3 ms·
> Allowing people the choice of whether they are the product or not. "Subscribe for no ads" seems like a good middle path alternative to selling ads without dem
by kelnos 3y ago
> Allowing people the choice of whether they are the product or not. "Subscribe for no ads" seems like a good middle path alternative to selling ads without demanding a whole new architecture and operational model for federated solutions.
The main problem with social media as it exists today is not advertising (as much as I despise advertising), but the toxic, addictive, engagement-at-all-costs nature of how the information is presented.
I agree with you that most people don't care about their data ownership/privacy to the point that they'll host their own instances. And if they don't do that, then they are beholden to whatever "algorithms" the centralized players want to use to ensure high levels of engagement that keep people on the site/app, and coming back to the site/app.
- munificent 3y agoBut it's the advertising that drives all of the stuff you do hate. When a business is ad-driven, human attention is the raw crude that it harvests to turn into a product (ad impressions) that it then generates revenue from. The more attention it can siphon up, the more ad impressions it can deliver and the more money the business makes. Does your coffee maker chime every twenty minutes to helpfully suggest you might want another coffee? No, of course not. Because the people who made that coffee maker already got as much money from you as they're gonna get when you bought it. As long as you're happy enough with it to not switch to the competition, they don't care how much you use it. They get no additional revenue from your additional use. With ad-driven businesses, every user is a potentially inexhaustible source of future attention, which is what drives all of these toxic user experience choices.