3 ms·
Putting aside the nonsense of "absolutely disgusting", this is incredibly vague and exceedingly implausible. Critiquing: > They say the largest property compan
by crazygringo 3y ago
Putting aside the nonsense of "absolutely disgusting", this is incredibly vague and exceedingly implausible. Critiquing:
> They say the largest property companies in the US (they named names, I can’t) are raising huge amounts of money... if they stop paying the loan, and the bank gets the building back, the bank cannot sue them for the remainder of the loan.
For this reason, banks generally do not loan more than what the building is worth. Banks aren't dumb, they're not going to fall for something as obvious as this.
> Banks will take hundreds of billions to trillions of dollars in losses. And literally everyone knows the US government will have no choice but to bail them out, as usual.
Not really. They sure didn't bail out Lehman. And the owners of SVB lost all their equity. Bank owners do everything they possible can to avoid failing and being "bailed out".
> Then, when the banks turn around and sell these properties for pennies on the dollar, these same property companies that caused the problem in the first place are going to buy better properties for cheaper and end up better off than they were before.
Properties are sold at auction or similar and go to the highest bidder. It's certainly not "pennies on the dollar".
In sum, none of this makes any sense.
- taeric 3y agoThey may not be idiots, but has the value of the buildings also plummeted? This could be akin to the toxic mortgage loans of years ago, just without the predatory lending that jacked up the values. Doesn't matter, too much, if the values just dropped naturally versus having been inflated by poor lending practices.
- vel0city 3y ago> banks generally do not loan more than what the building is worth. The building's worth was often based on pre-pandemic rent expectations. Lots of buildings are very empty these days, even if they're still currently leased. I wonder what the rates of renewals will be on suites where practically nobody goes to.
- crazygringo 3y agoThe article is talking about new loans, which are always going to be based on current valuations, not pre-pandemic ones.
- jsnell 3y agoI don't think the claim is about new or future loans. The suggestion is that they're raising money via equity, not via new loans. They'd just be defaulting on their old loans. But I agree that the story as a whole made very little sense.
- crazygringo 3y agoThe claim seems to be entirely about new loans, because the whole point of the supposed scheme is that the profit is coming from new loans that won't need to be paid back. Raising money by issuing new shares wouldn't have anything to do with anything here.
- vel0city 3y ago> the profit is coming from new loans that won't need to be paid back. When they go to buy the properties back, they'll be at the new valuations pricing in the fact they're probably going to have to offer significantly less rent than before to maybe get occupancy up. A lot of buildings have some pretty extreme valuations compared to how many people are actually coming in to the office. I've heard of >200,000sqft buildings leasing for $30-40/sqft with only a few hundred people actually coming in. ~$8MM/yr+ in leasing for like maybe 500 people to come into an office most days in a week. That's $16,000/yr in leasing costs supposedly for each of those seats, before things like utilities and maintenance are figured in. Does >$16,000/yr per desk make sense to keep a lease? I haven't heard those kinds of numbers just once. I've heard it (and seen it) several times. The office I go into has a nearly empty parking garage. It doesn't have the foot traffic to support the one cafe that used to be there. Whole floors are entirely open to be leased. I'm one of about four people who show up to the entire floor of the building. Its crazy how empty so many commercial office buildings are these days. Personally I wouldn't mind seeing a lot of this commercial real estate take a bit of a haircut on valuations, hopefully we'll see rents dip a good bit and we'll see actual occupancy up meaning better usage of the things we've already built. Its depressing seeing tons of capital just sitting there unused based on some improbable dream of getting more in rent.
- jandrese 3y ago> Banks aren't dumb, they're not going to fall for something as obvious as this. Historical evidence suggests otherwise. Obvious bullshit like this was the root cause of the 2008 housing collapse. As long as your bank isn't the one sacrificial goat the government chooses to let fail you will be fine.
- mcguire 3y agoIsn't the base problem that commercial real estate is worth much less now than when the loans were taken out? This is the same thing that happened to residential housing markets in the S&L and subprime mortage crises, right?
- gojomo 3y agoThe "walking away" definitely fits recent actions in the last couple of weeks in SF, per my other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36314386 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36314386 It's true they're "not dumb" - the "systemically important banks" know they can take a chance on a sectoral or cyclical collapse like this, because the government won't let them all fail together. The downside is capped, but the leveraged upside arbitrarily larger. While wiping out SVB's shareholders, the government launched special programs (like "BTFP") to help all SVB's peers with artificially-cheap money requiring less collateral than ever before. That's a stealth & incremental bail-out – which could paper-over the problems, or worsen them, depending on other economic developments. If commercial real estate broadly crashes, those banks will unload these properties they don't really want – as even the commercial real-estate pros couldn't make them profitable – at potentially-severe discounts to the unpaid loan amounts. If these discounts are anywhere near 50%, then "pennies on the dollar" would be a fair description. I guess time will tell.
- mo_42 3y ago> … Bank owners do everything they possible can to avoid failing and being "bailed out". Might be true. But everything they can is not enough. First, there’s the principal-agent problem: the owners (aka share holders) can not fully control managers or staff in general. Second, the goals of an organization do not necessarily align with the goals of the individuals that contribute to the organization. For example, young bankers who know that they will switch jobs some time will work differently than those who also own the bank. So usually there’s a bias towards more short-term profit and higher risk. Also for the bank as a whole there’s a bias towards risk because they have to compete with other banks. If I’d be a well-intentioned CEO I would still be forced into that behavior because otherwise I would simply be fired or the bank would lose against other banks.