3 ms·
Sorry I wasn't specific enough. I meant Texas's private, less regulated grid and the issues stemming from that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Texas_power_c
by solardev 3y ago
Sorry I wasn't specific enough. I meant Texas's private, less regulated grid and the issues stemming from that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Texas_power_crisis#%3A%7E%3Atext%3Ddeadly_winter_storm.-%2CLawsuits%2CAmerican_Electric_Power_utility_company.?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Texas_power_crisis#%3A%7E...
It's just funny that in the same country, two states suffer similar electrical outcomes despite polar opposite politics. Californians went all in on solar and their heavy regulated utility couldn't keep up, causing rolling blackouts and bankruptcies. Texas took a no shits given approach to their electric market and that backfired too, skyrocketing prices and killing hundreds.
I wonder how other countries deal with their grid upgrades. Judging by the GP's points, maybe not very well either?
- vel0city 3y ago> skyrocketing prices I just signed a contract a few days ago for 100% renewable $0.10/kWh including delivery for another year after coming off a 3-year contract for $0.08/kWh delivered. I don't know that I agree with "skyrocketing prices". Prices did increase the last couple of years with natural gas prices generally going sky high (I was seeing contracts ~$0.14-16/kWh for comparison), but prices have fallen again back to levels they were pre-Ukraine and pre-deep-freeze. Given most other things have inflated a good bit, real electricity prices in Texas are actually down compared to a few years ago. I wouldn't consider $0.10/kWh a "skyrocketing price". Average electricity prices in EU are supposedly €0.25/kWh which is what $0.27? 10 / 27 = .37, so my sky high electricity prices are a third of the average rate in Europe, so I guess theirs are considered astronomical? What are you paying for your electricity? https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Electricity_price_statistics https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php... Had the majority of resistive heating sources converted to heat pumps before the deep freeze, it possibly wouldn't have happened as it would have greatly reduced the electricity demand. Also, if things like gas compressors and other gas infrastructure was properly tagged as critical infrastructure Texas wouldn't have shot itself in the foot turning off those circuits causing cascading gas power plaint failures.
- solardev 3y agoThe skyrocketing during the freeze, I mean, because of supply and demand. And to your point, 10 cents is pretty low. California is up to what, 29 cents a kWh? I pay around 12 in Oregon, 6 in Chicago before that thanks to nuclear.
- vel0city 3y ago> The skyrocketing during the freeze, I mean I paid $0.08/kWh during the freeze. Very, very, very few people were on spot pricing plans. Like maybe a few thousand out of 10 million households. Griddy had a peak of 29,000 customers. They were urging customers to leave like a week or more before the freeze, so chances are they weren't still at 29,000. Even then, that's like 0.2% of households in Texas.
- solardev 3y agoThat's good to know. The media painted a very different picture. I should've known better :)
- vel0city 3y agoDon't get me wrong, there's still some amount of concerns about some of these charges. There are a lot of complicated things going on there, a number of court cases, and there's definitely a mixture of things going on. I was buying electricity through a retail electric provider (REP) who ended up folding and selling my contract to a new REP after the freeze so I and everyone else with a fixed contract in the deregulated areas had practically zero impact, maybe slightly higher delivery charges. Other people are on co-ops, and they might have to have some extra payments in their bills spread over a few years to cover the costs (depending on some court cases) or have their co-ops get pretty heavily restructured. Then there are some municipal electric companies who were often mixed, as sometimes those had generating capacity (so if those stayed online they received these huge payments or balanced out) and sometimes they didn't. But those people showing their $20,000 home electric bills? Far outliers, way outside the norm. They had signed up specifically for spot price energy plans without realizing what that really meant. I do imagine a number of people probably really didn't understand their plans, as its really easy to change plans and Griddy did a lot of direct selling. https://www.texastribune.org/2023/03/17/puc-appeals-court-uri-prices/ https://www.texastribune.org/2023/03/17/puc-appeals-court-ur... For a lot of people though there was confusion related to energy prices increasing after the freeze, which was correlated but not necessarily caused from the freeze. Global gas prices shot sky high, a lot of LNG capacity was added for export, a huge amount of Texas electricity is from gas, so electricity prices increased around that same time. Not necessarily from the freeze though, but most people weren't paying attention to the natural gas prices.