4 ms·
Anyone else worried that Vision Pro will simply be a large iPad and not macOS like, ie closed app store and not geared towards productivity? The fact that to ru
by satvikpendem 3y ago
Anyone else worried that Vision Pro will simply be a large iPad and not macOS like, ie closed app store and not geared towards productivity? The fact that to run VSCode you need to mirror your own Mac simply boggles the mind, it's like Apple wants to cut off the potential of the device at the knees simply to continue selling services.
- drcode 3y agoWhen Apple says "Pro", they mean you get to hang around with a couple of marketing people pointing at PowerPoint slides You thought they meant actual apps that professional people use, like VSCode?
- ohgodplsno 3y agoWhy worry ? It's already guaranteed to be the case. Apps will not have direct access to the cameras, meaning that the Vision Pro is destined to keep being a toy fully steered by Apple. You also cannot access any depth information, or anything that would make it useful as a general 3D computing device. You can't access eye tracking, so say good bye to foveated rendering. And since you can't have foveated rendering, well you're now rendering 2x 4k images on a relatively underpowered device.
- ladberg 3y agoFoveated rendering is supported by default. Most apps will rely on the OS's renderer and not their own so they don't have to do anything with eye tracking to have it enabled. EDIT: See cma's comment below which adds more info: apps that use their own render still support foveated rendering too.
- ohgodplsno 3y agoExactly. If you want to do anything without going through Apple's benediction, you're shit out of luck. It's one more episode in the war on general computing, except somehow it's okay when Apple restricts what you can do with your three thousand five hundred dollar ski goggles.
- toasterrepair 3y agoIt's okay for the general user.
- zgluck 3y agoYeah. To state the obvious: Apps will no longer run full screen; they will run as a 2D window in a 3D space. When Apple allows it the user will be able to ask the app to go full 3D (well, hopefully). All of this is: Apple taking further control of the experience.
- kitsunesoba 3y agoTo me it seems like less of a war on general computing and more like Apple is hoping to prevent mixed reality or "spatial computing" from becoming an extension on the privacy disaster that smartphones became. This seems prudent, because as personal as smartphones are, a headset like the Vision Pro dials that up tenfold. Considering what third parties have done with just the information surfaced in mobile operating systems, or heck even the web, I shudder to think of what they'd do with gaze data and a high fidelity color 3D map of your surroundings.
- archagon 3y agoThat’s great for the general case, but it should be also possible for a user to do whatever they want with their own hardware.
- kitsunesoba 3y agoIf there's a way to accomplish this without opening headset users into being easily socially engineered into figuratively selling the farm, sure. In this particular case I think perhaps a better approach would be to allow apps to bypass App Store restrictions so long as their source code is public and binaries match that code. This would naturally deter those with shady intentions, allow FOSS projects to thrive, allow both manual and automated third party vetting of apps, and help users better know what they're getting into.
- cma 3y agoFoveated is available on native renderers/custom engines too: (source: "Discover Metal for immersive apps - WWDC23 - Videos - Apple Developer " https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2023/10089/ https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2023/10089/) If they try to hide it by restricting access to reading the foveation texture, you can be sure anti privacy apps like Immersive Facebook will try tricks like recovering it from GPU timestamp queries (render two transparent triangles covering the screen in separate draw calls, find which took the longest, subdivide and repeat).
- krger 3y ago>Apps will not have direct access to the cameras A restriction for which I am thankful. >Vision Pro is destined to keep being a toy fully steered by Apple. I trust Apple a lot more than I trust the "let's figure out how to fingerprint users based on how they scroll and other metrics and use it to sell ads" crowd. >You can't access eye tracking, A restriction for which I am thankful. >so say good bye to foveated rendering. Vision Pro does foveated rendering.
- ohgodplsno 3y agoYes, yes, we know some Apple users are unable to see past the "you can't be trusted" that Apple keeps violently stabbing in your brain, you'll live in a company town with company stores and company credits and you'll be happy about it. Now can the adults use their devices? The Vision Pro does not provide foveated rendering if you do not go through the Apple renderer. There's some extremely vague wording regarding Metal supporting it, without any API documentation out.
- krger 3y ago>Yes, yes, we know some Apple users are unable to see past the "you can't be trusted" that Apple keeps violently stabbing in your brain, you'll live in a company town with company stores and company credits and you'll be happy about it. Apple isn't telling me that I can't be trusted. Apple is telling me that it's a stupid idea to trust third-party developers with unfettered access to my data, and they're not even a little bit wrong. This has been happening at least since the "Foursquare is uploading and storing every user's contacts" fiasco well over a decade ago. > Now can the adults use their devices? Of course. Feel free to bring to market your wonderful headset that allows VC-funded startups to create a never-ending torrent of privacy hellscape diarrhea apps you can enjoy until they implode. >The Vision Pro does not provide foveated rendering if you do not go through the Apple renderer. There's some extremely vague wording regarding Metal supporting it, without any API documentation out. That's because the API has yet to be released to developers. Perhaps you can wait until it is to get your mouth all frothy, sunshine.
