5 ms·
It's still all make-believe. And I say this as someone who has had an interest in Fortean and occult lore for years - it's just folklore people choose to preten
by krapp 3y ago
It's still all make-believe. And I say this as someone who has had an interest in Fortean and occult lore for years - it's just folklore people choose to pretend is real.
- DontchaKnowit 3y agoNo its not. Its metaphor for truth which is unable to be expressed with precise language - because we lack understanding.
- mock-possum 3y agoIf you lack understanding of the truth, and can only refer to it through metaphor, then how do you know it is true?
- Simon_O_Rourke 3y ago> If you lack understanding of the truth, and can only refer to it through metaphor, then how do you know it is true? Sure, then why bother systematizing its study in theology, would it be better to just study English language usage of metaphor?
- Simon_O_Rourke 3y agoHow can theology be a metaphor for truth when the core of what it's trying to reason about is unknowable? "Theology is the systematic study of the nature of the divine and, more broadly, of religious belief" [1]. The latter part I get, lots of people and groups (and regions) have religious beliefs and differences, so it's definitely worth some effort to figure out (from a sociological or anthropological view) what's going on within and between groups of people. I also get the ethics and philosophy parts, trying to what it means to be "good" etc. But this study of the divine is pure horses*t - even if it's not all just made up, then by definition it's still unknowable. If it's something that someone has just concocted on a whim and claimed it was dictated to them by the Almighty, then it's at best a 2nd or 3rd hand source and a dubious one at that. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theology
- standardly 3y agoI think he means the occult, not theology.
- b800h 3y agoThe occult is a form of theology. The sense I take is that he's taking a pot-shot at the lot of it. But I could be wrong.
- b800h 3y agoYou might like to look at some apologetical writing. Christian apologetics, for example, are often split into three layers, essentially: 1. Is there a God - this is actually fairly straightforward to argue, simply because we can use analytical philosophy to reason about the unknowable and first causes and so on. 2. Is Jesus God - much tougher to approach for obvious reasons, but can at least be reasoned about if you've gone through step 1. 3. Should I be x sort of Christian - easier to reason about if you accept 1 & 2. That first step is very approachable if you're already interested in things like logical proofs and higher physics.
- krapp 3y agoYour first layer isn't really "Is there a God" but "Does the Judeo-Christian God exist?" Like Pascal's Wager, Christian apologetics begins by assuming that the only God that can possibly exist is the one Christians already believe in. And neither logic nor higher physics proves that Christianity has the right idea out of the multitude of human religions and infinitude of possibilities beyond.
- b800h 3y ago@krapp - Disagree on that point. Obviously the three above are going to break down into further stages, but there are plenty of apologetic arguments which squarely fall into a broad question of "is there a God?" and not a more specific question. You're right about the starting point though. By its very nature it has to start there, but it doesn't assume that the people it'll be arguing with will be in the same place.
- 3y ago