6 ms·
The front page of lemmy: Lemmy - A link aggregator for the fediverse. Join a Server - Run a Server - Follow communities anywhere in the world Lemmy is a self
by Animats 3y ago
The front page of lemmy:
Lemmy - A link aggregator for the fediverse.
Join a Server - Run a Server - Follow communities anywhere in the world
Lemmy is a selfhosted social link aggregation and discussion platform.
No, no. You lead with the benefits to the user. This isn't Github.
It suffers from the same problem as Mastodon - "Join a server". But which one?
These federated things need to be set up so that there's "no wrong door". Enter anywhere, see the same stuff regardless of where it's hosted. Discovery and hosting may be distributed behind the scenes, but they have to have a unified user entry point.
USENET had that problem solved. It was federated, but it didn't look federated to the end user.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> No, no. You lead with the benefits to the user. This isn't Github Seriously. Have a default server (or set of defaults) newbies dump into after completing a simple sign-up flow. Then let them move it as they benefit from the product and gain an incentive to learn about it. Reddit is up in arms about API pricing and mods. Do you think the average Reddit user would have signed up if they had to first jump through hoops to prove their respect for community-based architecture? No! An infintessimal fraction of users care about philosophy or architecture, even when those values and decisions directly cause effects they follow. Users came for their cat pics. Give them their cat pics. Pitch them on the back end afterwards.
- Tempat 3y agoI don’t know much about how the fediverse thing works. Would it be theoretically possible to have something kind of like how torrents work, with some central list of all servers acting as the “tracker list”?: - Servers choose what they want to host and what their personal bandwidth limit is - A user visiting a specific subforum automatically downloads from whatever servers are currently available to serve it Then you’d never have to manually choose a server.
- wccrawford 3y agoYou don't have an identity on a torrent unless you join a server. Similarly, you need to join a Lemmy server to have an identity there, or anywhere on Lemmy. Unlike private torrent trackers, you only need 1 Lemmy identity, and you can subscribe to other servers' communities from your original server.
- TylerE 3y agoTorrents have magnet links, which don’t require servers at all.
- rf15 3y agoThat is untrue, you still need a server to facilitate discovery/passthrough. Peer-to-peer does not exist in the wider internet for most consumers.
- Strom 3y ago> you still need a server to facilitate discovery/passthrough You could just bruteforce IPv4 until you hit a peer that will give you a set of known peers.
- throwawaymobule 3y agoI don't think pex/dht operate on 'well known' ports. in fact, I think most clients are configured to randomize the port they use on each startup. most every client comes with a list of 'bootstrap peers' for dht though.
- Izkata 3y agoTrackerless torrents are very old now, they use the DHT network to find peers. I believe it needs to be seeded when you first start a newly installed client, but that's completely transparent to the user.
- mistercheph 3y agoThis is not about an IPO or infinite user growth potential in the next quarter. If we want to build a better world, some people must be left behind.
- NeuNeurosis 3y agoIf you leave too many people behind you aren't building a better world, you're building a walled garden.
- mistercheph 3y agoProgress is not linear. Young communities should and do alienate low effort and disinterested parties from participating while allowing anyone sufficiently interested to participate. We will find out if federated communities work because people will try to make them work in good faith, and if the core idea is good, it will be made universally applicable. The digital soldiers that thanklessly represent the technological status quo will always concern troll anything that isn't made by one of four companies for being insufficiently popular. Their input, like all the clamors of old-guard clingers-on will wash away, and they will be left with the basement full of floppy drives they thought would last forever. And the world will continue to turn and normal people will en-masse use technology that was once dismissed as having "too much sign-up flow friction" or "cognitive load" by patagonia wearing matcha sippers: people that will fall out from the world's grace just as quickly as they entered it.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> If we want to build a better world, some people must be left behind. This has to be parody.
- rakoo 3y ago> benefit from the product and gain an incentive > An infintessimal fraction of users care about philosophy or architecture [...] Users came for their cat pics. Give them their cat pics. Pitch them on the back end afterwards. I'm afraid you don't understand the concept of the fediverse. The philosophy is the point. Making reddit2 is completely useless. This is not a product, it's a vision of how we manage communications as a society. It implies involvement, because in a democracy you are part of the decision process, and you act as a community. Your egocentric, utilitarian, self-obsessed mindset is the complete opposite. I can't be really surprised to see this on hn, but oh well.