- 3y ago
- thebigman433 3y ago> Apps will not have direct access to the cameras Is there any headset that does allow this currently? Doesnt seem like any kind of differentiating factor
- ohgodplsno 3y agoEvery single headset in the world that has cameras. The HoloLens, anything that uses OpenXR and OpenVR (so, pretty much 100% of the current PCVR market), hell even the Quest has a Passthrough API. The Vision Pro is pretty much the only one that doesn't, because Apple thinks of their users as children.
- thebigman433 3y agoA passthrough API, but you absolutely do not get access to the headset cameras on any of those devices. Apple is very much in line with the standard here, you can make passthrough apps, but you cannot actually get the real data from the cameras.
- ladberg 3y agoYou can do VSCode Remote in a browser on an iPad so I'm not too worried. I think the bigger factor is that Apple is trying to push this as more of a workplace productivity machine than the iPad, so third party developers will hopefully be more amenable to porting those types of apps than they were to iPadOS.
- satvikpendem 3y ago> You can do VSCode Remote in a browser on an iPad I'm sorry but that's exactly the problem, I want the app natively (well, as native as you can get with Electron), executing code that I have on my file system. I don't want to execute remotely through a browser.
- bee_rider 3y agoYour requirements seem pretty specific, it might just not be the device for you.
- satvikpendem 3y agoHow is it "pretty specific?" Any developer is running code locally (unless you work for Google or some company where they have remote codespaces). Why should I not want a headset that instead serves as a replacement for a laptop?
- drewbeck 3y agoYou can want whatever you want. It’s not a failure of apple that they don’t serve your specific need, however. They just built a product for different people.
- satvikpendem 3y agoSure, that's fine. At the same time I can still call it a shame that they would have to do such artificial limiting. I'll more likely pick up the Android or Windows version of such a device without restrictions on what kinds of software I can run on my own hardware.
- drewbeck 3y ago> not geared towards productivity? The fact that to run VSCode Productivity !== coding. Coding is a subset of productivity, but most jobs do not require coding. I get that you want this to be something else, but a lot of people are incredibly productive on iPads today, and adding the ability to mirror your MacBooks screen means that this platform absolutely has a future in productivity. HN has a lot of this attitude — “I can’t code directly on it so this is a toy” — and it’s always a laugh for me. There’s … other people? Who want to do other things?
- satvikpendem 3y agoThat's great for those people but yes, for devs, it's not a real replacement for a MacBook, even though it literally has the same chip inside. It's a shame.
- krger 3y ago>That's great for those people but yes, for devs, it's not a real replacement for a MacBook, even though it literally has the same chip inside. Good thing Apple isn't marketing it as a replacement for a MacBook then.
- satvikpendem 3y agoOf course it isn't, they want you to buy a MacBook alongside, that's my entire point. They are artificially restricting one device in order to make you buy their other devices. It's the same story as the iPad, it also has the same chip as the Mac but they restrict apps like IDEs so people instead have to buy two devices. If it were a Surface-like product instead, with full macOS, I'd have bought an iPad in a heartbeat.
- krger 3y ago>Of course it isn't, they want you to buy a MacBook alongside, that's my entire point. Hardware company entices consumers to buy more hardware. Film at 11. >If it were a Surface-like product instead, with full macOS, I'd have bought an iPad in a heartbeat. Ah yes. The Surface, the device that showcases the appeal of running an OS designed for mouse/keyboard input with a thin veneer of touch support spackled on top. It's amazing Apple isn't sprinting to release a product along those lines.
- ConanRus 3y agoIt's the same concern I heard before the 1st Ipad announce: we want a MacOs on a tablet! No you don't. Coz MacOs apps knows nothing about the touch screen interface. And they know nothing about VR also, so nothing is changed here.
- satvikpendem 3y agoDo you realize that they all run the same kernel and OS underneath that's then restricted via feature flags? macOS can absolutely understand touch since it's all the same. This is also why their Continuity feature works so well, or why iOS apps can run natively on macOS.
- kitsunesoba 3y agoEven if it could run VS Code directly, VS Code would be at a disadvantage to other editors because native visionOS apps appear to use entirely vector UI and text to ensure sharpness and readability in a wider variety of conditions, which I don't see third party UI frameworks of any sort being able to hook into easily.
- satvikpendem 3y agoSomething is better than nothing.
- ladberg 3y agoI don't think web apps like VSCode will be at a disadvantage. If they're doing "normal" web rendering and not rolling their own canvas renderer like Google Docs then it should just work fine.
- kitsunesoba 3y agoIf they're running on top of the system WebKit yes, otherwise vector rendering will need to be implemented in Chromium/Blink.
- wkat4242 3y agoWell this is pretty clear to me, it's definitely running only iOS apps natively, I don't see why they would open the app store for it as it's a huge goldmine for them. Apple still thinks people can use an iPad for all their work though my experience at work is very different (and I managed a large fleet of mobiles)
- satvikpendem 3y agoIndeed, and it's a shame. I am looking forward to whatever is available on the Windows and Android side in the future, at least there I can run whatever software I want.