9 ms·
Stop Calling Each New Disaster “The New Normal”
- starbugs 3y agoHow about not calling something a crisis if it isn't? A crisis is usually short-lived, not a permanent state.
- hospitalJail 3y agoI got one better. Use actual math to decide how bad it is. COVID 1% death rates among the elderly, sick, and obese? Not a crisis, that is essentially a bad flu year prior to 2020. (And 2018 and 2019 had a relatively low excess winter mortality, keeping the people on the brink of death, alive). There is a particular issue the news loves to report on in America, its basically a rounding error, but when children are involved, its especially emotional. Climate crisis that could kill 100% of humans, all hands on deck. Obesity related issues, nearly all hands on deck. Cancer, just past fixing obesity. Car accidents are something worth extra investment too. Not even sure how to take this problem on, you mention the irrationality of an issue, and people get even more emotional.
- CalRobert 3y agoCovid was a sad reminder that we can rally the troops and make huge society-wide changes to protect old people, but won't lift a finger to protect kids from climate breakdown.
- hospitalJail 3y agoI'm not even sure it was to protect old people. It felt more like a political game.
- starbugs 3y ago> Climate crisis that could kill 100% of humans This wording is just a bait for clicks and taps and does nothing to improve anything. That's why people get tired and call it the new normal. Let them get emotional. It's part of the process of finding real solutions. Real solutions must work in the real world, globally in this case. It's not an easy problem to fix.
- hnbad 3y agoThat's why a lot of activists seem to have taken to calling it the "climate catastrophe" or the "climate disaster" I guess. "Climate change" is just another way to say "new normal".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- starbugs 3y agoInitially, it wasn't. Every new term is new only for a certain time. The way these terms are being used in the media can lead to semantic bleaching, which is why from time to time new terms are made up. In the end, this doesn't change anything about what it is. It's a somewhat slow process with a big lag between action and outcome. Using terms to describe this that typically are reserved for events that are fundamentally different in nature (much shorter time scales, short lag between actions and outcome, etc.) is counter productive. We have to grow up and learn to look at it from a calm, non-panicky view point and take action where action makes sense in the context of our lives (not only from a reductionist view point that only looks at the climate and nothing else). Maybe even more importantly, we have to learn how to be fine with not taking action where it doesn't make sense and would come with a high probability of making things worse.
- Waterluvian 3y agoMy favourite phrase for a “new normal” moment is the borrowed Simpsons joke: A: “This is the hottest summer ever!” B: “This is the coldest summer of the rest of your life!”
- boredumb 3y agoI think all the alarmist language is doing a massive disservice to environmental concerns for the reason the author is portraying but also a much different reason where a lot of people tend to greet hysterics with absolute doubt and discern. When environmentalists decided instead of having a real public conversation and resorting to what a lot of people perceive as the people screaming on the corner about the end times - they began getting met with people who will disregard everything they say and then decided to double down by labeling people who disregarded them as heretics. If I was more cynical I'd honestly believe that the climate change activists are agit-prop by groups that would be subject to a lot of the more reasonable environmental changes by letting/getting very loud and passionate people to tell middle and lower class people they can't own cars, eat certain meats and have their right to travel impeded in order to get a portion of the population to disregard any environmental legislations. I guess, a large portion of climate change activists give the same effect as flat-earthers do with some legitimate conspiracy theories but to the people trying to enact straight forward environmental legislations. A sort of, shitting-in-the-pool effect.
- crooked-v 3y agoThe attempts at "real public conversation" led to passive or active mockery anyway. Consider, for example, ManBearPig.
- boredumb 3y agoI don't think many people were under the impression Al Gore was having a real public conversation. His books and movies fall squarely into the "alarmist" category.
- CalRobert 3y agoIn what sense?
- JimtheCoder 3y agoDidn't he say we would all be underwater by 2010 or something? I didn't see the movie...
- throwaway22032 3y agoThe point of phrasing like "the new normal" is to frame the debate in the correct manner and focus on the actual issue at hand rather than people who attempt to exploit crises. In the pandemic we had a whole bunch of sweeping changes to society, some of which stuck for reasons wholly disconnected from the matter at hand. Some of us really care about climate change and environmental destruction, but at the same time don't want to throw out the baby with the bathwater. It's not worth "saving the planet" if we come out of the other side living in anthills unable to even enjoy the nature we have.
- pixel3234 3y agoDisasters are normal! In past 10,000 years global sea level has risen by 100 meters.
