7 ms·
It's weird how any mention of "hate" or "hate speech" or "hate groups" in an article immediately causes Hacker News to segfault and the first comment is always
by krapp 3y ago
It's weird how any mention of "hate" or "hate speech" or "hate groups" in an article immediately causes Hacker News to segfault and the first comment is always asking for a definition of the word.
And yet, in every argument defending hate speech under the principle of absolute free speech, or denouncing "the left" or "the wokes" or whatever the bugbear of the moment is, they seem to know exactly what hate means and how to apply it.
Anyway, since no one is going to bother reading TFA and this thread is probably going to be thoroughly derailed and flagged, the effect seems to be that deplatforming works:
We study the effects of six network disruptions of designated and banned hate-based organizations on Facebook, in which known members of the organizations were removed from the platform, by examining the online engagements of the audience of the organization. We show that on average, the network disruptions reduced the consumption and production of hateful content, along with engagement within the network among audience members. The results suggest that strategies of targeted removals, such as leadership removal and network degradation efforts, can reduce the ability of hate organizations to successfully operate online.
- commandlinefan 3y ago"Censoring people reduces their ability to communicate" is a "water is wet" finding, though. Of course the discussion turns to "when is this actually ok" because we've seen it abused over and over and over again (and only questionably ever used legitimately).
- youreincorrect 3y agoExactly. And, furthermore, the finding is akin to a form of survivorship bias. 'We found they stopped talking to each other and promoting hate online.' Okay, and what did they do next? Did they just stop hating people? Did they figure out a way to start meeting in person without Facebook to mediate the conversation? Did some of them become increasingly isolated that they decided to act out? Did some people who weren't members of the hate group happen to see this form of censorship and start to change their own minds? I'm not saying any of these outcomes are what happened or are inevitable, I'm wondering how they can call this real science when they don't even bother looking at the other effects outside of their water-is-wet conclusion.
- krapp 3y ago>Okay, and what did they do next? Did they just stop hating people? Did they figure out a way to start meeting in person without Facebook to mediate the conversation? Did some of them become increasingly isolated that they decided to act out? Did some people who weren't members of the hate group happen to see this form of censorship and start to change their own minds? Given that the target audience they were studying were users of the platforms, and the effect was the consumption and spread of hate speech within that population and on those platforms, I don't think that including n+ order effects across every other facet of society would have been necessary, or even possible.