4 ms·
Less so than you might expect. Because it's a single wavelength, ground stations can be much more efficient than solar; this means 80-90% for the relevant freq
by ben_w 3y ago
Less so than you might expect.
Because it's a single wavelength, ground stations can be much more efficient than solar; this means 80-90% for the relevant frequencies rather than 20-45% for typical solar PV.
Given the size of the ground stations are necessarily enormous, the energy can be quite dilute and still "interesting" power output.
I don't think it'll pass the geopolitics test, as you need to prove to your enemies that it can't be abused; and I have yet to hear any proponents seriously consider what can go wrong if there's more than one over the horizon at any one time (that reminds me, I do need to write this up properly…), but if there's only one then the maths says it's probably safe.
Unfortunately, the very thing that makes it safe is another reason for pessimism (on Earth): a back-of-the envelope calculation suggests the ground stations have to use about 50,000 tons of aluminium given the size constraints are based on wavelengths, regardless of the power going through them. That's not much for one, but if you need four thousand of them then it's comparable to a 2 TW antipodal power grid which would make space beaming redundant anyway.
I can easily see this being used on a Mars colony to get past the global dust storms, but I don't really see it becoming a major player on Earth thanks to the political issues and the alternatives.
- dabluecaboose 3y ago>I can easily see this being used on a Mars colony to get past the global dust storms, but I don't really see it becoming a major player on Earth thanks to the political issues and the alternatives. I could see it becoming analogous to current-day satellite phones. Some very specific uses in remote areas, but not the standard for everyone.