7 ms·
Flickr disables Pinterest pins on all copyrighted images
- fufulabs 15y agoWhat happens if [Etsy, Amazon, Tumblr, Wordpress, Blogger] blocks Pinterest and build pinboards into their own site?
- nswanberg 15y agoThen that company would be an underdog in the pinboard business, with lost referrals (Etsy, Amazon) or a distraction from the core focus (WordPress, Blogger), and have to spend several years building a community of users who think to go to the new site to pin things. And other sites would presumably also block this upstart. If pinning were just a technology feature Tumblr seems the closest to being able to duplicate it (their archive view seems vaguely close to a pinboard, minus the interactivity), but they would also have to provide users with a better alternative.
- cft 15y agoLooks like the Hollywood war on the Silicon Valley is gaining steam. We are a large chat/IM provider, not directly involved in any copyright-able content and the last 5-6 months have been exceptionally hard in the amount of bullying from MPAA and the likes because of their complaints about LINKS and other things- often plain text where users just talk about copyrighted materials!
- k-mcgrady 15y agoWhat does Flickr have to do with Hollywood? They are using a method Pinterest provides so that people can't pin copyrighted content. A feature users who own copyrighted content most likely are happy they implemented.
- ricardobeat 15y agoThis is stupid. Are we starting over again? Just don't provide a high quality version if you are selling it. This kind of blocking is just annoying as any other DRM and will certainly be side-stepped by end users.
- silentOpen 15y agoBlocking? This is just a gentleman's agreement to respect the author's wishes. Does Pinterest include attribution?
- djloche 15y agoAgreed - if my images on flickr are set to NOT allow sharing, Flickr implementing solutions to prevent people from sharing these easily is a good thing. Attribution or not, if you've set your images to not allow sharing, sharing it expressly goes against the creators wishes. Compare: google (or any third party) using tracking cookies when your settings say otherwise & expressly told your browser not to allow it.
- jrockway 15y agoYour rights as a content creator are limited by law, and it's unfair for content creators to use technical means to circumvent the public's right to their content. (I say this as an author of one of those dead-tree things, and of much software. I'd like people to follow my license agreement, but some in some cases copyright law grants my users more rights than the license, and I respect that.)
- true_religion 15y agoAre you implying that the public has a right to share content by law, regardless of the content creators wishes?
- dangrossman 15y agoIt does; it's called fair use.
- true_religion 15y agoAh fair use is a defense in court, not something you can trot out in all situations before you get to court. Secondly, consider the context... how are you going to argue that people have a fair use right to share copyrighted images with the public simply because they want to show what they 'like' on their pinboard? Allowing that makes a loophole big enough to render pretty much any copyright protection of images null.
- potatolicious 15y agoI just pinned a bunch of my own images today. Flickr, don't tell me what I can and can't do with content I created myself.
- atarian 15y agoHow do you expect Flickr to differentiate from you and someone else who wants to rip off your content?
- spullara 15y agoWith cookies, this wouldn't be that hard. I wouldn't be surprised if they ultimately let people pin their own content regardless of their settings.
- icebraining 15y agoI wouldn't, if I was making that decision. I can see too many users changing the setting to disable sharing, testing it and then claiming Flickr is "broken" (or worse). And rumors like that easily spread and are hard to disprove.
- snsr 15y ago> How do you expect Flickr to differentiate from you and someone else who wants to rip off your content? Any photographer or artist who really doesn't want their images shared should not make them available on the internet. Period. Given the capabilities of current computing platforms, there exists no method by which you can restrict redistribution. Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.
- mbreese 15y agoThis is a good point. If you don't want your photos seen by others, don't put them on Flickr. If you want to sell highres versions of your photos, only put lowres versions up. So long as things are properly attributed and only low-quality images are stored/used, I see this as Fair Use.
- gmaslov 15y agoWhat? They disabled Pinterest on ALL images which are not in the public domain? Sheesh, might as well drop the feature altogether if you're going to disable it on 99.9% of content. Oh, you mean they allowed copyright owners to disable Pinterest on their images. That makes more sense. Sorry, it just gets my goose when people misuse the word "copyrighted" this way.
- krisrak 15y agoHere is how you pin blocked content to Pinterest in simple steps ;) http://blog.initlabs.com/post/18226946517/how-to-pin-blocked-content-to-pinterest http://blog.initlabs.com/post/18226946517/how-to-pin-blocked...
- Tangaroa 15y agoFlickr respects the wishes of its users. So? If they had gone the other way, the headline could be "Flickr allows stealing of artist work".
- mtigas 15y agoAgreed. What bothers me about the “controversy” (“exclusive” link-baiting headline nonwithstanding) here is that Flickr might be the most transparent image sharing website with regards to setting your own content licensing. It’s not like Flickr has pulled a fast one on everyone by suddenly repurposing peoples’ work. Pinterest was the one that created this opt out, seemingly specifically for the types of content that are explicitly "all rights reserved" in the more restrictive (more meatspace-realistic) sense that Flickr uses on photos flagged as such. Generally all content implicitly has some sort of rights reserved, but in Flickr’s case the "all rights reserved" option is a conscious decision to pick it. (Or alternatively: to not read the fine print on what licenses you can pick — and who does online, anyway?) The one knock on Flickr’s CC licensing I recall was a dust-up a few years ago where a CC-BY photo was later used in an advertising campaign unbeknownst to the person photographed or the person who originally posted the picture on Flickr: https://www.nytimes.com/2007/10/01/technology/01link.html https://www.nytimes.com/2007/10/01/technology/01link.html FWIW, Flickr’s default behavior at the moment (“all rights reserved”) is to protect photographers’ rights and prevent things like that from happening and it’s better IMO to err to that side of caution.
