11 ms·
> Outside of that it's egalitarian and openly accessible to a greater degree than anywhere else on the internet Except for all of the hate, vitriol, prejudice,
by JohnFen 3y ago
> Outside of that it's egalitarian and openly accessible to a greater degree than anywhere else on the internet
Except for all of the hate, vitriol, prejudice, and disregard for the basic humanity of others, it's egalitarian and accessible??
- brookst 3y agoWell, sure, if you’re not one of those people, the abuse isn’t even targeted at you.
- GenerocUsername 3y agoNot true. As a member of one of the largest, mainstream segments of America, I constantly feel attacked while browsing 4chan. Your choice to engage is entirely based on your ability to filter and rationalize
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Applejinx 3y agoHuh. I don't hang out on 4chan but I've spent time there, for instance as a would-be draw, ah, 'friend'. Doesn't matter who you are, you constantly ARE attacked while browsing 4chan. That's kind of the point. Nobody gets to be the in crowd and protected: the closest I've seen of that is for instance literal Trump and Putin, and I don't believe for a second they are truly exempt: the more certain /pol/sters try to make them be protected, the more it backfires with 4chan. Whether it is in ANY WAY USEFUL to go to a place where everybody hates you and you hate them right back and that's what the community is, that's another question. Looking back on my relation to such things, part of the reason I drifted off was that I found things to care about or be interested in, didn't matter what, and having any arbitrary interest was as good as 4chan, at dealing with the worthlessness and ennui. 4chan is a really good place to spend time if you haven't killed yourself yet. If you can connect with pretty much anything else in the universe, the other thing has a pretty easy time showing its appeal compared to 4chan. For instance, I got into MLP fandom, bronies. That came off 4chan, a great example of how channers can be redirected into anything else no matter how inappropriate, just as a relief from being channers. It's always gonna be there at the end of the line, when there's nothing else but death. But then, there are actually plenty of other things, 4chan is only one angle a person can take. It's not entirely about choice, though. As choice erodes, 4chan beckons (while flipping you off).
- eindiran 3y agoThis is a deep misunderstanding of 4chan, enough so that I find it difficult to believe you've even seen any board on the site you are discussing. The abuse is directed at everyone; no matter what opinion you share, no matter who you are, you will be verbally abused in a variety of ways. Totally innocuous opinions that you would be lauded for or totally ignored for on another site are just cause for being berated and harassed on 4chan, though the extent of it is largely governed by the culture of the particular board. I think this is what OP meant by "egalitarian" (though I certainly wouldn't have chosen that word) -- equal opportunity abuse. This shared constant toxicity plus no karma/upvotes and no attachment to an online persona through anonymity mean that the playing ground is perhaps uniquely level.
- bmarquez 3y ago> The abuse is directed at everyone; no matter what opinion you share, no matter who you are, you will be verbally abused in a variety of ways. Yeah, this is what people misunderstand about 4chan. Obviously my race gets a lot of flak, but I've even seen racial slurs about white Europeans I've never heard anywhere else. I'm not saying it's morally right, but it feels more of a hazing tactic than legitimate hatred. Once you pass that filter you have access to some interesting information.
- AbrahamParangi 3y ago4chan has the most egalitarian slur ecosystem I've ever seen, it's incredible.
- UncleMeat 3y agoBut it is absolutely not the case that the abuse is the same magnitude at everyone.
- buggyipadmettoo 3y agoAnd? Imagine, for example, a comedian who pokes fun at all groups exactly equally. There are infinite types of people, he wouldn’t be able to say a word. Different things are different and that’s not inherently wrong.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- JohnFen 3y ago> the abuse isn’t even targeted at you. This doesn't actually make a difference one way or another. Abuse is abuse.
- flangola7 3y agoYup. Go measure how often someone is accused of being a groomer pedo, simply because they're trans or have trans kids, vs how often someone is accused of being a groomer pedo, simply benzoate they're cis or have cis kids. The ratio is not 50:50. It isn't even 95:5.
