4 ms·
It's not really like HN though, YCombinator may be voluntarily providing the service and us users are voluntarily providing the content. The difference with a
by jiggy2011 15y ago
It's not really like HN though, YCombinator may be voluntarily providing the service and us users are voluntarily providing the content.
The difference with a torrent download (in many cases at least) is that the author is not voluntarily sharing it with you so they're not really offering it. Somebody else may be voluntarily sharing their bandwidth with you but that's about it.
- icebraining 15y agoThe owner of the copy is voluntarily sharing it with me. The author may not be, but then again when Renault sold me a car, they don't get to tell me who I can share it with.
- jiggy2011 15y agoThese arguments on here are starting to feel like a broken record. It's more like you lend your car to a friend under certain conditions (such as not relending) and find that they have in fact re-lent it to their friend who has in turn re-lent it to someone else who re-lent it to someone who decided to melt it down and sell it for scrap.
- icebraining 15y agoLend? No, it's a sale. RIAA and MPAA themselves say so, and so do my receipts.
- jiggy2011 15y agoYou might buy the physical object (say a CD/DVD) but in most cases you only license the works contained on it.
- icebraining 15y agoTell that to WMG: http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/sister-sledge-files-class-action-286903 http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/sister-sledge-files...
- Pheter 15y agoPutting analogies aside, as everyone seems to focus on the analogy rather than the actual topic: Person A made something and is granting access to their creation subject to certain conditions. Person B finds a way to access the creation while circumventing the creators conditions. This is clearly wrong.
- icebraining 15y agoSome conditions are abusive. Try selling a non-perishable product in the EU with the condition that you provide less than two years of warranty and you can have a court telling you that. Of course, this particular conditions are legal, but that doesn't mean they're not abusive too.
- Pheter 15y agoIf you don't like the conditions then you can decline and not have access to the creation.
- icebraining 15y agoAnd if they don't want me to share the content they can not sell it to me.
- Pheter 15y agoWhy do you think it's okay to lie in this situation?
- icebraining 15y agoLie? I didn't lie. They never asked me.
- Pheter 15y agoI might have misunderstood you. Do you mean that if they don't want you to share the content then they shouldn't sell it to you, because you will share it regardless of what the terms of the sale dictate?