3 ms·
> If Reddit forces them off, and they create www.askhistorians.com, then I'm making a account there. And that's fine, but you're talking as if everyone is like
by lelanthran 3y ago
> If Reddit forces them off, and they create www.askhistorians.com, then I'm making a account there.
And that's fine, but you're talking as if everyone is like you, with only 1 subreddit that they browse.
In reality (and reddit probably has the numbers to verify this), most people jump across maybe 10 or more different mods.
They're not going to go create 10 different accounts elsewhere.
I personally am not a big reddit user, and yet I have about 10 sunreddits that I subscribe to. Logging into reddit (old.reddit), I see all those posts after login.
This is also the reason why the federated system is broken by design: the type of users who use reddit don't want the friction of logging onto a dozen different instances to see all the posts related to ONE top.
I think what a lot of people are missing is that centralisation is what provides the value reddit has. Moderators (seriously, those people are a dime a dozen - in fact you can charge mods a fee and you still won't run out of mods wanting to sign up) are not the primary value in reddit. Posts are not the primary value in reddit.
Being the central place where all the people you want to hang out with are hanging out is the primary value of reddit.
- dale_glass 3y ago> In reality (and reddit probably has the numbers to verify this), most people jump across maybe 10 or more different mods. So do I. I expect there to form some viable alternative to Reddit eventually. > This is also the reason why the federated system is broken by design: the type of users who use reddit don't want the friction of logging onto a dozen different instances to see all the posts related to ONE top. Federation means separate servers talk to each other and can share content. Eg, I'm on fosstodon.org, but I see posts from an user with an account at tech.lgbt. That's how federation works. > I think what a lot of people are missing is that centralisation is what provides the value reddit has. Moderators (seriously, those people are a dime a dozen - in fact you can charge mods a fee and you still won't run out of mods wanting to sign up) are not the primary value in reddit. Posts are not the primary value in reddit. But this centralization can be provided by anyone else. I don't care that it's provided by Reddit Inc. I come for the posts, where they happen to be hosted isn't very important. I think it can also be provided in a federated manner. There's really no reason why Reddit couldn't be split into a myriad servers that then get aggregated into a giant feed for those who want it.
- phpisthebest 3y ago>> Moderators (seriously, those people are a dime a dozen - in fact you can charge mods a fee and you still won't run out of mods wanting to sign up) are not the primary value in reddit. THis is a falsehood that keeps being repeated so instead of posting for the 100th time proving this to be false, I challenge you to cite your sources where you prove this is true, because most of the subreddits complian all the time about not being able to find mods. >> Posts are not the primary value in reddit. Quality Posts are the value...... Question do mods add that value, that QA... if a gardening subreddit was flooded with porn would it be valuable to the people to visit that subreddit?