4 ms·
Before we stopped funding things properly, medical research was undertaken in publicly funded bodies. Thats where Insulin, and Penicillin emerged from. Prior to
by ggm 3y ago
Before we stopped funding things properly, medical research was undertaken in publicly funded bodies. Thats where Insulin, and Penicillin emerged from. Prior to this of course drugs like sulpha and their precursors lay in the fully commercial dyestuff industry of "Mauve" fame (the Bayer-Hoechst thing)
A shitload of science is done on the public purse.
I don't want to objectify you, and you aren't wrong because stuff is now being done speculatively for profit day 1, but the "moral" aspect of this is really dubious to me: If we want to fund public health drug research, we can. And if we did, there would be no reason to vest patents over the discovery, we sunk the public purse into the drug design for public good outcomes.
I back India every time on this: Fuck the patents, they just make the drugs.
- AlbertCory 3y ago> I don't want to objectify you What??? Read the post again: it was studiously neutral on the topic. I'm describing a political reality: software should be carved out of their space. They have a ton of clout in DC, and if you insist on killing drug patents, too, then nothing will ever be done. Guaranteed.
- ggm 3y agoYep. This is true. Until we get a good old fashioned FDR style socialist government back, its stupid to think about US centrally funded public works in any dimension. It was studiously neutral. But, the world is bigger than the USA and US patents leak into the world, which is a problem: other economies do it differently. Drug patents are bad. The pragmatic good in the short term is that they got us the covid vaccine, and will get us malaria, and better flu shots and probably personalised cancer treatments. All of that should be nationalised, and made available worldwide for public good. Fuck the shareholders. (not you. you're just calling it as you see it. I'll say it again: you aren't wrong) Software patents are both bad, and stupid.
- robomartin 3y ago> Fuck the patents, they just make the drugs. > Drug patents are bad. The pragmatic good in the short term is that they got us the covid vaccine, and will get us malaria, and better flu shots and probably personalised cancer treatments. All of that should be nationalised, and made available worldwide for public good. > Fuck the shareholders. I wonder if you have any experience at all in a non-trivial business where heavy investment is a necessary precursor to getting something to market. For example, a hypothetical where you have to invest a million dollars cash and a year of work by a team of ten well-paid professionals (which is expensive) to get a product to market. I say this because anyone who has this experience would not say the things you are saying. Not because you altruistic sentiment is wrong. It isn't. At all. Your perspective is rooted in public good for the greatest number of people. Again, nothing wrong with that at all. The issue is one related to business reality. If the prevailing mode of operation is for society to just take what you develop through heavy investment of cash and time and give it to everyone, the problem quickly becomes evident: Nobody is going to take the risk or make the investment. "Fuck the patents, they just make the drugs" is a commendable position that can only be held by those who do not have to make the investment necessary to create and support those drugs or products. From that perspective, it is easy to steal anything. Yes, it is stealing when you take someone's work-product and do not compensate them at all. To use an imperfect example to illustrate the idea, it's like a situation where you spend five years saving money and slowly using it to build a house, only to have a bunch of people move-in and take it once built...and they don't pay you anything for it. In parts of the world this kind of thing actually happens, I know someone who had this problem in South America. It's fine to want better things for everyone. However, these ideas have to be rooted in reality. If everyone steals nobody is going to have any interest or motivation to take risks and build better things.
- AlbertCory 3y agoThanks. Somehow it's not even possible to talk about "software patents" without someone insisting on dragging in "drug patents." Why would you deliberately make yourself a target for one of the biggest lobbies in DC? They are separate discussions.
- 3y ago
- AlbertCory 3y agoOK, I've seen your posts before and getting triggered by a bad word is not something I'd expect from you. > Until we get a good old fashioned FDR style socialist government Until then, we can excise our field from that cesspit. That's something could be done without a revolution.
- Nullabillity 3y ago> What??? Read the post again: it was studiously neutral on the topic. Bullshit. Your post starts with the assumptions that: 1) good patents exist, and 2) medical patents are good. Neither of those assumptions are "neutral".
- AlbertCory 3y ago> Bullshit. Your post starts with the assumptions that: 1) good patents exist, and 2) medical patents are good. You're so articulate. "Drug and medical patents have at least some moral claim to virtue " is not an assumption that "medical patents are good." No it doesn't. Unless subtlety is lost on you.