these posts are not ours, they are the posters" and yet the poster cannot edit/delete them.
Of course, HN itself kills your edit window after a certain time limit, so there is some legal way of doing it, I assume.
- tazjin 3y agoHN also has a prominent FAQ entry about this where they say they will help you with deletion requests for personal information if you email them.
- brookst 3y agoSection 230 does not talk about ownership. A freight company is generally not liable for contraband shipped without its knowledge. That does not mean that all shipments become the property of the freight company. Same thing.
- bombcar 3y agoA freight company that took your freight, refused to give it back, and acted like it was now theirs would appear to own it. If Reddit says "your content is yours but you cannot delete it" they're in a bit of a cake-and-eat-it-too scenario. I'm entirely sure it's legal (as other forums/HN/etc do it too) but I'm not sure it's right.
- brookst 3y ago> If Reddit says "your content is yours but you cannot delete it" they're in a bit of a cake-and-eat-it-too scenario. Yes, but the user is also in a cake-and-eat-it-to scenario: they get to own the content and have it distributed for free. Both sides of this come from the perpetual non-exclusive license that posting to Reddit or Twitter or anywhere confers. "Ownership" is too reductive a concept for IP, which is why the section 230 thing is a non sequitur.