- thot_experiment 3y agoIt's absolutely not for everyone, but I think the anonymous nature makes it so low stakes it's trivially easy for me to just not care, not engage. You can just ignore things you don't like!
- mjr00 3y ago> You can just ignore things you don't like! I do think this is one of the big hidden problems with upvote/like systems. Seeing a post you don't like or disagree with on Twitter/Facebook/Reddit with a lot of likes/retweets/upvotes/etc psychologically puts you on the defensive. 10,000 likes on a post you disagree with means you're up against an army of 10,000 people who disagreed with you! So you do what's natural: you fight back, you summon your own army of people (hoping to get a respectable counter-army of likes). This creates a toxic environment and you can see it play out on Twitter: every Democrat-leaning tweet will have its top reply be a Republican-leaning tweet with a counter-point, and every Republican with a Democrat. Meanwhile, on 4chan or other old-style message board withouts those systems... yeah, it's just some asshole with a stupid opinion. Just ignore them, no need to waste effort engaging.
- ddq 3y agoArguably, the addition of showing links to all the replies to a comment could have contributed towards 4chan's drift further into engagement-baiting content. It's the closest analogue to the visual, numeric feedback mechanism you describe. Interesting because from a functional user experience perspective, it's an objectively useful feature for navigating discussions. An obvious addition in terms of web design, yet with unforeseen repercussions. The medium is the message, after all.
- mjr00 3y agoVery true! But even then, the dynamic is a bit different. Reply-links on a post that's an obvious joke are analogous to upvotes, but reply-links on a politically controversial topic could be anything, though most likely disagreements. Plus the absolute number is going to be orders of magnitudes smaller than likes. But I do agree it's contributed to bait posts a lot, yeah. Interesting to see the impact of such a seemingly small UX change.
- anononaut 3y agoIt's a deliberate gatekeeping mechanism. 4chan isn't a monolith, either. Some communities are tucked well enough away that it isn't _as_ needed. Furthermore, it isn't hate of "others" so much as it's a hate of all.
- JohnFen 3y ago> Furthermore, it isn't hate of "others" so much as it's a hate of all. I don't understand what you mean, unless you mean posters on 4chan hate themselves. Anyone who isn't you is an other, after all.
- anononaut 3y agoYou will never find a more self-loathing bunch, in fact! However, there are several recurring threads, some older than Reddit, dedicated to self improvement and escaping neetdom. There are also threads openly embracing it.
- pessimizer 3y agoPlenty of people on 4chan don't hate anyone.
- Levitz 3y agoIt's more egalitarian and accessible than any other social media I can think of, yes. In 4chan a literal nazi, a drag queen, a bona-fide pedophile and a luddite can exchange opinions with no prejudice, because none of them know anyone else's background. You might think that these people can't talk about certain things, but any subject in which discussion becomes too caustic simply doesn't even take place in other platforms, and not every discussion is a life or death discussion, they can talk about photography just fine.
- csin 3y ago"In 4chan a literal nazi, a drag queen, a bona-fide pedophile and a luddite can exchange opinions..." This is overly romantic. I just visited /g/. Less than 1 min in, I see "nigger" and "faggot". I'm sure there are blacks, gays and drag queens that see value in 4chan and are desensitized to those words. But, I'd estimate 99% of the population is white men/boys with antisocial tendencies. Which is fine. There's nothing wrong with like minded people building a village. But let's not pretend the culture of the site, doesn't instantly weed out a huge chunk of multiple demographics.
- bobsmooth 3y ago>But, I'd estimate 99% of the population is white men/boys with antisocial tendencies. You'd be wrong https://knowyourmeme.com/photos/1220127-pol https://knowyourmeme.com/photos/1220127-pol
- hhmc 3y agoone photo isn't data
- bobsmooth 3y agoIt directly refutes OP's "estimation".