- ceejayoz 3y agoExtinction is normal, but we probably don’t want to go extinct either.
- defrost 3y agoAccuracy, please. During the peak of the last Ice Age (~20,000 years ago), sea level was ~120 m lower than today. As a consequence of global warming, albeit naturally, the rate of sea-level rise averaged ~1.2 cm per year for 10,000 years until it levelled off at roughly today's position ~10,000 years ago. [1] The important part being things have been stable for a very long time wrt human history. All our established patterns, infrastructure, agriculture, etc. risks being upended by relatively drastic change as a result of our activity as humans ... or not, if we recognise the causes and take action to mitigate. [1] https://www.imperial.ac.uk/media/imperial-college/grantham-institute/public/publications/briefing-papers/Sea-level-change-Briefing-Note-1v2.pdf https://www.imperial.ac.uk/media/imperial-college/grantham-i...
- 29_29 3y agoAccuracy, please. Florida has been both completely submerged and prior to the ice age had much much more coast line. If you dig anywhere in Florida you can find evidence of it being the sea floor. > with the result being that the oceans were about 400 feet (122 meters) lower than today. During the last global "warm spell," about 125,000 years ago, the seas were about 18 feet (5.5. meters) higher [1] https://www.usgs.gov/media/images/coastline-eastern-us-changesslowly https://www.usgs.gov/media/images/coastline-eastern-us-chang...
- swader999 3y agoExcept it never leveled off. It's been rising at the same rate for several thousand years.
- swader999 3y agoWhat happened in Alberta was just a couple weeks of warm weather after a fairly cold winter. The timing was right when new growth hadn't had a chance to take hold so all the dry grass and tinder was perfect fuel. The rap attack helicopter crews were dismantled in both BC and Alberta to save a few millions at best. Easily doubled the size of the burn area not having this capability. This is normal but not new. Alberta has had larger amounts burned and the trend is down. The 1920's to 1940's were the worst in recorded history. Accurate measuring of what was burned has improved each decade too. Earlier in the record much was not included.
- op00to 3y agoThe problem isn’t just the fire. It’s the strange weather patterns that bring smoke down to areas that have never seen conditions like that. Was the warm ocean keeping the jet stream from its typical shape?
- swader999 3y agoSmoke in New York from Canadian boreal fires happened in the May 2010 fire and the May 1870 Saguenay fire. In 1870 parts of Europe were covered in smoke from the Canadian fire. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saguenay_Fire https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saguenay_Fire
- ip26 3y ago1870, 2010, 2023, ????
- _ea1k 3y ago1870, 2010, 2023, 2146, ????
- runarberg 3y agoSo what is you point here? That warming planet is not likely to increase the rate of New York suffering smokes? Honestly this would put New York in a pretty special place as forest fires are set to increase a lot, and smokes are expected to distribute in higher density to wider areas. This is pretty observable on the West Coast already, where we have a brand new Smoke Season in the early to late autumn in the Pacific North West. But realistically New York will not be this lucky, and the chances of the next smokes coming as distantly apart as per-industrialization is probably close to 0. I’m not a climate scientist but I bet we will for sure see several more smokes coming to New York before the end of the century (just like we have on the West Coast in the past 5 years).
- exitb 3y agoWhile I support the efforts to prevent and reverse the environmental damage we're causing, personally I don't believe they'll really succeed. It seems that human society is fundamentally incapable of acting in a coordinated way against a global, long term threat. So at a certain point convincing people to take the bus instead of a car, specifically because that will save the planet, starts to seem like a lie. It's not unreasonable to start thinking in terms of preparedness, rather than just prevention.
- swader999 3y agoWe dealt with the ozone hole fairly well. There hasn't been total nuclear war. The Netherlands is ten feet under sea level and does fine. Polar bears and all other bears are absolutely thriving.
- exitb 3y agoNeither of these things required any change from regular people. In fact, today many people say that ozone hole just disappeared, because the changes needed were so transparent, no one even noticed. Is there a way people can continue their normal lives, but still eliminate the green house gasses emissions?
- swader999 3y agoWe won't reduce emissions unless there's a massive reduction in population. Otherwise normal people will adapt. Less people will die if the planet warms more. Extreme cold events kill more than heat waves do and that's even without including the seasonal flu and cardiac events related to the cold.
- Timon3 3y agoThere are hard limits on how much heat a human can take. We cannot adapt beyond, except for literally never going outside again.
