4 ms·
I mostly agree. The only fine point I'd disagree on is that there is a significant (academic) camp that believes that language equates to understanding. That to
by godelski 3y ago
I mostly agree. The only fine point I'd disagree on is that there is a significant (academic) camp that believes that language equates to understanding. That to properly speak requires understanding (fwiw, I think LLMs demonstrate that this isn't true). So I definitely understand the Layman confusion. But we'd have to get into other arguments like embodiment, if cognition is functional, and many other philosophical discussions. I don't think the public is generally acquainted with these ideas and it is certainly clear that a growing number of researchers aren't either. There's just too much to learn that it's easy to push of other things, especially as we chase benchmarks.
So I understand how people get confused, which is why I try to respond in detail. But also I think many focus on tiny discrepancies or are willing to argue from a novice perspective as if it is authoritative (which corelates strongly with expertise). But I agree, there is a lot we don't know. But there are some things we can reject, which is all I'm trying to do and I think we agree there. Maybe you agree with my nit picking.