3 ms·
The problems you want to address are real. I also have seen the drift in HN over the years, as zealots start to outnumber (or at least out-post) those who will
by AnimalMuppet 3y ago
The problems you want to address are real. I also have seen the drift in HN over the years, as zealots start to outnumber (or at least out-post) those who will actually think.
But I suspect that tools aren't good enough to reliably work. (Do you want this post, say, marked as FUD because of a negative take on HN posters?)
The best answer I have is to parallelize dang. Downvote it when you see it, and don't feed the trolls (that just gives them a chance to make another comment). If it's particularly bad, downvote and flag. (I'm not sure what the threshold is to kill a comment. It's more than one flag, but it's not that many. I suspect it's in the low single digits. If very many people see the problem, and will bother to flag it, bad comments will quickly die.)
But there are at least two problems with my solution. First, it hasn't been working so far, or at least it hasn't been working well enough. It working better requires a change in behavior (and more effort) from the established users, which is kind of a tough ask. Second, this is something that could be turned against us if a block of zealots decided to mass-downvote and mass-flag things. I mean, we can vouch for dead comments, but that's also work...
- jjgreen 3y agoI get the impression that most people downvote a bad (or bad-faith) comment, flag a nasty one. I find that one time in 4-5, my flag seems to kill the comment, so I guess it takes around that many.
- roflyear 3y agoThere's big problems with both downvoting and flagging: you don't know WHY people are doing it. Without that, you can't correct behavior.
- jjgreen 3y agoI'm regularly downvoted and I know exactly why: because I'm mocking Rust's curl | sh or Python's appalling packaging or whatever, no-one is going to "correct" that behaviour and it doesn't matter anyway; it's just HN karma.
- roflyear 3y agoIs that "why" though?
- brudgers 3y agoThe simplest correction that might work is don’t do what was downvoted or flagged, again.
- roflyear 3y agoRight. But there's a difference between that thing and why it was downvoted. It could have been downvoted because it is factually incorrect, which means you should be careful about posting incorrect information. It could have been downvoted because it's inflammatory. It could have been downvoted because it is redundant (doesn't add to conversation). Sometimes it's not clear, and you only can speculate.
- brudgers 3y agoInflammatory is self evident. Non-contributory is self evident.
- roflyear 3y agoI didn't say it wasn't obvious in ALL CASES. And even in those cases there are language and communication issues that make it not obvious. Someone who doesn't speak English for example may use a tone that comes across as inflammatory when they really are just trying to lightheartedly say "wtf mate" which is sometimes a perfectly fine response.