4 ms·
I'm a big fan of liberating data (especially my own!) from walled gardens, but I have to assume that whatever they're doing is against Instagram's terms and Ins
by xnx 3y ago
I'm a big fan of liberating data (especially my own!) from walled gardens, but I have to assume that whatever they're doing is against Instagram's terms and Instagram will do everything to stop/break this.
- naillo 3y agoThe startup strategy of knowingly breaking laws for brand awareness and picking up some users like this and then removing it once you get caught.
- hbn 3y agoFrom what I read in another comment, it takes advantage of the data export function Instagram themselves offer
- not2b 3y agoIt would appear that you assume incorrectly. Instagram will let you dump all your data into a JSON. All Pixelfed is doing is reading that JSON. Pixelfed has no contract with Meta that would block them from reading in that JSON.
- nfriedly 3y ago> Pixelfed has no contract with Meta that would block them from reading in that JSON. I think they're using OAuth to connect the accounts, and I believe Meta requires developers click through some agreement to do that. Edit: I was wrong, see below.
- Stephen304 3y agoThere is no oauth involved, the import works by requesting your instagram zip archive and then selecting the downloaded zip file in Pixelfed. You can check out the code here: https://github.com/pixelfed/pixelfed/blob/dev/resources/assets/components/AccountImport.vue https://github.com/pixelfed/pixelfed/blob/dev/resources/asse... The neat thing is that it unzips the file locally and only uploads the posts you select, which Dansup says helped get around very large instagram archives and also means you don't have to worry about posts you don't want imported being sent to the pixelfed server.
- smashah 3y ago> Pixelfed has no contract with Meta As a victim of Meta's Cease and Desists for open-wa, the contract terms is in the Terms of Service that anyone associated with Pixelfed, or anyone associated with the development of Pixelfed has ever accepted regardless if it's a personal or testing account. In these ToS agreements, Meta believes they can prevent anyone making any tools that they deem break any of their ridiculous terms of service. I literally had to stop working on my OSS project/tool due to this bullying. Unfortunately I, or other Devs, do not have enough resources to fight this immoral megacorp so therefore they win our compliance.
- hospitalJail 3y ago>walled gardens This is marketing speak. Do not call it walled gardens. Called it curated, fixed, whatever. Gardens have delicious fruits, vegetables, and beautiful flowers. It creates a positive emotional spin on what is otherwise something bad for consumers.
- robertlagrant 3y agoClearly you've not seen most gardens.
- true_blue 3y agoI've only ever heard "walled garden" used in a negative sense, so I think most people get that it's not meant to be a good thing. Emphasis is placed on the "wall" rather than the "garden".
- blendergeek 3y agoCurated sounds much more positive than "walled". If you don't like garden, say "walled city".
- helsinkiandrew 3y agoInstagram (Facebook graph) API allows extraction of data and “Sharing to/from other platforms” is (currently) an accepted use.
- zeruch 3y agoIG has to allow an export function, if nothing else to help with compliance (e.g. CCPA) and in a digestible format. All PF has done is built a parser for said JSON formatting.