4 ms·
Can You Change Your Metabolism?
- paulpauper 3y ago“Each metabolic activity or system in the body is interconnected, and [if] you start exercising more, over weeks and months, your body adjusts and starts spending fewer calories on overall tasks and resets back to where it was,” Urlacher says. This energy compensation may explain why simply adding more miles a week can yield fitness and other gains but has little effect on weight. People who exercise also tend to increase caloric intake to compensate for the additional energy expenditure. damn. turns on its head the common notion exercise is good for weight loss. maybe instead of making exercise predictable and routine, it should be done randomly to prevent this adaptation from occurring?
- ndsipa_pomu 3y agoDiet control is the most effective way to lose weight, though not necessarily easy for people and exercise is the best way to improve health and fitness. Strangely, I find my appetite is suppressed immediately after doing a bit of cycling, but I'm sure I make up for it the following day.
- LoganDark 3y agoWhen I started ADHD meds I lost like 10lbs in a month due to eating way less. I think I'm now 20lbs under where I started after 3 months or so and I think that's where it's going to stay. I'm not one to worry too much about my weight, it's just something my doctor told me because he weighs me every appointment.
- tsimionescu 3y agoYes, various mental conditions and drugs can significantly affect our weight through poorly understood indirect means. A common example is lithium, often given to people who suffer from bipolar disorders - it has a significant effect on weight, typically causing many kilos of weight gain. It's very funny to see people then claim that the story stops at CICO or that your calories in and/or your calories out are entirely within your conscious control.
- msy 3y agoThe evidence of anything other than simple CICO is marginal in both quality and impact. Sure, all sorts of things might make you feel hungrier or make you want to eat more or less but whether you actually gain weight or not is a product of how much food you put in your mouth and how much you move. But this is not a popular fact when everyone wants an excuse for failures of attention, discipline and willpower. Only real exception here are medications that affect water retention, but that is entirely separate to fat gain/loss.
- tsimionescu 3y agoCICO itself is actually at best an approximation, since neither CI nor CO are measurable, especially in any kind of real-world setting. Eating less and working out more will lead to reduced weight loss, but how people may be able to achieve this, especially on the long term, is unclear. The evidence for any kind of nutrition finding is slight. CICO has the advantage that it matches very basic thermodynamic principles, so it has to be true to some extent. But beyond this basic level, all you get in reality are some broad strokes. We know how much calories maximum can be extracted from a piece of food. We know how much energy minimum you need to consume to perform a particular excercise. But no one really knows how much calories one particular person will actually get from eating one particular piece of normal food, no one knows how much it will actually vary between people, no one knows what might affect that difference. No one also knows how much energy you'll actually use for doing a particular exercise given efficiency losses from your movements; and no one actually knows how much energy your body is passively consuming - nor everything that affects both of these. Beyond the problem of actually measuring CICO, there is the additional problem of treating humans as fre will agents when it comes to food, when we know full well we are biological machines that have biological imperatives. We may be able to suppress our base instincts to achieve longer term goals, but this ability is obviously limited. Things like appetite are not within our control, and our ability to prioritize the longer term goal versus the short term need that our body is signaling is also obviously limited. And not only are these limited, we know very well that they are affected by all sorts of internal processes. There are many psycho-active medications that are very very strongly proven to have an effect on appetite (lithium, SSRIs), as are certain diseases (thyroid issues for example). But sure, keep blaming people for their diseases. It worked great for curing AIDS, so I'm sure it will work on obesity any day now.
- Tade0 3y agoI found that after doing one of my bi-weekly cycle runs I simply sleep better and therefore feel less hungry during the next the day. Also despite hydrating there's slightly less water in my body, so I appear somewhat leaner.
- tsimionescu 3y agoAnyone who has tried to lose weight can tell you that. Exercise is extremely important for your health, but it doesn't significantly help with weight loss (assuming you're not doing professional sports levels of exercise). On the other hand, over the long term, more muscle weight will passively consume more calories and thus can help maintain your (lean) weight, especially for people who like eating a lot.
- occz 3y ago>On the other hand, over the long term, more muscle weight will passively consume more calories and thus can help maintain your (lean) weight, especially for people who like eating a lot. This is misleading - the amount of additional energy passively consumed by muscle mass is pretty insignificant - 10-15 kcal per kilo of muscle mass.^[1] Resistance training is still good, but definitely not good for this particular purpose. [1] https://www.unm.edu/~lkravitz/Article%20folder/metabolismcontroversy.html https://www.unm.edu/~lkravitz/Article%20folder/metabolismcon...
- votepaunchy 3y agoSo that lean muscle mass burns it’s weight in body fat about every 1.5 to 2 years.
