2 ms·
I discovered a related problem before, while integrating with an enterprise customer/partner. Some critical software they used was erroneously signing&validati
by neilv 3y ago
I discovered a related problem before, while integrating with an enterprise customer/partner. Some critical software they used was erroneously signing&validating the wrong part/extent of a very security-sensitive message.
I raised the issue on my company's end, and we had to explain to the customer/partner their big problem.
> On macOS, we could reveal a surprising result: although Microsoft Office indicates that the document is protected by a signature, the signature is not validated.
I wonder whether someone discovered the incorrect digital signatures approach while working with the code on the occasion of a MacOS port/implementation, slammed the brakes on that while escalating the issue internally, a decision was made to keep it quiet, and the MacOS implementation was shipped just stubbing out the signature validation behavior (or otherwise made to always claim validation OK)?
I wonder whether these broken digital signatures were exploited in the wild. Were forged invoices paid, or banking details changed, while trusting the signature? Was a digital signature held up as evidence in legal proceedings? Are there any automated systems that rely upon the digital signatures in these documents?
> acknowledged and awarded our research with a bug bounty.
Rather than just uncomfortable conversations everyone wishes they weren't a part of... there's cake? :)