- 3y ago
- perfunctory 3y agoToo bad the author is not offering any alternative. It's not good enough to just say "stop doing X". It would be nice if it's followed by "Do Y instead". Maybe I missed it, but the only thing I found in the whole article that resembles a counterproposal is a single sentence in the end - "... policy flows from conversation and debate instead of force." So we are supposed to have more conversation and debate? Sounds like exactly what we've been doing for the last 30,40,50 years.
- JimtheCoder 3y ago"So we are supposed to have more conversation and debate? Sounds like exactly what we've been doing for the last 30,40,50 years." It has sounded more like competing monologues than anything else to me...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mistermann 3y agoGood point....it's like, does anyone actually think something useful is going to come out of threads like this other than enjoyment?
- Levitz 3y agoThe subtext under the headline seems direct enough: >When it comes to the climate crisis, new normals convey a single, grim message: instead of acting, get used to it The idea is to stop calling things "The new normal" since that implies acceptance. Fight instead. Don't go along with the idea that the world has to be like this.
- pif 3y agoConcerning climate change, the world is going to be like this. All models are clear that global warming cannot be reversed. No "turning green" will lower average temperatures enough in our lifetime. Thus, acceptance is capital, because only acceptance of reality can lead to sensible solutions. As a side note, screaming "It's too late: hurry up!" is really an idiot way to advocate your cause, whatever your cause may be.
- sgt 3y ago2043AD: "A nuclear bomb went off today in New York City. Welcome ladies and gentlemen, to the New Normal™. That is why we at Chemcorp have a special on Iodine tablets for only $3.99/month! So put on your radiation suit and head on down to your nearest store!"
- CalRobert 3y agoI wish we had a better word or phrase to encapsulate "the rate of change in our planetary systems has increase, and will continue to increase, with greater and greater disruptions and crises as time goes on" Basically taking second derivative of crises.
- spywaregorilla 3y agoAccelerating
- swader999 3y agoBut it hasn't. Sea level rise and extreme weather events are not on an accelerating trend. Hurricanes for example. Fires in the twenties and forties were much worse. North America is greener now more than ever in the last two hundred years.
- CalRobert 3y ago"Between 1901 and 2018, the average global sea level rose by 15–25 cm (6–10 in), or 1–2 mm per year.[1] This rate is increasing; sea levels are now rising at a rate of 3.7 mm (0.146 inches) per year.[2] " https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_level_rise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_level_rise sources are 1: IPCC, 2019: Summary for Policymakers 2: IPCC, 2021: Summary for Policymakers seems credible?
- swader999 3y agoThat 3.7mm per year is dubious. But, yeah sure I'll even give you that, and it's easily manageable over that time frame. More from your source: "" If global warming is limited to 1.5 °C (2.7 °F), then sea level rise does not accelerate, but it would still amount to 2–3 m (7–10 ft) over the next 2000 years, while 19–22 metres (62–72 ft) would occur if the warming peaks at 5 °C (9.0 °F)
- Havoc 3y agoStop telling me what to do
- romusha 3y agoNobody cares
- Epicism 3y agoCalling each new disaster the new normal is now the new normal
- photochemsyn 3y agoStop calling it 'climate change', the correct (causative, descriptive) phrase is 'fossil-fueled global warming'. Industry PR types worked hard to relabel the phenomenon because the former is a blander term that doesn't explicitly point the finger at the root cause. As far as normals, the warming rate is slow enough that it takes about ten years (running average) for conditions to notably change. See this 'staircase of denial' tweet. https://twitter.com/mathiasced/status/1616348855842250754?lang=en https://twitter.com/mathiasced/status/1616348855842250754?la... This is a hard problem for human civilization because 'taking action' today - i.e. replacing all fossil fuels with renewables on the fastest imaginable timeline (about three decades of constant heavy lifting at best) won't affect the rate of warming much for the next 100 years or so, we'll be seeing +0.1 C per decade at least for that timeframe on average (higher at the poles, lower at the equator). I suppose 'normal' is what humans get used to, as once some phenomenon has been the same for about a decade, people start calling it normal. This is a flaw in human cognition, resulting in poor capacity for truly long-term planning.
- RajT88 3y agoCalling things the "New Normal" is the "New Normal".
