6 ms·
At least in Europe, electronic signatures of a certain form are legally equivalent to handwritten signatures [0], and are increasingly used as such. Emails don’
by layer8 3y ago
At least in Europe, electronic signatures of a certain form are legally equivalent to handwritten signatures [0], and are increasingly used as such. Emails don’t provide that legal value.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EIDAS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EIDAS
- cedilla 3y agoI agree, in Europe digital signatures are very common now. Although at least for me it's almost exclusively PDFs.
- londons_explore 3y ago> Emails don’t provide that legal value. In general, agreeing to something by text in an email is as legally enforceable as a signature.
- logifail 3y ago> In general [..] ...but apparently not always. Not something I'd want to bet my business or reputation on. "AUSTRIA’s Federal Administrative Court [..] declared a framework contract from Austrian Federal Railways (ÖBB) to Stadler for the delivery of up to 186 double-deck trains to be null and void due to an alleged formal error in the qualified electronic signature of the offer." (September 2021) https://www.railjournal.com/news/austrian-court-annuls-stadlers-obb-train-contract/ https://www.railjournal.com/news/austrian-court-annuls-stadl...
- c00lio 3y agoThat is about a public tender, where there are "form requirements", meaning that certain documents and signatures have to conform to the required form. Usually that means "in writing, on paper, with signatures made by hand" or the new legally accepted replacement of secure electronic signatures. Sometimes it might even mean signing the paper in front of a notary, e.g. for contracts regarding the sale of real estate. But in general, outside clearly defined exceptions, contracts and declarations do not have a form requirement, so even oral agreement or "conclusive behaviour" (sign language, point-and-grunt, silently carrying an item to the cash register) are absolutely valid. Of course, when in doubt, proving the exact content of such an unwritten contract may be hard.
- D13Fd 3y ago> But in general, outside clearly defined exceptions, contracts and declarations do not have a form requirement, so even oral agreement or "conclusive behaviour" (sign language, point-and-grunt, silently carrying an item to the cash register) are absolutely valid. Correct in the US, although it's worth mentioning the Statute of Frauds and the Uniform Commercial Code: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statute_of_frauds https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statute_of_frauds https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniform_Commercial_Code https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniform_Commercial_Code
- ogig 3y agoTrue, our company constantly use certificate based signatures, and government agencies emit most documents with the same method, almost always on pdfs. Tho most people tend to use AutoFirma, a java program written by the government for signing and checking signatures validity. I would love to see it thoroughly audited too.
- tpurves 3y agoI think the main point the parent comment is making is that, today and historically, the great majority of contract disputes today don't involve disputing (analog or digital) signatures. People usually dispute about all the other terms rather that about the act of having signed it. [Even though analog signatures aren't particularly secure either] However, if Microsoft signatures have now became more forgeable at scale, perhaps we could see some rash of fake contract fraud in the future where disputing fact of signature becomes more common.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ClarityJones 3y agoThe question of signing generally arises with dueling forms, where there's no dispute that "a" 20-page contract was signed on June 4, 2017, and that this is page 20, with all of the signatures, but... What did that contract say in Paragraph G on Page 12? Perhaps the bank only retained page 20, and is saying that they used the same master form for every mortgage and the master form says "this" on page 12. Or one party discovers that other has misplaced their copy of the contract and then shows up with a copy that has advantageous wording on page 12.
- wongarsu 3y agoOn "serious" contracts, it's common to put your initials on each page, or to fan out the stack of papers and sign the margin so that each page contains part of that signature. Both are in addition to the "real" signature at the end, and provide some protection against exactly these kinds of problems. I guess a cryptographer would add a hash of all preceding pages on the last page.
- CuriousCosmic 3y ago> I guess a cryptographer would add a hash of all preceding pages on the last page. That's basically how hashes and signatures work anyways. They basically take in the result of the previous block and integrate it into the new block so that if you change any part of the previous parts, the whole thing breaks. Edit: I should specify this is how the algorithms themself work. Implementations can fuck this up (and they do a lot).
- c00lio 3y agoEIDAS isn't worth the paper (pun intended) it is written on, if insecure "click a link in an email"-signature schemes such as https://help.eversign.com/hc/en-us/articles/6664408666013-Is-Xodo-Sign-Legally-Binding- https://help.eversign.com/hc/en-us/articles/6664408666013-Is... can claim compliance...