- andyfleming 15y agoI'm not sure about all that. They could easily respond to an article like "Flickr allows stealing of artist work" by adding "nopin" later. However, I don't disagree with their intention. It is nice that they are considering the user in that way. Maybe a better implementation would be for it to be a preference, rather than assuming. They could have an option like "prevent users from posting my photos to other websites".
- spullara 15y agoThey do have that option. The photos they are protecting have that option set. On their settings page: http://www.flickr.com/account/privacy/ http://www.flickr.com/account/privacy/ They have a setting that says "Allow others to share your stuff". If you have marked it No, it cannot be shared to Pinterest. Seems pretty straightforward to me.
- artursapek 15y agoAll those resources and they use an alert()?
- spullara 15y agoThe alert is from the Pinterest bookmarklet.
- andyfleming 15y agoIt seems as though the pinning of a photo on flickr would give the artist more recognition. Isn't that more helpful than hurtful?
- OneBytePerGreen 15y agoJust checked... pinterest creates a copy of the medium-size image and stores it on their own servers. Users can view and re-pin it without seeing the context and author. Very surprising to me, and not cool.
- cheald 15y agoGiven that the alternative is effectively stealing bandwidth, which would you prefer?
- xxbondsxx 15y agoBandwidth stealing and giving credit to the photographer are not mutually exclusive.
- Karunamon 15y agoIt's a valid point, downvoters. I think that having to ask permission to link an image inline is pretty silly - the responsible thing to do would be to rehost it in some manner and then link the rehosted version. Screwed if you do (accused of breaking "copyright"), screwed if you dont (accused of "stealing" bandwidth).
- true_religion 15y agoI guess you don't really believe in copyright if you're going to use scare quotes around it.
- viscanti 15y agoI guess I don't see how copyright applies to publicly viewable images online that are being used for non-commercial purposes. Certainly someone can link to that page, and anyone could see the image. It seems to come down to "credit", and there should be a link to the original content. The internet is pretty much built around the idea of finding interesting things in other places online and then sharing that. In fact, Google made a very profitable business just following and index those links to other content. The point of pinterest is to share interesting visual pieces. So a textual link doesn't do as much as showing a thumbnail. But it's still the same basic concept. Just as blogs expose links to interesting articles, so too does pinterest expose interesting pictures. In both cases, if you like the original what you see, you should be able to visit the original author/creator's page to check out more. I see this as about as reasonable as blocking links on a blog. Don't publish articles online if you don't want people to link to them. Don't publish photos online if you don't want people to link to them (or share smaller thumbnails). If someone takes your article/photo and claims credit for it, then you have a valid argument. But if someone's whole "crime" is to enjoy your content enough to share it and advertise for you, a "thank you" would be more appropriate than arguing that they're infringing your copyright.
- courage 15y agoFlickr and Pinterest both have systems that allow copyright holders to specify what rights they wish to grant to others. Those two systems are now interoperable. Cool.
- jchrisa 15y agoAgree. Isn't this the whole point of having a creative commons API on Flickr in the first place?
- potatolicious 15y agoIf we're going to start defining the CC license in this way, we really need one that's even more restrictive - i.e., all rights reserved, except social network sharing. The current CC non-commercial, non-derivative, attribution-required seems insufficient in comparison.
- eCa 15y agoWhat surprises me most about CC-licensed work is how often the author/licensor neglects one aspect of the license: -------- Attribution — You must attribute the work in the manner specified by the author or licensor (but not in any way that suggests that they endorse you or your use of the work) -------- [1] Attribution in manner specified by the author or licensor. I can't remember a single time that I have seen anybody that uses CC specify in what manner they require attribution. It would be quite simple to require reasonable attribution in a way that a user of pinterest can't do, and in that case use of the licensed work would be in conflict of the license used. [1] http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/ http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/
- datums 15y agoFacebook allows you to post pins to fb, but doesn't allow you to pin images that are fb. http://min.us/mbrREewTH7 http://min.us/mbrREewTH7
- joejohnson 15y agoTo call linking to a copyrighted work piracy is a stretch.
- icebraining 15y agoApparently, Pinboard copies the actual image to their servers and serves from there. Barring fair use or a license, it's copyright infringement.
- Atomus 15y agoI don't get it, Pinterest is an enabler for photographers and artist. I never go to Flickr, could care less, but if I see something of interest on Pinterest (or any other sharing site), I would actually make the effort to go to Flickr and check it out. If I really like what I see from said artist/photographer, I would perhaps consider purchasing some of their work to display in my home. If not, by sharing what I saw, I potentially gave that artist a ton more eyeballs on their work, thus increasing their chances of people buying their artwork. The benefits far outweigh the disadvantages of sharing IMHO
- courage 15y agoThe benefits of share most likely do outweigh disadvantages for most people, most of the time. The whole point of putting photos on Flickr is that you can share them with other people. However, Flickr also gives its users the opportunity to specify access controls on their photos as well. Being able to control who sees, and who shares photos is another reason to use Flickr. As both an engineer and a photographer, I greatly prefer a system that puts its users in control, rather than forcing everyone into a single path that the designers believe is in their best interest.
- icebraining 15y ago"Illusion of control". It's more a way to tell the user that the photographer doesn't want it to be shared than an actual control.