2 ms·
I have to say it because a lot of HN users try to convince me that GPT has understanding. We actually have 0 ML models that demonstrate understanding. Frankly,
by godelski 3y ago
I have to say it because a lot of HN users try to convince me that GPT has understanding. We actually have 0 ML models that demonstrate understanding. Frankly, we don't know if this is even possible yet. Sure, in the future I believe we'll have AGI, but an AGI would likely recognize that my statement is contextualized around the current environment and fitting common human speech patters rather than making an absolute immutable statement.
- silverbax88 3y agoThey are just stochastic parrots. Impressive and useful, but that's all they are.
- Timon3 3y agoThe comment above is a completely original thought. It was not memorized and pattern-matched.
- Ajedi32 3y agoDepends on how you define "understanding" I guess, but it certainly seems to me like GPT-4 "understands" the concept of weight well enough to not be tripped up by this particular logic puzzle. You can argue it's just an imitation of "understanding" and not the "real thing", but how good does an imitation have to be before it's functionally identical to the real thing? You can argue different cherry-picked examples seem to demonstrate a lack of understanding, but does that mean it doesn't possess understanding in general or just that it doesn't understand those particular topics? I agree GPT-4 is not a human-like AGI, and that the people expecting it to behave as one or expecting a future version right around the corner that does are likely in for disappointment. But at the same time, LLMs are capable of writing coherent, never-before-seen code from natural language instructions, solving basic never-before-seen natural language logic puzzles, and playing half-decent chess moves from never-before-seen positions[1], all in a single model that was never specifically trained to do any of those things. To say those tasks don't require at least some level of intelligence or "understanding" seems far fetched to me. [1]: https://dkb.blog/p/chatgpts-chess-elo-is-1400 https://dkb.blog/p/chatgpts-chess-elo-is-1400
- godelski 3y ago> You can argue different cherry-picked examples seem to demonstrate a lack of understanding To be clear, an example does not necessitate cherry-picking. Cherry picking specifically requires one to ignore evidence to the contrary. There's a certain irony here. The reason I state this is because the criteria upon which you give me is impossible. The list of examples is non-exhaustive. Nor do I have infinite time or space in which to provide these examples. The example was shown because it demonstrates a simple question that we'd expect any reasonable understanding creature, that knows what a pound and kilogram are, to be able to answer. The LLM demonstrates that it has the requisite knowledge, that it knows the relation between the two units, but it fails to make the correct conclusions which requires the understanding part: putting the knowledge together. The follow-up question also is an example, and a different one for that matter. I'm not sure your link creates a compelling argument. This is despite the fact that Chess itself is not generally considered a good setting for testing understanding. I mean we've pretty much agreed on that even before Deep Blue. We need to be very careful in how we state things and try to interpret others. I hope I have not mischaracterized your claims. But I'd also encourage you to not be so antagonistic with others, especially while demonstrating the very thing you accuse them of. Internet comments are not academic and that's okay, but we should still try to be friendly. Not that a little poking won't happen.
- Ajedi32 3y agoI'm not sure why you interpreted my comment as "antagonistic" or "unfriendly". Yes I do disagree with you (at least assuming I'm understanding you correctly), but I'm not attacking you personally, just your argument. I guess it's fair to say my examples are cherry-picked too (though I didn't really give specific examples in my comment so much as entire general categories of problems ChatGPT is known to be proficient at solving). But they aren't so cherry-picked as for "random chance" or "that example was in the training data verbatim" to be possible explanations. It's not like I had ChatGPT answer 100 billion questions and am only showing you the top 0.1%. It's very common for ChatGPT to be perfectly correct even when answering logic puzzles or coding problems not in its training set. So if not those then what's your explanation other than "understanding"? On the flip side, I don't think it's possible to prove ChatGPT does not posses understanding with individual examples. (And it seems you agree?) Those are easily dismissable as just "ChatGPT isn't great at that particular task". Particularly given how many other tasks ChatGPT is great at. Scott Alexander figured this out back in 2019 before GPT-3 was even a thing (let alone ChatGPT), I think it's worth a read: https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/02/19/gpt-2-as-step-toward-general-intelligence/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/02/19/gpt-2-as-step-toward-g... > The example was shown because it demonstrates a simple question that we'd expect any reasonable understanding creature, that knows what a pound and kilogram are, to be able to answer. Not really though. The "pound of bricks or pound of feathers" question is specifically designed to trip up humans, and the specific formulation you used seems specifically designed to trip up LLMs (by playing off their tenancy to pattern match common sayings), yet despite those disadvantages GPT-4 succeeds. Further, I don't think "I'd expect even a child to be able to answer this" is a good metric. ChatGPT isn't human, so we shouldn't expect it to be good at everything humans are good at just because it's good at some things humans are good at. Again, I'm not trying to argue ChatGPT is a human-like AGI.
- fragmede 3y agohttps://chat.openai.com/share/e7157554-6534-4b73-98b9-672e474254bf https://chat.openai.com/share/e7157554-6534-4b73-98b9-672e47... I used two words that probably don't exist anywhere in the training data and asked it (ChatGPT-3) to compare the weight of a kilogram of one vs an lb of the other. It initially gets it wrong, but when asked to show its work, it's suddenly able to decide that a kilogram of something is heavier than a pound of something. Using understanding or reasoning, or stochastic parroting; whatever you want to call it. I'm not claiming it's AGI, or sentient, but it's also clearly not just a Markov chain.
- godelski 3y agoBe careful, some of the questions you ask are leading. This can be quite difficult because you can't give it any information. Think about if you were to program this, how you would ask it to automate and find a stopping criteria without hinting to it anything. The way I did it uses the same response because you could at least grab the output and compare (easier said than done). It is really easy to hint to it information. "why would that be the same? show your work" Hints at an error. If someone asked you that while solving a math problem would you think you made a mistake? Granted my question also hints as a mistake, but through repetition a reasoning entity would figure out I'm going to continually ask that and to stop second guessing itself.