3 ms·
Long tail/"short tail" paradigm is about the distribution of purchases/views/streams etc. A statistical property, not about mere quantity. So not about whether
by coldtea 3y ago
Long tail/"short tail" paradigm is about the distribution of purchases/views/streams etc. A statistical property, not about mere quantity.
So not about whether there were 530 TV shows that were increased to 2,108, but whether the distribution of watching is wider or more like a power law.
- majormajor 3y ago> Long tail/"short tail" paradigm was about the distribution of purchases/views/streams etc. A statistical property, not about mere quantity. The author doesn't provide any evidence that the decades-long trend of "more options = broader distributed viewership" has broken, and the person you're replying to has shown that the "more options" trend is largely continuing. The author is cherry-picking also-not-relative-distribution numbers from a relatively small time frame and extrapolating wildly. Let's look at the longer timeframe. From Wikipedia for I Love Lucy: "The episode "Lucy Goes to the Hospital", which first aired on Monday, January 19, 1953, garnered a then-record rating of 71.7, meaning that 71.7% of all households with television sets were tuned to the program, the equivalent of some 44 million viewers.[71] That record is surpassed only by Elvis Presley's first of three appearances on The Ed Sullivan Show, which aired on September 9, 1956 (82.6% share, 60.710 million viewers and a 57.1 rating ).[71] The overall rating of 67.3 for the entire 1952 season of I Love Lucy continues to be the highest average rating for any single season of a TV show.[72]" MASH: "The series premiered in the US on September 17, 1972, and ended on February 28, 1983, with the finale, showcased as a television film, titled "Goodbye, Farewell and Amen", becoming the most-watched and highest-rated single television episode in US television history at the time, with a record-breaking 125 million viewers (60.2 rating and 77 share)" By the time we get to something like Friends we're down to 52M live viewers for its finale, and it's only shrunk since then. Netflix doesn't give equivalent counts or US-only ones, as far as I can find, just "at least two minutes within N weeks" type stuff and similar; I believe if they had that level of cultural ubiquity, they'd be shouting it to the rooftops more explicitly. And if they did, the linked article would be citing it. But instead, they're just speculating that all the numbers and trends we do have better measured are wrong. If you look at ticket sales counts instead of box office for movies you'll see a similar large representation of older stuff, and that's a quantity comparison even with a smaller population to boot .
- potatolicious 3y agoBut this is pretty observably true - TV viewership spread is wider than ever before. Remember that we started with a ~dozen TV networks showing one show at a time. The concentrating effect was so immense that the viewership numbers from the 70s and 80s have never been surpassed. Take a list of the highest-viewed programs of all-time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_watched_television_broadcasts_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_watched_televisio... The only modern programs that even rank is literally the Super Bowl. The last shows to break 100mm viewers was in 1977 and 1983. For primetime programming things peaked in the 80s with the Cosby Show, with ~30m households tuning in every single night for a single TV show. Viewership of linear broadcast programs has been on a slow downwards slide since. And that's not because people are watching less programming overall - but because they're now watching a vast array of other programs, including non-traditional programming like YouTube. The tail has never been longer. Not only can you find a much wider variety of content than ever before, but the long tail is immensely popular! People are making a living doing shows with a few tens of thousands of fans, and major high-profile, high-budget productions get nowhere close to the viewership from TV's heyday (Succession's finale had ~3m viewers!) because the distribution of viewership is so much wider than before!
- rufus_foreman 3y ago>> Remember that we started with a ~dozen TV networks showing one show at a time Lol, a dozen? There were ABC, NBC and CBS that might (or might not) have all been available in your area. Plus PBS if you counted that. I didn't like Masterpiece Theatre, so just 3 for me. The largest cities might have had a few independent channels (not networks), but for most of the country, that was it.
- bryanrasmussen 3y ago>Long tail/"short tail" paradigm is about the distribution of purchases/views/streams etc. A statistical property, not about mere quantity. not exactly, it is also about narrowing of people's interests based on the wider range of opportunities. If the wider range of opportunities means that the people can now stop wasting their time on Sexy nurse stories and Voracious Space Aliens by narrowing in on their true interests - Sexy Nurses that marry voracious space aliens to exclusion of other stories - but if instead what happens is a wider range of media being consumed without narrowing in on very specific sub categories then what has happened is not a long tail but simply consumers expanding their range of choice. Both of these phenomena - long tail and expansion of choice would lead to limits of viewership because there is in either case more media fighting over the viewership but while the result is pretty much the same the causes are slightly different.