2 ms·
> There’s no visual indication that there’s more content present in this window—the only way to discover it is to scroll downwards. However, without an affordan
by eviks 3y ago
> There’s no visual indication that there’s more content present in this window—the only way to discover it is to scroll downwards. However, without an affordance to indicate the presence of additional offscreen content, the chances are low that someone will bother to check.
> This is why Apple introduced a preference to always show scroll bars.
But the proper solution is to add the info/affordance in that specific instance instead of always wasting space even when you don't use the scroll bar. This would also allow you to have a more convenient wide scroll bar for when you actually need to use it (in very large documents/lists, though currently you can't setup your scroll bar to depend on that)
And here is the main problem with the article - this general approach blocks would block all UI innovation until some browser/OS vendor implemented something poorly (of course, this doesn't mean your implementation will be better, but someone else's will be)
- pickingdinner 3y agoI was under the impression "scrollbar = more to see" has been somewhat of a standard for a while now. The Mac example is just one of those classic UI fails. The worst are the pages where the scroll wheel doesn't work, even when you can see the scrollbar just fine. I'm always baffled, since no simple page would have that problem. Clearly they developed it and didn't care for breaking it. In html I would sometimes force the scrollbar to always show to prevent layout stuttering. But otherwise, changing the color of the scrollbar to match the fg and bg colors of the page shouldn't be too big of a deal. And I wouldn't mind if some browser skins would change the default scrollbar colors to match, either. Scrollbars are already stylized across the web and across programs. Most users don't mind it. With options come the bad choices, which anyone can list on one page.
- eviks 3y ago> "scrollbar = more to see" has been somewhat of a standard for a while now. That's not a great standard because it conflates conveying information with providing control. 001 px width is enough to convey isScrollable info, but makes it impossible to scroll 100 px width makes it easy to scroll, but is a waste of space to convey convey isScrollable info