- fnovd 3y agoIf the philosophy is the point, it's a dead platform. Utopian ideals are fine, if that's your thing. Shaming people who don't share them is just rude. I don't see how you can compare the platform to the democratic process and not expect the same warts you see in democracies. A few people care a lot, some people care a bit, most people barely care at all. Grandstanding will never change that.
- rakoo 3y agoI've said it in a sibling post, but I don't believe our political systems are perfect models of democracy but are closer to benevolent dictatorships. It's comfortable, but that's not xhat the fediverse is about. There are plenty of centralized platforms with exactly the same problems as reddit, the fediverse is about building something else.
- fnovd 3y agoIf there are no successful, extant examples, then I don't think it's a good basis for anything. As I said, it's a Utopian ideal. That's fine, but it's not practical (and it's not trying to be). I think there are going to be incredibly valuable lessons-learned from these federated models, and interesting things will happen there. However, all of that will be capitalized by a nimble, forward-thinking, idealistic-yet-centralized model that gets rid of all the ideological cruft and polishes a real, useful, and engaging product.
- kristopolous 3y agoIsn't this the same problem IRC had but IRC was (still is?) fairly widely used? (Wikipedia says its peak was about 10mil in 2004/2005 - which makes it 1% according to here: https://www.internetworldstats.com/emarketing.htm https://www.internetworldstats.com/emarketing.htm) Regardless, if I was able to capture 1% of the net, that's not a failure by any stretch. How did IRC succeed here? Have any hard evidence as opposed to intuition or speculation?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> what's different? IRC, like e-mail, is grandfathered in. There wasn't a centralized alternative that worked when they were born.
- kristopolous 3y agoICQ? AIM? AOL chat rooms? I think there were many options at the time. Maybe the DCC transfer and easy scriptabilty thanks to Khaled Mardam-Bey's mIRC might be a valid claim. Perhaps also the impermanence of the history of the channels afforded certain types of interactions that you wouldn't do with you know, theoretically forever scrollbacks. I guess this brings us back to classical marketing about how you can't have a sustainable differentiated product based on negatives. (as in, this is not the bad guy). You need to have something in the affirmative
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> ICQ? AIM? AOL chat rooms? 1988 versus 1996 and 1997, respectively. AOL proper was an IRC competitor, as was CompuServe, but their definitions of working weren't different from IRC's.
- kristopolous 3y agoThat's not a useful comparison. The fact that IRC existed in 1988 does not bring a user onboard in 2004. That same argument didn't save WAIS, Fido, or Gopher. Nor did it keep Tymnet or Bitnet around and didn't give Compuserve and The Well a seat at the winners table. It also wasn't a saving grace for Friendster, MySpace, or LiveJournal. Magnavox putting out the first home gaming console in 1972 hasn't made them a gaming juggernaut nor does Xerox run the desktop. Neither Palm, Go or IBM makes my smartphone nor is my laptop by Grid Compass, desktop by MITS, spreadsheet by VisiOn or my pants from Arnold Constable. I don't fly Western Air Express, drive a Rickett, subscribe to RealNetworks Rhapsody for music nor am I posting this on slashdot.org. Citing an early creation date is a survivorship fallacy here. The real question here is why didn't it die like everything else. Why is it one of the few legacy survivors?
- sharperguy 3y agoNice thing about nostr is your account isn't tied to a server. The servers are just relays, and your messages are authenticated via pgp key. So your client will present you with a default set of servers, and if you need to change it later you don't need to recreate an account to do so, just tweak a setting. The nostr community right now mostly want to replace twitter rather than reddit, but in principle it would be possible.
- leesalminen 3y agoI’ve been thinking about the “relays as subreddits” paradigm for nostr. It could work.
