3 ms·
Doesn't support algebraic data types, though. FWIW I think this article mentioning them at all is sort of weird because the article doesn't propose them either
by LoganDark 3y ago
Doesn't support algebraic data types, though.
FWIW I think this article mentioning them at all is sort of weird because the article doesn't propose them either, lmao
- tikhonj 3y agoRight, the article talks about "type Point = Point1D | Point2D | Point3D" syntax at the end... which would work just as well with dataclasses as with structs!
- masklinn 3y agoIt already does too. Just remove the `type` bit and you have an alias for a union, which has been supported since typing was added (though the `|` syntax was only added in 3.10). And AFAIK the type checkers do handle completeness on unions.
- fritzo 3y agoDo you mean Python's lack of a labeled union type?
- Spivak 3y agoPydantic does though. class A(BaseModel): status: Literal["success"] class B(BaseModel): status: Literal["error"] class C(BaseModel, ABC): __root__: Union[A, B] = Field(discriminator="status") aorb = C.parse_obj(blah…).__root__ if aorb.status == "error": # aorb will type check as B.
- b33j0r 3y agoYou are a friend and a scholar. I was looking for a solution in pydantic that is wildly relevant. Thanks, I didn’t realize that was implemented/existed. My only objection is using ABC in your MRO. Haha, just a little bit overloaded with abstract base classes and using A, B, and C. I got it eventually! Cool.
- Spivak 3y agoYa know what, on reading that that does seem confusing. My brain had long since internalized ABC as a single token I didn't even notice.
- LoganDark 3y agoI believe this is a good example of type narrowing :)
- LoganDark 3y agoYeah. Been spoiled by Rust.
- contravariant 3y agoIt doesn't seem that far off though, it does have a union type and with pattern matching you can achieve pretty much the same thing (sure you may need a few extra classes if the types aren't distinct already but that seems like a small difference). I don't know if type checkers can figure out if a pattern match statement is exhaustive yet though, that would be interesting.
- joiguru 3y agoWhich Python 3.10 and static type checkers much of the benefits of algebraic data types is already available [1]. [1]: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/16258553/how-can-i-define-algebraic-data-types-in-python https://stackoverflow.com/questions/16258553/how-can-i-defin...
- masklinn 3y agoThe typed equivalent of a sum type in python is a union (https://docs.python.org/3/library/typing.html#typing.Union https://docs.python.org/3/library/typing.html#typing.Union). Works with pretty much every type you can think of, but has the usual union limitation that you can't have two variants of the same type (e.g. int | int | float). Then again, you can just create newtype wrappers, and that's essentially the same thing as different constructors for a sum type.
- LoganDark 3y agoYou'd need to create newtype wrappers anyway in order to tell them apart, I'd assume. Otherwise it wouldn't really be an algebraic data type as much as a... union type.
- masklinn 3y agoHence “equivalent”. Of your variants all have trivial and non-overlapping payloads you can just use them as-is, or erlang-style tagged tuples, in most cases it’ll do fine.