3 ms·
> but the government also has no place passing legislation against or “regulating” that. Banning recommendations would probably be fairly excessive, at least i
by rsynnott 3y ago
> but the government also has no place passing legislation against or “regulating” that.
Banning recommendations would probably be fairly excessive, at least if the recommendation is consensual (that is, if the site has the user's informed consent to profile them for recommendation purposes). However, it would arguably be pretty reasonable, and in line with how, say, 'native' advertising is generally treated, to require sites to include a warning to the effect that this is a machine recommendation which is vulnerable to manipulation.
As is, users may read recommendations as "this is what my friends are watching" or "this is what a human has chosen as recommendations for everyone", whereas in fact they are generally "this is the platform's attempt at maximising the ad revenue they can squeeze out of me, but also it may have been manipulated by malicious actors and the platform knows that". This should probably be made clearer to users.
- SllX 3y agoIs that really the case though? I think most people do understand that it is largely a non-human automated process that figures out what to show them. I asked someone else what the labeling really gets you, but your argument seems to be that the transparency is an end in and of itself. So what about just a general disclosure that this service relies on automated recommendations?