- PheonixPharts 3y agoWhile I agree with the title, I think the author misses the real reason not to refer to the "New Normal". David Wallace-Wells sums it up pretty well: > It is tempting to look at these strings of disasters and think, Climate change is here... this is how California governor Jerry Brown first described the state of things in the midst of the state's wildfire disaster: "a new normal" > The truth is actually much scarier. That is, the end of normal; never normal again. We have already exited the state of environmental conditions that allowed the human animal to evolve in the first place, in an unsure and unplanned bet on just what that animal can endure. This is where climate change, from a human perspective, is so different than any other disaster we've dealt with prior. From earth quakes to even something as extreme as nuclear war, these events represent a single, high magnitude disruption of the status quo, which then leads to the return of a new stability. Once the change has occurred adaption can begin. Climate change will continue to get worse throughout our lives, the lives of our children after us, and most certainly their children as well. We won't reach a new point of stability which we can call the "new normal" for multiple generations. You'll never get "used to it" during your life time. As soon as people get used to smoky skies, hotter summers and drier winters, the next challenges will starting to occur and they'll be more extreme.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nologic01 3y agoClimate change from anthropogenic green house gas emissions is an example of "fiddling with systemic parameters" and hoping that all response is linear. Its not just CO2 and friends. Any shifting around of systemic chemical compositions (whether in air, water or soil) has similar potential for difficult to predict (and hard to reverse) damage. Given our role and abilities fiddling with these types of systemic abundances does not lead to immediate feedback loops. It takes generations to move the needle. But tipping points are real in any complex system. The biosphere is not a static something that can be tuned at the service of homo sapiens. It will rebalance. And the new equilibrium might not be to our liking. Surviving this "slow cooking of the frog" phenomenon will require us to develop behaviors that we have never before contemplated. Developing a web of trust, objectivity and sense of responsibility not only among all living individuals but also all future generations.
- paganel 3y ago“Stop being a doomer!” sounds even better, especially after two years of Covid-related doomer mandates that have brought us (and especially our kids) more harm than good.
- SoftTalker 3y agoPhrases like "the new normal" are clues that what you are reading is propaganda. The author has an agenda, and is not just relaying information. If you find yourself using such phrases, stop. It's cliche, and weakens the message. Stick to facts, or if you are writing persuasively, make a proper argument instead of falling back on stock phrases.
- runarberg 3y agoWhat do you suggest instead? My favorite phrase that I think captures the urgency and the desperate nature of the situation is “This is only gonna get worse, and we are all going to die”.
- holbrad 3y agoWe shouldn't be spewing bullshit like this... It's going to get worse, but trying to spin climate change as some apocalyptic event where we all die is just silly.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 3y ago> we all die is just silly. Not all then, just hundreds of millions of person. Phew!
- runarberg 3y agoI remember a time when this was phrased as an “inconvenient truth” or that “we can all do our part to make the world a better place”. Honestly I prefer the alarmist hyperbole. The truth is that a lot of us are going to die, more of us will have our lives uprooted. Keeping calm and pretending otherwise seems like a greater bullshit and I at least am not gonna take it. The world is worse, it is gonna be worse. Some rich folks and politicians are responsible. And I want them to feel bad about it. A point of comparison. The pandemic does seem like a walk in the park next to the climate catastrophe, I don't recall people warning about alarmist speech at the onset of it.
- 3y ago
- sfeaster 3y agoThis is an "old man yells at clouds moment." Eventually you either give up on expecting the media to be a purveyor of good or, at a minimum, frame an argument such that laymen have a thoughtful view on an issue OR be perpetually frustrated - yelling at clouds, so to speak. I realized I had to choose the former for my own mental health. The incentives of 24 news cycle media in no way align with a healthy society. Best to accept that truth and move on.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 3y agoAnd how do you move on?
- sfeaster 3y agoWith systems (and the media is a system) incentives are destiny. Unless you can change the dynamics and incentives of the news/media market, I'm not sure what choice one has. Again, you can keep hoping but reality will win out. I mean, go ahead, write your articles like this but the incentives will win out and the broader media will keep writing according to what perverse incentives say gets the most eyeballs.
- scrubs 3y agoWhy (Stop Calling Each New Disaster “The New Normal”); - because it's hype - because it's entitlement: embellisher's don the hat of a super sophisticated tech in the middle of a maelstrom that only his 1000 yard stare can reconcile. You can't really know how tough this stuff is... and it's what make me and my job cool. I'm a warrior! - cause it's an implicit admission one has no solutions. - cause it's not quantified. If I wanna know if it's normal I'll talk to accountants and insurers to see trends not the cool guy.