3 ms·
The danger of delegating education to journalists (2012)
- graycat 3y agoIt took me a LONG time to accept what journalism actually is. For "The danger of delegating education to journalists", NAW. It's okay. Not entirely joking, we already do that! It's a standard part of nearly all colleges and universities. It's usually called the Drama Department, in particular where the subject is writing fiction. Or, "How to grab your audience by the heart, the gut, and below the belt, always below the shoulders, never between the ears." The "long time" was because I had a tough time believing that journalism would replace good information with just emotion, replace documentation of events with drama about the people involved in the events. This post is partly parody, but not all. Yup, I'm beyond merely frustrated and outraged at nearly all of journalism. For the Hacker News audience, there is maybe an upside: Due to current desktop computer hardware, operating system and applications software, one person with just a coaxial cable connection to the Internet and a business account (so that can receive connections) can bring up a Web site with another approach to journalism. Gee, just yesterday noticed that Patreon has their relationship with 250,000 "creators", say, Web sites. Some of those sites can be new approaches to journalism. I'm guessing that one result will be, call it, a fragmentation of media/journalism.
- trabant00 3y agoWhile I think journalism has a lot of issues this is not one of them. How a layman journalist could parse a scientific paper and compress it for a wide audience without giving some false impressions I can not imagine. "The devil is in the details" in a inescapable law. For reporting on science the trouble is with the readers, not the papers. People want to draw conclusions applicable to their lives, or at least for having the upper hand in an argument. These studies are narrow in scope by necessity and are observations rather than predictions or prescriptions. The reality is that most studies like this can not be used as self improvement guides. Not the ones about achieving mastery in your field, not the ones about mental health, nutrition, exercise and so on. But then why would people bother to read about them? The human mind is on the lookout for shortcuts, the elixir of eternal youth, happiness , love is as in high demand as it always has been. Hundreds of years ago these where presented as vials of exotic substances. Now we're rational and educated, we want the elixirs presented as science bits. So what's a journalist to do? He too has to pay for rent and food.
- dsign 3y agoI think the fault lays with the journalist, if they are the ones creating the faulty product. But, without the journalist, the public would have to learn to read scientific papers on their own, which they probably wouldn't do even if their life depended on it. So this battle can not be won in our current society.
- trabant00 3y agoThe public can not learn to read scientific papers, no matter how much they would want to. You have to be on par with the person who wrote the study, in their field, to really be able to judge it. The chain should be, take for example nutrition, something like: study - skeptic science community - trials - health administration - policy - personal doctors - public, with constant feedback between the links. You still have leaky abstractions at every level but the positions are (or should be) equipped to handle it. Study -> news -> public, or study -> public is an impossible chain. That's how you get all the fad diets, covid home-made remedies and so on.