3 ms·
Yes, there's a name for this, but I forget what it is. Being a beginner or a true expert are relatively safe. Beginners are aware of the limits of their knowle
by JohnFen 3y ago
Yes, there's a name for this, but I forget what it is.
Being a beginner or a true expert are relatively safe. Beginners are aware of the limits of their knowledge/skills. Likewise, true experts are aware of the limits of their knowledge/skills.
In between the two, though, people tend to think they understand more than they actually do.
And, of course, being a beginner, intermediate, or expert is topic-specific. You can be an expert in one things and a beginner in another at the same time.
- Benjammer 3y agoIt's along the same lines as Fred Brooks' "Second system effect," although not quite the same.
- astura 3y ago>Yes, there's a name for this, but I forget what it is. Resume Driven Development.
- hhh 3y agoBell curve moment
- 6D794163636F756 3y agoThis sounds like the Dunning Kruger effect
- JohnFen 3y agoDunning-Kruger is certainly a closely related effect, yes, but wasn't what I was thinking of.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 3y ago> name for this Sounds like "Advanced Beginner" https://daedtech.com/how-developers-stop-learning-rise-of-the-expert-beginner/ https://daedtech.com/how-developers-stop-learning-rise-of-th... "Expert Beginner" is the one who barely knows shit but convinces themselves they know everything and "Advanced Beginner" is the one who thinks they know just slightly more than they really do until their compiler gives them an error they didn't expect.
- B1FF_PSUVM 3y ago> a name for this The canny valley. Aka just learned enough to be dangerous.
- phkahler 3y ago>> You can be an expert in one things and a beginner in another at the same time. That's apparent or implied mastery. Psych friend says it happens all the time, executive type comes to therapy. He's a master at his business, has all sorts of industry experience, really knows his stuff, but then has trouble in say... personal relationships because he's absolutely clueless on those types of things. Mastery in one area does not imply it in another. So when you think "this person is really smart, why are they making xxx stupid decision?" just check if the reason you think they are smart is in any way related to the area of the stupid decision ;-)
- jchanimal 3y agoA complication is the skills curves overlap so while I was a dangerous intermediate at database design 15 years ago, now I am a dangerous intermediate at organization design.
- cratermoon 3y agoRichard Dreyfus came up with a Five-Stage Model of Adult Skills Acquisition. 1 Novice. Follows simple rules. Performance is poor. 2 Advanced beginner. Rules modified by context & situation. 3 Competence. Able to recognize more contextual elements than can be used. Ability to chose a perspective for analysis and prioritize features of the context. However, does poorly at choosing the right perspective. 4 Proficient. If detached rule-following is replaced by intentional learning, learns to use judgment and emotion in choosing perspectives. However, that judgement and emotion informs a decision still based on rules and maxims. 5 Expertise. Applies refined discriminatory perceptions to determine what must be done and what must happen to get there. Analysis and calculation are not necessary. It's stage 3, "does poorly at choosing the right perspective" and 4, "decision still based on rules and maxims" where problems arise. In Dreyfus' original paper, he considered learning in the context with feedback. BTW the paper is worth reading for Dreyfus' comments on feedforward simulated neural networks.
- memefrog 3y agoSounds like the 'bell curve'/'midwit' meme, which shows an IQ bell curve and three people: one on the left, one in the middle and one on the right. The left and right have the same view, and the middle has a (clearly worse, usually overcomplicated) view. Example: The dimwit just uses a simple notes app. The midwit uses an overengineered and elaborate note-taking system using flash cards, Anki, spaced repetition, etc. The midwit spends more time on his note-taking system than he does actually taking notes on anything. The expert realises that all of that bloat is unnecessary and that he is more effective just using a simple notes app. You can communicate all of this in one image: https://media.licdn.com/dms/image/C5622AQFrWvMGA7E7bA/feedshare-shrink_2048_1536/0/1674685713129?e=1689811200&v=beta&t=Ss4hqAzMuowSU3tNDt_oD3QYoI58YNMKKil1XmbXm1Q https://media.licdn.com/dms/image/C5622AQFrWvMGA7E7bA/feedsh... https://media.licdn.com/dms/image/C5622AQFrWvMGA7E7bA/feedshare-shrink_2048_1536/0/1674685713129?e=1689811200&v=beta&t=Ss4hqAzMuowSU3tNDt_oD3QYoI58YNMKKil1XmbXm1Q https://media.licdn.com/dms/image/C5622AQFrWvMGA7E7bA/feedsh...