4 ms·
> I used to think that professional investors actually were a little smarter than the rest. It's been my experience that you can't tell who's smarter than who
by JohnFen 3y ago
> I used to think that professional investors actually were a little smarter than the rest.
It's been my experience that you can't tell who's smarter than who by what they do for a living. On the whole, no group is actually smarter than any other group.
> It's pretty sad that "look like you know what you are doing and convince gullible people" is probably the best future career advice I can give to my school-age daughter.
I don't agree with that takeaway. I think the takeaway is that confidence is the primary thing that people take as a proxy for competence. It's not really about gullibility as much as people engaging in a heuristic. So learn to fake confidence, but have the chops to back it up.
- kriro 3y agoI'd venture that professional concert piano players or chess professionals (just to pick two random ones that popped into my head) are on average more intelligent than other fields which I won't name. I suppose it depends on the definition of smart which I understand as intelligent/good rational decision making but maybe you mean somthing else.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoI think the point GP was trying to make was about individuals in the groups, not averages. There are some brilliant janitors, and some professional piano or chess players have had savant syndrome. You're unlikely to find unintelligent or savant biochemists, but I'm sure more than a few are hyperfocused on their discipline to the exclusion of competency in other areas.
- 8note 3y agoFor the uninitiated, what is a savant syndrome? What's it look like for a pianist vs a biochemist?
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoThink "Rain Man". Though only about half are autistic: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Savant_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Savant_syndrome Two pianists: Autistic savant syndrome: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derek_Paravicini https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derek_Paravicini https://www.ted.com/talks/derek_paravicini_and_adam_ockelford_in_the_key_of_genius https://www.ted.com/talks/derek_paravicini_and_adam_ockelfor... Acquired savant syndrome: https://www.cbsnews.com/colorado/news/derek-amato-acquired-savant-syndrome-piano/ https://www.cbsnews.com/colorado/news/derek-amato-acquired-s... I doubt a biochemist would have savant syndrome. It's possible, maybe. It would probably look like someone who could recall all of the enzymes (and their variants) and intermediates in various biosynthetic pathways and could tell you without research which enzymes would need to be expressed together to get from one starting chemical to another.
- pessimizer 3y ago> On the whole, no group is actually smarter than any other group. This is the law of averages. Almost never true.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoYou're ignoring GPs first sentence: "It's been my experience that you can't tell who's smarter than who by what they do for a living." This first sentence indicates that they are writing about individuals with a vocation, not a group average. Statistically, in developed countries, any given manual laborer is likely to be less smart than any given venture capitalist, but Elon Musk, for instance, has been both. If you'd randomly picked him, in December of 1989, from the pool of manual laborers, you would have been wrong.
- adrianmonk 3y ago> It's been my experience that you can't tell who's smarter than who by what they do for a living. On the whole, no group is actually smarter than any other group. I assumed they meant professional investors are smarter about evaluating potential investments. Not generally smarter, just smarter about what they put their money into.
- ryandrake 3y agoOP here. I guess rather than "smarter" I meant to convey: less gullible, less vulnerable to being influenced by silly signals like someone's mannerisms and confidence, less reliant on unexplainable gut feels. I guess when I think of professional investors picking some of these dogs, my mind imagines that scene in Moneyball[1] where the old timers are trying to pick baseball players by who "looks good," "has a good jaw," "how the ball sounds when it pops off his bat, and "what the player's girlfriend looks like." 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pWgyy_rlmag https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pWgyy_rlmag
- 8note 3y agoIsnt that shown to be not true by how effective indexes are? The smart money is to assume you won't beat the market
- adrianmonk 3y agoI don't know that that's proven. I think it has been shown that index mutual funds generally do as well as actively managed funds. One explanation is that the fund managers don't know better than anyone else. Another explanation is that the fund managers do know better, but their fees are so high that it cancels out the benefit of their expertise. That is, their expertise is real but overpriced. On a practical level, there's also the matter that, even if some fund managers do beat the market, some other fund managers don't, and it's hard to tell which is which. By going with an actively managed mutual fund, you take on "how do I know my fund manager is one of the good ones?" risk, which you don't have with index funds.
- deterministic 3y ago> It's been my experience that you can't tell who's smarter than who by what they do for a living. There are always exceptions of course. But it is most definitely true that (for example) the average IQ of people doing high end physics is way higher than the average IQ of people laying bricks.