3 ms·
I think about the fragility of heroic personas a lot. During the peak of the 2020 protests and riots, there was a spate of statue toppling that, on their face,
by petsfed 3y ago
I think about the fragility of heroic personas a lot. During the peak of the 2020 protests and riots, there was a spate of statue toppling that, on their face, seemed excessive. Like various Confederate leaders, sure. But George Washington? Thomas Jefferson?
But it turns out that George Washington owned a lot of slaves. Jefferson has a very complicated and questionable history with slavery in particular. I learned a bit about Robert E. Lee's history of slave ownership, and it's directly at odds with what I was taught in school. Its worth investigating if you've time.
I eventually landed on this idea that there are specific acts that we should encourage our children to emulate, but there is no entire person that any children should aspire to emulate. Oskar Schindler, we should recall, was a member of the Nazi Party (and, I'm surprised to learn from wikipedia, was employed by the Nazi intelligence organization, and was convicted of spying on Czechoslovakia for the Nazis, prior to the German occupation).
I am troubled by the idea that we should always forgive and forget, as it were, the things that get people canceled today. Yes, people change, and a questionable tweet by an 18 year old should not dog them in perpetuity until the end of their life. But on the other hand, I feel like we should not grant blanket pardon for people who have not sought to redress their own sins, and sincerely apologized. E.g. Donald Trump's past is littered with exceptionally bad behavior, and it seems he never expresses contrition, but always asks that the public set aside that bad behavior.
- tialaramex 3y agoIn regard specifically of statues and monuments, we should not erect statues of people but of ideas. New York has a tremendously famous statue, it is not a statue of a person, it's a statue of an idea and ideas are something we can aspire to in a way we cannot and should not for people. Courthouses often feature Lady Justice, who likewise is an idea. We might erect more statues of Hope, and of Beauty, we have built many symbolic tombs said to contain an "Unknown soldier", again symbolising an idea, not the individual even in cases where a specific unidentified corpse has been entombed.