- jasode 3y ago>It suffers from the same problem as Mastodon - "Join a server". But which one? [...] USENET had that problem solved. It was federated, but it didn't look federated to the end user. USENET also had the "chose the wrong server" problem. If I chose my ISP (e.g. Verizon) as my USENET entry point, then I would miss out on many newsgroups that Verizon didn't have. Or, Verizon had the newsgroup but had extremely short retention of old messages history. So, I paid $12.99/month for GigaNews to get all the newsgroups with months-to-years retention. Lemmy/Mastodon/etc replicate the same federation issues as USENET because running servers costs money and different people have different thresholds of spending. This independence/freedom of the admin running the server the particular way they want is touted as a positive but it also has inherent disadvantages. The contemporary situation of Beehaw instance defederating lemmy.world -- is replaying the same tradeoffs that USENET went through. (E.g. similar to an ISP's USENET service choosing not to carry alt.binaries.* or whatever.) Beehaw explains they have limited resources and can't handle the influx from lemmy.world. Yep. Very understandable.
- Accujack 3y agoThis is actually as designed, and is a good thing. It creates the possibility for a business model where subscribers pay for access to a big news spool and lots of groups. Just like USENet. There will be some growing pains, but there will eventually be a continuum of "free" lemmy servers, for pay premium ones, and lemmy servers where the front end is only an app on your phone. And they'll all see the same messages.
- jasode 3y ago>And they'll all see the same messages. I think you should re-evaluate that assumption: https://www.google.com/search?q=mastodon+instances+blocks+gab https://www.google.com/search?q=mastodon+instances+blocks+ga... https://www.google.com/search?q=mastodon+blocklists https://www.google.com/search?q=mastodon+blocklists https://www.google.com/search?q=mastodon+blacklists https://www.google.com/search?q=mastodon+blacklists https://www.reddit.com/r/Mastodon/comments/kw8jht/how_do_i_see_what_a_given_instance_has_blacklisted/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Mastodon/comments/kw8jht/how_do_i_s... Also, expand the ">Moderated servers" heading and scroll down through the instances they block: https://mastodon.social/about#unavailable-content https://mastodon.social/about#unavailable-content Why do different Mastodon instances decide on not federating some of the other instances?!? It's because the owners pay money for running their particular server which makes them feel entitled to run it the way they want. The "pick any server, it doesn't make any difference, you'll see _all_ messages anyway" -- is not realistic given that each fediverse node administrator can exercise their freedom to choose what messages their server accepts.
- 6510 3y agoOr to put it more generally, you have to look at your product or tool from the perspective of the laziest dumbest most unreasonable kind of people you want as the audience. You are not to complaint about how lazy they are, how dumb or how unreasonable, there are thousands just like them - shut up and do your job :-) The mega pun is that if you are hard working, intelligent and reasonable this is going to be incredibly hard for you. You are going to need help from someone who is non of those things.
- slowmovintarget 3y agoAnd woe unto you if you join in the wrong place. I had to look up what the term "tankie" meant.
- silverbax88 3y agoAgree with this. When I first hit Mastodon and Lemmy, I was hit with 'Join a server'. OK, but I want to at least start with one that's a 'main'server before I jump somewhere else. I can always splinter off later. Now that I've been on Mastodon and Lemmy, it makes more sense, but this is a HUGE barrier to adoption.
- leokennis 3y agoSo well said. After the Twitter apocalypse I joined Mastodon, but the instance I joined (mastodon.world) was missing a lot of people that did advertise they were on Mastodon… So I clicked some links from those people and managed to follow them. But I cannot just search for people or topics now? I first need a link to another instance? What is this, a second job?
- FormerBandmate 3y agoTruth Social is the most successful Mastodon instance by far despite being garbage because it has a clear, consistent design and user interface, and has exclusive content from an extremely popular influencer. Any Mastodon or Lemmy instance that wants to truly replace Reddit needs that, Gmail doesn’t present itself as a federated messaging platform and make you jump through 30 hoops to join while having arbitrary management that bans at random
- marcod 3y ago> These federated things need to be set up so that there's "no wrong door" I would argue they are. Any of the servers will work fine. There needs to be a paradigm shift that only things that are centrally managed and have a profit motive are good.
- silon42 3y agoMultiple servers... Even on reddit I'd want a separate user for separate groups of subreddits... (at least for posting, for reading it could work as you describe, probably client could authenticate at one server, but connect to others to get the data). Just make sure that the client can support this cleanly/efficiently.