- tsimionescu 3y agoI'm not sure what this article is, but BMR is most highly correlated to lean body mass, and it varies by a pretty large margin between individuals (e.g. Men are typically quoted as requiring ~2000Cal/day, vs women requiring ~1200, and much of the difference is actually attributable to lean body mass).
- Etheryte 3y agoExercising to lose weight is a myth and this is well known in all circles relating to fitness, sport, etc. The main question is why is this idea so prevalent in the mainstream if more or less everyone who's even a bit educated on the matter agrees that it's bogus?
- ffgjgf1 3y agoIt’a not bogus though. People just severely underestimate how much exercise they need to drop significant amounts of weight. Also there is the longterm benefit due to increased metabolism.
- Etheryte 3y agoFor all practical intents and purposes it is bogus though, we're talking about an order of magnitude of a difference between what your eating accounts for and what working out accounts for for an average individual. You can easily consume more calories by having a sandwich or two than you burn in a gym session. Saying that losing weight is simply a matter of working out more is highly misleading and sets people up for failure. Saying people should work out to lose weight is like saying people should avoid avocado toast to get rich — yes, every little bit helps, but it really misses the real point.
- sahila 3y agoYou make it seem like people can't reason for themselves about it. If you go on a 3 mile run, people will burn about 300-400 calories and is immediately available if you use a watch or even just your phone to track. Then you can walk into Chipotle and see a burrito is 900 calories and do the math that you'd need to run 3 times a week to burn off an extra burrito. But yes, most fitness proponents will almost always say that weight is controlled in the kitchen. Where do you see that people say you should only workout to lose weight?
- ffgjgf1 3y agoThere are other benefits from exercising other than the calories burn during it. Increases to both short term metabolism and longterm due to higher muscle mass do add up. > Saying that losing weight is simply a matter I never said that. But yes if you’re at a stable weight adding regular exercise to your routine might be enough to tip the scales. It’s not going to be simple though. > s like saying people should avoid avocado toast to get rich Nonsensical analogy.
- pleb_nz 3y agoMost people who do fitness or sports already understand this. As the saying goes fitness starts in the gym, weight management starts in the kitchen.
- veave 3y ago"Nutrition has made no progress. It has discovered no stable facts. Everything nutritionists have said, they have said the opposite ten or twenty years later (if not much sooner). They literally know nothing. After a century of countless experiments, the most common, most basic problem they’ve addressed—the optimal ratio of fat, protein, and carbohydrate—is completely unsolved. If they can’t figure that out, anything more sophisticated seems hopeless."
- tsimionescu 3y agoWhile I fully agree withtthe gist of this quote, I think one major point is wrong: the idea of an optimal ratio between the macronutrient is probably bullshit in itself. In fact, the idea of categorizing food into such simple categories (three macronutrients + vitamins and minerals) at all seems wrong. Fiber plays a major role, different fats and different carbs have widely different effects, probably different proteins too. Note: the source of the quote for anyone curious to read more: https://metarationality.com/nutrition https://metarationality.com/nutrition
- carlmr 3y agoAside from macronutrients being too broad to be entirely meaningful. The underlying assumption that there is an optimal ratio already seems naïve. Humans probably have wildly different nutrition needs depending on how physically active they are, how hot it is in their part of the globe, which foods are available in their area, their gut microbiome, etc.
- simplicio 3y agoAlternatively, I think the idea that outside some extremely broad parameters (not eating a diet lacking essential vitamins, under-eating to the point of malnourishment or over-eating to the point of severe obesity, etc) there are no particular nutritional needs is under-examined. Nutritional Science seems based on the idea that relatively minor tweaks to diet can influence health outcomes. After several decades of failing to find what those tweaks might be, it always seems strange to me that people don't seem to consider that they might just not exist, and that the human body is fine with whatever food it gets, within some broad range.
- rsecora 3y agoThis article reveals how Scientific American has declined over time. It has become a mere shadow of its former self, resorting to sensationalism for online engagement. I understand the need for the magazine to cater to an audience, but how was this article even approved? It lacks specifics, relies on common knowledge, lacks relevant studies or investigations. It's nothing but clickbait.
- lozenge 3y agoIf it's accurate and has higher readership, what's the harm? I found it useful. Re topics, it is a shame for the regular readers if they have limited themselves to the short list of high SEO performing topics. But it would be hypocritical to complain about it from a link aggregator site where the article has only reached the front page due to this choice of a popular interest topic. When did you cancel your subscription?
- madsbuch 3y ago> If it's accurate and has higher readership, what's the harm? The other commenter argued that it relies on common knowledge as opposed to scientific knowledge. That's the harm. Especially for a journal claiming to be scientific.