5 ms·
> (1+1/x)^x limited to infinity is the definition of e This shouldn’t be “memorized” as a “fact” though. As you point out, it’s the very definition of e. Which
by jacobolus 15y ago
> (1+1/x)^x limited to infinity is the definition of e
This shouldn’t be “memorized” as a “fact” though. As you point out, it’s the very definition of e. Which is to say, to really understand what the exponential function means implies building up a mental model about lim [n→∞] (1 + x/n)^n and its behavior, interacting with it, connecting it to other functions, seeing what happens when you combine it with other ideas: trying to integrate/differentiate it; noticing how it reacts to fourier transform; relating it to rotations, areas, imaginary numbers; writing it as a taylor expansion or continued fraction, or with a functional equation, or as the solution to a differential equation. Connecting it to derived functions such as e.g. the normal distribution, or sine, or hyperbolic sine. Generalizing it to an operation on complex numbers, or quaternions, or matrices. Thinking about what exponentiation in general really means. Coming up with algorithms for computing e’s decimal expansion or proving that e is irrational and transcendental. Solving problems with it, like to start with, continuously compounded interest (&c. &c. &c.).
No one who had really learned about exponentials in a deep way would easily forget that this is the definition of e, and that has nothing to do with lists of facts or rote memorization.
> Single-character symbols (and multiple character symbols) that not only hide tons of meaning through a dereference, which is naturally how language works, that also suggest a meaning themselves, are stupid and promote natural diseased human thinking.
I think you should try writing out some very difficult complex math proofs before you make this assertion (say, for instance, a proof . Things are bad enough when we pack ideas down. Start expanding them in the middle of the computation, and it the steps become almost impossible to see or reason about.
The whole point of assigning things short simple names is that it gives a clear analogy (to past experience w/ the conventions) that provide a shortcut to anticipating how particular types of structures and operations behave. Cramming a matrix or a multivariate function or an operator down into a single symbol helps us to treat that symbol as a black box for the purpose of the proof or problem, which helps us bring our existing mathematical tools and understandings to bear. Sometimes, we run afoul of false impressions, as when we apply intuition about the real numbers to matrices in ways that don’t quite apply, or intuition about metric spaces to general topological spaces, &c. But this is I think an unavoidable cost, and it’s why we strive to be careful and precise in making mathematical arguments.
- TeMPOraL 15y agoSingle symbols are ok, but why do they have to be denoted by a single letter? There's a reason why using single-letter (or two, or three-letter) variables is discouraged in programming in favour of longer, descriptive names. It's to avoid the moments in which you start wondering, in the middle of reading a function, 'why q has to be greater than k-1? And what the hell is this Q(p) anyway?'. I really don't understand why both math and physics are so into one-character symbols. Even the OP's Bayes theorem example shows that it's easier to read a formula, when the symbol names self-evaluate to their meaning.
- crntaylor 15y agoA lot of the time when doing math, you literally don't want to know what a particular symbol stands for - you just want to manipulate the symbols abstractly. Too much interpretation can interfere with the process of pattern recognition that is essential for doing mathematics well. You also see this in programming whenever someone writes public interface List<T> { ... } in Java, or when you write Tree a = Empty | Branch a (Tree a) (Tree a) in Haskell. It doesn't matter what 'T' and 'a' are, so we use short, one-character representations for them. The fact that you can write Bayes rule as P(A|B) = P(A)P(B|A)/P(B) (where I've even used a zero-character representation for the background information!) expresses the fact that A and B can be arbitrary events, and don't need to have any connection to hypotheses, models or data. It just happens one of the applications of Bayes rule is in fitting scientific hypotheses to data. This question at math.stackexchange.com goes into a little more detail: http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/24241/why-do-mathematicians-use-single-letter-variables http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/24241/why-do-mathema...
- TeMPOraL 15y agoOk, this is a good reason, though I'm don't think it covers all the use cases, in particular on the borderline between math and physics. But yes, I can see how in programming, knowing what the variable really represents is usually helpful, while in math might usually be not. Thanks for the link, there are some good thoughts there.
- deleted 15y ago