4 ms·
Invest in what instead of heat pumps? It's hard to understand what you're pushing for. Resistive electric heat (which would be less efficient and have a higher
by solardev 3y ago
Invest in what instead of heat pumps? It's hard to understand what you're pushing for. Resistive electric heat (which would be less efficient and have a higher load on the grid, and your power bill too)? Non electrical heating (fossil fuels)?
In the US there isn't a concerted push to disinvest in the grid for the heat pump lobby's sake. Our grid is old and frail and Texas is insane and California has way too much solar and not enough storage, but heat pumps aren't really a major factor there.
And overall, isn't higher efficiency good for everyone (for costs, climate, noise) even if we do upgrade power grids and production? It shouldn't be an either/or but both.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoInvest in the grid and electricity production so that the many people for whom heat pumps are not a practical option have an affordable solution. France used to push for all electric at home, with resistive electric heat because they had plenty of affordable electricity. I'm sure it's the same in countries with plenty of hydro. Now, here in the UK the grid is already maxed out. Renewable projects cannot go forward because they cannot connect to the grid. So the government is desperate, taking into account the bloodbath that's coming with EVs and that they want us to get rid of our gas boilers as well. Heat pumps minimise impact on grid and push a lot of the cost to people. I'm not saying that heat pumps should not be installed where a good fit, but in the real world there aren't in many situations and for many families's budgets. It's never black and white.
- notacoward 3y ago> Now, here in the UK the grid is already maxed out. A maxed-out grid is an argument in favor of heat pumps, since they're more efficient than resistive - especially at the temperatures that prevail in the UK.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoYes, except that they are impractical and unaffordable for many, and that the grid just be upgraded anyway (EVs, etc), as I wrote in all my comments. I am just saying that heat pumps are no panacea and are not always a practical/viable option so let's not create another sacred cow here.
- notacoward 3y ago> they are impractical and unaffordable for many If you're not going to provide any evidence, please stop making that claim. Heat pumps are not bulkier, noisier, or more expensive than any alternative that would suffice for most people. They are more efficient and environmentally benign, likewise. Using dogwhistles like "sacred cow" or insulting interlocutors is not going to carry the day for you.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoPlease be civil or "have a good day".
- notacoward 3y agoPlease take your own advice. Your reliance on fallacies, falsehoods, and repetition is toxic to civil discourse, and that's before we even get to the explicit accusation that everyone who disagrees with you has tunnel vision. Tone policing never works when it comes from the worst offender.
- vel0city 3y agoFunny you mention Texas, as these days 60% of Texans currently heat their homes from electric (almost always resistive) sources. If we shifted all of those resistive heaters to heat pumps we would net reduce our electrical demand in the winter. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1231906/residential-heating-fuel-distribution-in-texas/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1231906/residential-heat...
- solardev 3y agoSorry I wasn't specific enough. I meant Texas's private, less regulated grid and the issues stemming from that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Texas_power_crisis#%3A%7E%3Atext%3Ddeadly_winter_storm.-%2CLawsuits%2CAmerican_Electric_Power_utility_company.?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Texas_power_crisis#%3A%7E... It's just funny that in the same country, two states suffer similar electrical outcomes despite polar opposite politics. Californians went all in on solar and their heavy regulated utility couldn't keep up, causing rolling blackouts and bankruptcies. Texas took a no shits given approach to their electric market and that backfired too, skyrocketing prices and killing hundreds. I wonder how other countries deal with their grid upgrades. Judging by the GP's points, maybe not very well either?
- vel0city 3y ago> skyrocketing prices I just signed a contract a few days ago for 100% renewable $0.10/kWh including delivery for another year after coming off a 3-year contract for $0.08/kWh delivered. I don't know that I agree with "skyrocketing prices". Prices did increase the last couple of years with natural gas prices generally going sky high (I was seeing contracts ~$0.14-16/kWh for comparison), but prices have fallen again back to levels they were pre-Ukraine and pre-deep-freeze. Given most other things have inflated a good bit, real electricity prices in Texas are actually down compared to a few years ago. I wouldn't consider $0.10/kWh a "skyrocketing price". Average electricity prices in EU are supposedly €0.25/kWh which is what $0.27? 10 / 27 = .37, so my sky high electricity prices are a third of the average rate in Europe, so I guess theirs are considered astronomical? What are you paying for your electricity? https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Electricity_price_statistics https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php... Had the majority of resistive heating sources converted to heat pumps before the deep freeze, it possibly wouldn't have happened as it would have greatly reduced the electricity demand. Also, if things like gas compressors and other gas infrastructure was properly tagged as critical infrastructure Texas wouldn't have shot itself in the foot turning off those circuits causing cascading gas power plaint failures.