5 ms·
First of all, the OS does not style widgets, the browser does. And scrollbars are completely different in different browsers - they have different sizes, differ
by tsimionescu 3y ago
First of all, the OS does not style widgets, the browser does. And scrollbars are completely different in different browsers - they have different sizes, different behavior, different look-and-feels. So either you create versions of your app which match each browser individually, or you re-style the scrollbars to look the same as the rest of the app.
Thirdly, there is an obvious counter to your arguments that shows that one-size-fits-all design is not actually what users always want: games. You wouldn't expect a game to use the system look-and-feel, it rightfully uses a look-and-feel that matches the game itself.
And we can extend this observation further out: if your app is self-contained enough, and you have a distinctive enough style that your users like, then you should re-style everything away from the OS style to your specific unique look.
Should every app do this? Absolutely not. But is there no case outside gaming where an app should? Of course not.
- pprotas 3y agoMacOS and iOS scrollbars are the same in every app and browser. They are styled by the OS, even in iOS games.
- tsimionescu 3y agoPerhaps, but MacOS and iOS are not the only OSs out there. Also, full screen iOS games have full control of the screen and I/O, and can choose to draw anything they want and implement any interaction they want, they don't have to rely on the system to draw widgets for them.
- pyrale 3y agoI believe the point is that if you're unhappy with the default scrollbar, you should get rid of it altogether rather than torture it into doing something it's not meant to do. Having done e.g. an endless scroll application, the scrollbar was unfit for our use, no matter what we did. The right solution was to remove scrollbar and implement our own scrolling mechanism.
- 411111111111111 3y agoWhich is straight up what jmbwell was complaining about, as it breaks their workflow such as tapping on the top to scroll to the beginning and everything else they mentioned.
- nailer 3y agoI appreciate this is off topic and not a solution but on iOS you can tap the hole on top of your screen to scroll to the top on any application.
- 411111111111111 3y agoYes, that's one of the features that break with endless scroll bars, which was what this whole discussion was about.
- nailer 3y agoIt works for every single app that has endless scroll bars on my entire history of using iOS. Try it on Reddit for example.
- LeoNatan25 3y agoIt breaks more often than it doesn’t. Yes, the page “scrolls”, but it scrolls only a few pixels, while the internal “custom” scrolling implementation doesn’t respond to the event and does not scroll to top, resulting in a terrible UX.
- pyrale 3y agoWhen you scroll on reddit, there is a beginning and no end. Some applications have neither a beginning nor an end, so scrolling to the beginning makes no sense. At best, you could make "scroll to the beginning" get back to the start of your navigation, but then your scrollbar wouldn't let you go further. (also if you have both horizontal and vertical scrolling, you're still left with no horizontal options)
- not1ormore 3y ago[dead]
- creshal 3y ago> And scrollbars are completely different in different browsers - they have different sizes, different behavior, different look-and-feels. Yes, and? No matter what it is, it's what the users of said platform are used to. Is there really a benefit to forcing users to re-learn such a critical component? > You wouldn't expect a game to use the system look-and-feel, it rightfully uses a look-and-feel that matches the game itself. 1. Not everything is a game. 2. Depending on the game, system look&feel can be perfectly fine: SimCity 2000, Aurora, the Rule the Waves series, and probably loads of other simulation games all use it, because their art style doesn't require to re-invent the wheel poorly. 3. Games whose art style do need custom look&feel will most likely be using a fullscreen canvas/WebG(L|PU) widget anyway and will be able to use it regardless of CSS support of the feature.
- tsimionescu 3y agoMy point was that a general "no app shall customize scrollbar look and feel" is wrong, as there are certain kinds of apps that do benefit from custom look and feel. Sure, not all games, but also games are not so entirely different from other kinds of apps. Also, I thought the specific points about CSS and how to achieve custom styling if desired are irrelevant. The arguments I was replying to were about UX, not about details of how that is implemented.
- noduerme 3y agoIt's very hard to actually write good UX from scratch, particularly stuff like scrollbars that require all sorts of relative resizing, drag listeners, velocity methods, second and tertiary controls (keyboards, drag-selection of text) and often need to handle those things after a variety of user interactions without redrawing their content or slowing anything down by constantly remeasuring the rest of the UI. Because it's difficult, it's often done poorly, which leads to people thinking it should never be done at all. To your point about games, I find most custom-written scrollboxes in games to be pretty terrible, but we all kind of appreciate them just for their uniqueness, because as UX items they're generally not something you interact with that much. (Unless you're playing Crusader Kings, in which case ... ) I remember being disgusted and offended by Apple's app developer rules two decades ago, which included dictates such as never implementing your own UX elements like scrollbars. We're still debating whether they were wrong. As long as there are bad ways to build UX elements, some people will do them, and this will serve as proof for a few big companies that it should never be done.
