4 ms·
I was curious why it seems so much nicer than Comic Sans (and many commenters here seem to agree). Many of the letterforms have been dramatically "straightened
by crazygringo 3y ago
I was curious why it seems so much nicer than Comic Sans (and many commenters here seem to agree).
Many of the letterforms have been dramatically "straightened" -- a Comic Sans "m" is kind of hideous, with the three vertical strokes intentionally all at different angles... whereas in this one they're all essentially vertical.
Comic Sans is ugly because it's terribly proportioned (intentionally) to mimic the way a child would write. But when you straighten everything and the letters necessarily fit into a grid... it's just much, much nicer aesthetically.
Just a gentle "handwriting mono" font, rather than the original which is (again, intentionally) horribly kerned and where half the letterforms feel like they're about to topple over from imbalance.
- lucideer 3y agoAnother notable deviation that may affect the aesthetic is that it's been slightly seriffed (fIijl) for some reason.
- nemetroid 3y agoI think Comic Code stays more true to the aesthetics of Comic Sans. https://www.myfonts.com/collections/comic-code-font-tabular-type-foundry https://www.myfonts.com/collections/comic-code-font-tabular-...
- anikom15 3y agoComic Sans is actually quite legible for its class and well-hinted. It works better with antialiasing off. The main criticism is in its overuse.
- dspillett 3y ago> It works better with antialiasing off This is largely because it was specifically designed to be readable on low resolution screens without sub-pixel rendering (which wasn't a thing at the time as on a great many Windows machines you could only really rely on the standard 16 colour palette). It is also part of why other fonts with similar target aesthetics look much better in print and on more modern devices - techniques used to improve it for low resolution use have a detrimental effect when not using it that way. > The main criticism is in its overuse. The second is inappropriate use. It is still the better choice for child-hand-like writing if you are targeting 4-or-8-bit/pixel displays at 640*480 resolution (or not much more) on ~14 inch devices, but how many times is it actually used that way?
- wodenokoto 3y agoIt is not modeled on children’s handwriting but, as the name implies, letters found in speech bubbles in comic books.
- CharlesW 3y agoAlso, "real" comic book fonts do exist: https://www.comicbookfonts.com/ https://www.comicbookfonts.com/
- crazygringo 3y agoIf you look at the font, it's quite clearly extremely "irregular" in a way that children's handwriting is, and comic book speech bubbles very much are not meant to be. Indeed, the creator used some comics as a starting point, but then tried to redraw the strokes with a mouse (!), and intentionally drew them wrong, not keeping them straight, etc. So the goal was not to reproduce comic speech bubbles at all, but to create something instead "strange and childlike". You would never want to use it for actual comic book lettering. From an interview [1]: > They wanted all kinds of fonts – a lot of them strange and childlike. One program was called Microsoft Bob, which was designed to make computers more accessible to children. I booted it up and out walked this cartoon dog, talking with a speech bubble in Times New Roman. Dogs don’t talk in Times New Roman! Conceptually, it made no sense. > So I had an idea to make a comic-style text and started looking at Watchmen and Dark Knight Returns, graphic novels where the hand lettering was like a typeface... Instead, I looked at various letters and tried to mimic them on screen. There were no sketches or studies – it was just me drawing with a mouse, deleting whatever was wrong. > I didn’t have to make straight lines, I didn’t have to make things look right, and that’s what I found fun. I was breaking the typography rules. My boss Robert Norton, whose mother Mary Norton wrote The Borrowers, said the “p” and “q” should mirror each other perfectly. I said: “No, it’s supposed to be wrong!” [1] https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2017/mar/28/how-we-made-font-comic-sans-typography https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2017/mar/28/how-we-...
- pessimizer 3y agoExcept speech bubbles in comic books look a lot better and more regular.
- bityard 3y ago> to mimic the way a child would write No, it was intended to mimic the style of comic book lettering, hence the name. Part of the reason Comic Sans is reviled is because not only is it a terrible font, but it is also a far cry from actual comic book lettering.
- crazygringo 3y agoNo it wasn't, see my cousin comment.
- markandrewj 3y agoIt seems like this isn't very well known, but the design of Comic Sans is actually intended to help children with dyslexia. The creator of Comic Sans also talks about this in his lectures. Listening to him talk about the design of the typeface changed my perception of it. Ref: Vincent Connare: Comic Sans is the Best Font in the World https://youtu.be/xXdzBTeYZlE https://youtu.be/xXdzBTeYZlE Ref: https://www.nothingcomicaboutdyslexia.com/ https://www.nothingcomicaboutdyslexia.com/
- tapland 3y agoWas it intended to? I know it's useful for dyslexics but I've not seen anyone claim it was intentionally designed with that intent and I'm pretty sure that has been explained to be a happy coincidence in the past. Ref2 doesn't state that, and I can't do video right now. Edit: And neither does Ref1
- markandrewj 3y agoThank you for the correction. I thought I had read it was part of the initial design consideration at one point, but reading about it further again, I think the discovery that it helped dyslexic readers happened after the typeface was made public. It is still an interesting aspect of the typeface that doesn't get much attention though, although there are other typefaces that also try to help with dyslexia. If you are interested in design, I still recommend watching the talk when you have the time. It has been a while since I watched it, but the designer is well spoken.
- Phrodo_00 3y agoThere's a font called OpenDyslexic[1] that was actually designed to do that [1] https://opendyslexic.org/ https://opendyslexic.org/
- michelb 3y agoSome info about these fonts here https://www.edutopia.org/article/do-dyslexia-fonts-actually-work/ https://www.edutopia.org/article/do-dyslexia-fonts-actually-... Fwiw my dyslexic friends feel no benefit from these fonts. Would love to hear other experiences.
- brazzledazzle 3y agoI absolutely (irrationally, I admit) despise comic sans from a purely personal aesthetic perspective but this does bug me less which is saying a lot.
- polpo 3y agoReminds me of Apple’s Chalkboard font, which basically fixes everything that’s off putting about Comic Sans while still being casual and child-like: http://www.identifont.com/differences?first=Chalkboard&second=Comic+Sans http://www.identifont.com/differences?first=Chalkboard&secon...
- behnamoh 3y agoIt's beautiful!
- cubefox 3y agoComic Sans was made to look as if it was handwritten. The Chalkboard font looks too artificial for that. E.g. k,l,m,n have too straight lines.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoNah look more closely. They are slanted
- nerdponx 3y agoI thought Comic Sans was meant to mimic the text in a comic strip, not a child's handwriting.
- Kuraj 3y agoYou're gonna love Comic Neue: https://comicneue.com/ https://comicneue.com/
- archermarks 3y agoI love this? I'm not sure if it's ironic, unironic or what but I'm digging it.
- keyle 3y agoIt doesn't even look half as bad as I imagined it would! Looks like a good Friday font or for that codebase you despise opening, or a perfect prank for a developer who left their computer unlocked.