4 ms·
I attended Stuyvesant in 1973-76, which I learn from this article was the era of the highest black enrollment. I have a few quibbles: the article states t
by leephillips 15y ago
I attended Stuyvesant in 1973-76, which I learn from this article was
the era of the highest black enrollment. I have a few quibbles: the
article states that admission was solely by test score. In fact, one of
my best (black) friends at Stuyvesant sheepishly told me that he
scored somewhat below the cutoff but was admitted as part of a
program to admit students from “disadvantaged” backgrounds with lower
scores. He was sheepish because he knew that I knew that he was in
fact quite wealthy and was from a privileged background. His
father was a famous radio personality. But the system treated him as
a member of a “disadvantaged” group because of his complexion.
The article says “Students take the exam in October of their eighth-grade
year”. Many students who will wind up at Stuyvesant never go
to eighth grade. Like me, they are placed in an accelerated
junior high program that consists of seventh and ninth grades only.
Also, the article refers repeatedly to “middle school”. The first
time I heard this term was after I moved away from New York.
The article refers to “free preparatory programs”. Never heard of
them, nor any other type of test preparation or practice. The test
resembles an SAT. If you know English and your junior high math, it’s
not that difficult to get in to Stuyvesant, frankly. I know this
because I was not very good at taking tests, and was somewhat
surprised that I got in.
A bigger obstacle is the desire to go there. Most American students
don’t want to face a year each of physics, biology, and chemistry,
math up to (and optionally including) calculus, and much more,
including economics, metal shop, and drafting. It might not sound
like much to the Germans and Japanese, but it does not resemble the
typical American highschool curriculum. I was shocked to meet people
in college whose mathematical knowledge seemed to stop at what I had
learned in 10th grade and who had never heard of mitochondria. All
this, and the nerd stigma, was what kept my siblings, for example,
from taking the test and settling for our abysmal neighborhood
school. Note that most of Stuyvesant’s population consists of the
offspring of immigrants, who seem to appreciate the importance of
education.