- berkes 3y ago> First of all, the OS does not style widgets, the browser does. This goes beyond scrollbars. There are hundreds (thousands?) of libraries or entire frameworks to build consistent dropdowns. Even more to create date-pickers and to replace alert dialogs, add modals, and whatnot. This shows that the browsers don't do a good job offering nice and neat UX on them. Same for scrollbars. Browsers offer native dropdowns (that more-or-less match your OS - depending on browser and OS), datepickers (that at least match your locale) and even native alert dialogs. And many are ugly as hell, have a terrible UX or integrate very poorly. IMO fair points. And often even reasons to replace the native widgets with tons of JS, CSS and dom manipulation. Edit: though I don't think this is the case for scrollbars, I think browsers do a good enough job there. The one reason that I very much disagree with, it cross-browser or cross-platform consistency. No-one cares that widgets on your website or -app are the same on chrome/windows, icebeaver/weirdlinux and safari/OSX. Because no-one other than the webdeveloper and -designer will ever use them on all those platforms and expect everything to look the same on all these platforms.
- chiefalchemist 3y ago> And scrollbars are completely different in different browsers - they have different sizes, different behavior, different look-and-feels. So either you create versions of your app which match each browser individually, or you re-style the scrollbars to look the same as the rest of the app. Find me a user that sez "This experience sucks...that's the native scrollbar" and I'll give you $100. If you give me $1 for every user who is fine with the native experience they are most comfortable with. If you give me $1000 for every time a custom scrollbar isn't accessible. Fwiw, I've never visited a site with a custom scrollbar that didn't have other UI / UX issues. The fancy scrollbar didn't makeup for those. p.s. Gaming is a different aesthetic, a different audience, etc. It's not what should be the user-centric internet.
- tsimionescu 3y ago> p.s. Gaming is a different aesthetic, a different audience, etc. It's not what should be the user-centric internet. I don't think that games are an entirely different world from web apps. There is some amount of gradation between pure document-like pages at one extreme and games at the other, and a whole spectrum in between (say, an app like Google Earth probably doesn't need regular scroll bars to implement most of its scrolling behavior, while not being a game). Also, I think users are quite observant of color clashes, and will notice if you have system-styled scroll bars in the middle of a web page that is styled in a specific way. I don't even understand how this is a controversial opinion - especially when we have things like dark mode that was available in numerous apps long before any OS or browser supported it natively - thus requiring the app to re-style all controls.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoThe technology is not the audience / culture.
- criley2 3y agoThe "But games don't standardize the UI" is actually a worse argument than it appears on the surface. Since every game is re-inventing the wheel, they're all making inferior wheels. UX/accessibility is so far behind OS/web in full screen games that I'm impressed that disabled people can even play most games at all. It's not uncommon to boot up a brand new game in 2023 that has the menu design and UX consideration of a late 90s website.
- tsimionescu 3y agoI don't think most games would become compatible with a screen reader if their inventory system had a better scroll bar. You are right that game UIs tend to be well behind some common OS elements in terms of accessibility, and even low hanging fruit are sometimes missing, but it is also the case that many (most?) games are fundamentally incompatible with many disabilities and as such improvements in certain specific UX areas are low value. Doesn't excuse the fact that they should do better where it's possible, though.
- no_time 3y ago>You wouldn't expect a game to use the system look-and-feel, it rightfully uses a look-and-feel that matches the game itself. Oh yes I do. https://store.steampowered.com/app/2008100 https://store.steampowered.com/app/2008100
- Sophira 3y agoThe difference is that games are a deliberate exercise in non-productivity. You are generally not trying to 'get something done' in a game except what the game itself is asking you to do. When using a webpage, you generally are trying to 'get something done'. Besides, games implementing their own widgets can be terrible for accessibility.
- tsimionescu 3y agoThe majority of game menus are there to help you get something done. With some exceptions, games are not played inside their menus, and have the same kinds of UX concerns as any regular app. The main difference between games and many other apps is that games are trying to sell you a fantasy, and look and feel are much more important to keeping you in the right mindset than in some other apps. But there are other apps and even web pages with similar goals which don't quite qualify as games.