3 ms·

Reddit would be infinitely better without any subreddits bigger than about 100k subscribers.

by mvdtnz 3y ago

zucked 3y ago
That’s been the part of this blackout that has hurt the most, honestly. I’ve been on Reddit for longer than a decade and all but entirely shut out the front page subs like Videos, InterestingAF, etc. I wouldn’t miss those if they disappeared tomorrow. Instead, I’m in far smaller niche and location-relevant subs. I didn’t realize what cutting off my city subreddit would do for my sense of connection to my city. I didn’t realize how shit general search results are for questions about hobbies. It’s really made me question if can allow one entity to serve as such an important conduit to my interests again.
epmatsw 3y ago
Sports subreddits are a notable exception imo. While they might get a bit silly, r/cfb, r/nba, etc. are so much better than Twitter or any other public forum that losing them would be pretty awful.
- mvdtnz 3y ago
  I only follow motorsports so the only sports subs I'm on are motogp, v8supercars and formula1. The F1 subreddit (over a million subs)is one of the absolute worst places on the internet for any kind of discussion. It's totally dominated by The Hive Mind, dissenting opinions are absolutely unwelcome and the top posts on every single post are low-effort jokes, usually jokes that have been told a thousand times before. It's awful. MotoGP (250k+ subs) is better, but still suffers from similar problems. V8Supercars is quiet, but the discussion is of a far higher quality. "Better than twitter" is a low bar to clear.
  - snuxoll 3y ago
    /r/formula1 is really hit or miss. I wouldn't say it's as horrible as you make it out to be, but the pervasive groupthink of the sport as a whole (whoever is on top needs to be knocked down a peg, Liberty Media sucks, whatever) is certainly strong there.
  - paulmd 3y ago
    Subreddits generally undergo twinkdeath between 100k and 1m users. Once enough people know about the sub they tell all their snoo friends and pretty soon it’s just a hivemind and memes and funny quips. Watched it happen to a lot of tech subs. The exception is subs that lean heavily into over-the-top curation which is also its own special kind of groupthink hell imo.
tedunangst 3y ago
So what does user 100001 do?
- krasin 3y ago
  I think that OP talks on the logarithm scale. 100k vs 1M is a big difference in quality of content and discussion. 1M vs 10M is even more so.
8organicbits 3y ago
Subscribe to the subreddits you enjoy (regardless of size) and ignore the rest. You are not forced to view content from the big subs.
bazmattaz 3y ago
Reddit would be better with better moderation. Would be great if there was a clever way (machine learning?) to identify and remove all low effort posts and reposts. Would also be better if there was a clever way to detect and ban karma whores and users who just post crap to build karma and sell the account. All the big subs are garbage these days

Reddit would be infinitely better without any subreddits bigger than about 100k subscribers.

by mvdtnz 3y ago

Reddit would be infinitely better without any subreddits bigger than about 100k subscribers.

That’s been the part of this blackout that has hurt the most, honestly. I’ve been on Reddit for longer than a decade and all but entirely shut out the front page subs like Videos, InterestingAF, etc. I wouldn’t miss those if they disappeared tomorrow. Instead, I’m in far smaller niche and location-relevant subs. I didn’t realize what cutting off my city subreddit would do for my sense of connection to my city. I didn’t realize how shit general search results are for questions about hobbies. It’s really made me question if can allow one entity to serve as such an important conduit to my interests again.

epmatsw 3y ago

Sports subreddits are a notable exception imo. While they might get a bit silly, r/cfb, r/nba, etc. are so much better than Twitter or any other public forum that losing them would be pretty awful.

mvdtnz 3y ago
I only follow motorsports so the only sports subs I'm on are motogp, v8supercars and formula1. The F1 subreddit (over a million subs)is one of the absolute worst places on the internet for any kind of discussion. It's totally dominated by The Hive Mind, dissenting opinions are absolutely unwelcome and the top posts on every single post are low-effort jokes, usually jokes that have been told a thousand times before. It's awful. MotoGP (250k+ subs) is better, but still suffers from similar problems. V8Supercars is quiet, but the discussion is of a far higher quality. "Better than twitter" is a low bar to clear.
- snuxoll 3y ago
  /r/formula1 is really hit or miss. I wouldn't say it's as horrible as you make it out to be, but the pervasive groupthink of the sport as a whole (whoever is on top needs to be knocked down a peg, Liberty Media sucks, whatever) is certainly strong there.
- paulmd 3y ago
  Subreddits generally undergo twinkdeath between 100k and 1m users. Once enough people know about the sub they tell all their snoo friends and pretty soon it’s just a hivemind and memes and funny quips. Watched it happen to a lot of tech subs. The exception is subs that lean heavily into over-the-top curation which is also its own special kind of groupthink hell imo.

tedunangst 3y ago

So what does user 100001 do?

krasin 3y ago
I think that OP talks on the logarithm scale. 100k vs 1M is a big difference in quality of content and discussion. 1M vs 10M is even more so.

8organicbits 3y ago

Subscribe to the subreddits you enjoy (regardless of size) and ignore the rest. You are not forced to view content from the big subs.

bazmattaz 3y ago

Reddit would be better with better moderation. Would be great if there was a clever way (machine learning?) to identify and remove all low effort posts and reposts. Would also be better if there was a clever way to detect and ban karma whores and users who just post crap to build karma and sell the account. All the big subs are garbage these days