- RavingGoat 3y ago
- korse 3y agoI really value places where discussion can happen without gatekeeping. The worst is 2FA or a phone number IMHO, however nothing compares to being able to jump straight into the pool. IRC is one such place and 4chan is another. Even the HN crowd appears to agree[1]. For everything else there is documentation, experimentation, social clubs and entertainment. 1. There is a 'account system' for reputation, but it is trivial to auto generate throwaway accounts for 'hot takes' or counter group-think. There are even simple mirror websites that allow for browsing without hiding flagged posts. No Edit:[I don't think any] attempts have been made to reign this behavior in, likely for good reason. Perhaps it keeps the discourse interesting and encourages lateral thinking?
- Miraste 3y agoYou don't even need a mirror website, hiding flagged posts is a setting.
- Akronymus 3y agoI would call the tone of 4chan (insulting everything and anyone) to be gatekeeping, specifically against those who wish to have more moderation/"nicer" discourse. IMO gatekeeping (by the community) is a good/necessary thing for spaces to not become completely gutted/become kicked out of what was formerly your space. I think this image sums it up quite well. https://img.ifunny.co/images/8f4199becd35483d8f498f9ccd0eb73f405de8e49e9211a239997e5a60684d4d_1.jpg https://img.ifunny.co/images/8f4199becd35483d8f498f9ccd0eb73...
- thegodtsar 3y ago4chan is the perfect example of what society looks like when nobody plays control nazi with a zen stick! The people that can't stand it are more fucked up than the ones on it. They just don't know it yet or bothered to look.
- Applejinx 3y ago[flagged]
- pessimizer 3y agoNone of those things prevent you from using the site or limit any of its features (accessibility), and your voice is exactly as loud as everyone else's and their judgment of you is only a judgment of what you've just said (egalitarian.) Just listing a bunch of unrelated shit that upsets you isn't responsive to the comment you're replying to.
- treprinum 3y agoYou can have a freedom or order, but not both at the same time. Most social networks decided for the order, suppressing freedom. Freedom brings some positives and many negatives, that's life I guess.
- Fricken 3y agoOther social media platforms are by and large just more passive aggressive variants of 4chan.
- colordrops 3y agoYes. It's anonymous, so no one knows who you are. It's unfiltered, so anyone can post. Some community members can be assholes, but that doesn't change those two basic ground rules. Those problems you list are present on every online forum and are orthogonal to being free and egalitarian.
- oilchange 3y ago> Except for all of the hate, vitriol, prejudice, and disregard for the basic humanity of others, it's egalitarian and accessible?? What's more egalitarian and accessible than allowing all "hate", "vitriol", "prejudice" and "disregard for the basic humanity of others"? What you do you prefer? A non-egalitarian and inaccessible place where only the hate, vitriol, prejudice, etc you agree with is allowed?
- AlecSchueler 3y agoYou say that like the latter choice is ludicrous, but community moderation is very normal online and off.
- account42 3y agoNormal maybe but that doesn't make desirable, certainly not for everyone - hence spaces like 4chan.
- AlecSchueler 3y agoTrue but we also live in lands of common law, and 4chan is still at the base level limited by those.
- mtrower 3y ago> relating to or believing in the principle that all people are equal and deserve equal rights and opportunities. Everyone gets equal right and opportunity to demean each other equally!
- opportune 3y agoI think a lot of this is a cultural issue you learn to get over. Outside of pol, it’s just shock-humor teenage boy talk. I’m Jewish and mentally filter out all the antisemitic stuff without even thinking about it. 95% of the content outside certain pockets is not even antisemitic, it’s just a shock humor phrase used independently of any actual relation to being Jewish like the term “goyslop”. And yeah, a certain portion of the population does actually hate Jews/transgender people/black people. But when you post nobody knows you are like that. It’s ego-less, you don’t even have an account, so you really don’t even have any reason to care because it’s not directed at you in particular, so it’s just like if you saw something racist on Twitter. Just a very different model compared to the pseudonymous forums/Reddit/hn and fully-linked regular social media.