- 1MachineElf 3y agoDisclaimer: I'm not familiar with this service or EIDAS, so my comment might be entirely off the mark. The decision to require users to use an emailed link to view and sign a message could stem from DLP requirements. Emails are plain-text and therefore any sensitive data leaked could be irreversibly exposed. By keeping the messages inside a system that requires authentication, there is less likelihood that a someone besides the intended recipient will interact with the message. Such systems also support auditability and DLP scanning.
- layer8 3y agoI don’t know where you’re taking “click a link in an email” from, but that’s decidedly not how eIDAS works. The private keys must be hardware-protected and under the sole control of an identified signer, which usually means either a physical token or a 2FA-protected remote key in an HSM. In addition, a prior ID verification procedure like video ID or a face-to-face verification is required.
- c00lio 3y agoWell. Eversign holds the key and promises to only use it when you authenticated by clicking the link in the email that was sent to you personally. eIDAS was intentionally formulated to allow such signature services, making the whole thing quite pointless from a security perspective.
- layer8 3y agoService providers must undergo audits to ensure that the security measures they take meet the eIDAS requirements. This includes strong protective measures against unauthorized access to private keys. The keys are usually unrecoverable when the end user has lost their credentials. It’s actually quite involved and costly to become such an accredited provider.
- psychphysic 3y agoIn the UK at least it you email agreeing to terms and then appear to be complying you're unlikely to get out of it. Common examples are someone is sent a contract of employment unfortunately often after starting and they don't sign it. If they have been coming into work broadly in line with that contract so long as it's fair, employee and employer are bound by it. Here is an interesting edge case in the UK [0]. Long story short if you give someone the ability to sign on your behalf and appear to consider parties bound by that it's binding. In a personal sense, I send out appointment letters but my secretary does it for me. I consider myself as bound to that as if I arranged it myself. I gave the secretary latitude to book appointments for me, and I usually turn up to those appointments. If that letter is signed, or if it's by my hand. Doesn't legally matter as much as you'd imagine. [0] https://www.lexisnexis.co.uk/blog/banking-and-finance/gordon-ramsay-bound-by-ghost-signature-of-guarantee https://www.lexisnexis.co.uk/blog/banking-and-finance/gordon...
- justincormack 3y ago"An Englishman's word is his bond" as the old saying goes, verbal contracts are enforceable. The whole financial system used to run on purely verbal contracts. There are some requirements, there has to be a consideration for example. I am not sure this is true in other legal systems though.
- zzbn00 3y agoAs an interesting edge case, in an auction contract can be formed without words either: it is formed on the "fall of the hammer" https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1979/54 https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1979/54
- denton-scratch 3y agoI don't know about other places; but in the UK, a contract doesn't even have to be written down, let alone signed. Of course, an unwritten contract is no more valuable than the paper it's (not) written on; and either party can dispute the terms. But you can still make a valid contract with a verbal agreement and a shake of hands. But don't do this unless you trust your co-contractor!
- CrampusDestrus 3y ago>Emails don’t provide that legal value. In Italy there is an officially legislated signed email service that has legal value
- dfox 3y agoThe service probably has nothing to do with email and is only tangentially related to eIDAS. At least that is the case in Czech Republic. One surprising fact about such systems is that they tend to produce blockchain-like audit log and predate bitcoin by several years.
- necovek 3y agoAppend-only stores of record predate "blockchain" by decades: a distributed trust/consensus algorithm is the real innovation in Bitcoin.
- bogeholm 3y agoI’ve found the per-country overview of general legality of digital signatures on DocuSign [0] quite informative. As an example, in DK an email constitutes a valid contract for most purposes. [0] https://www.docusign.com/products/electronic-signature/legality/global https://www.docusign.com/products/electronic-signature/legal...
- necovek 3y agoWhich makes attacks like these even worse: Serbian law, for instance, has a clause how you are not allowed to dispute an electronic signature signed using an officially issued eID certificate. While I am sure that clause can be nulled and voided if it came to that, the fact that the responsibility is on the signee is terrible.
- bombolo 3y agoIn italy we have PEC, which is legally regulated signed emails