3 ms·
It's hard for the public to understand most court rulings, especially when the headlines are always so alarmist and yet the rulings, especially SCOTUS rulings,
by qingcharles 3y ago
It's hard for the public to understand most court rulings, especially when the headlines are always so alarmist and yet the rulings, especially SCOTUS rulings, are usually so incredibly narrow and on some tiny statutory interpretation.
This case is a classic "nothing to see here" moment being paraded as if the sky is falling.
I get it though, I sometimes have to read a ruling five times just to figure out what the hell has been decided.
- jfengel 3y agoThe vast majority of SCOTUS rulings are narrow and largely irrelevant. They also usually attract little attention. The cases where SCOTUS attracts the most attention are the ones where fairly broad decisions are made, or at least hinted at. The public is usually wrong in their understanding of it -- as non-experts practically always are. Nonetheless, SCOTUS does make, several times a year, decisions that have a direct bearing on people's lives. They may not understand the nuances of the decision but they know when their rights have expanded or collapsed. Such decisions are usually issued at the end of June. Expect there to be several significant and not-at-all-narrow decisions very soon.
- qingcharles 3y agoI live for all the 4th Amendment decisions. It's been an interesting decade for those with the changes in technology. I'd still love SCOTUS to rule that it's a 4th Amend. violation to access my stored email without a warrant. Still only an appellate decision on the topic from the 6th Cir.