3 ms·
I'm an American, but I have a very international backstory (so I am sympathetic to other PoVs). The one thing that the US does have, is that raucous, "Ain't no
by ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago
I'm an American, but I have a very international backstory (so I am sympathetic to other PoVs).
The one thing that the US does have, is that raucous, "Ain't no one gonna tell me what to do!" attitude. It can be annoying as hell, but does mean that we don't react well to authoritative control.
Despite the "whataboutisms" (PRISM, Snowden, etc.), the US is pretty much a proponent of an unfettered Internet.
So whatever replaces it as a main actor, should be fairly representative of all the stakeholders.
- dijit 3y ago> does mean that we don't react well to authoritative control I find that ironic, because US-ians are the first to throw themselves on the pulpit to their chosen deities. Be it politicians (or political parties), especially wealthy people or their favourite corporations. I suppose the difference is that nobody really forces you worship any of these people in particular, you might, from a far, notice that they all center across worship of the economic system. Which is "extract value and externalise cost at all times" with a minor emphasis on equating dollar-worth to intrinsic value to society. EDIT: Downvoting me doesn't really prove anything; You might not feel devout to your overlords but you certainly appear that way from the outside. (from a UK/Swedish perspective~)
- croes 3y ago>Despite the "whataboutisms" (PRISM, Snowden, etc.), the US is pretty much a proponent of an unfettered Internet. It's not whataboutsim, it's one of the reasons for an unfettered Internet. But only if it suits US interests. Do you remember the crypto wars?
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoFair point. Who should replace them? UK? France? Sweden? Germany? Türkiye? Kenya? Argentina? Israel? Iran? China? Every nation has its own agenda. I do find it interesting that everyone was happy to throw mud at the first part, but completely ignored this part: > So whatever replaces it as a main actor, should be fairly representative of all the stakeholders. Consensus is really, really difficult. It’s easy to criticize, but difficult to find common interests.
- surgical_fire 3y agoPerhaps there won't be a consensus. The internet may be ubiquitous now, but its mainstream adoption is barely 2 decades old. Countries are slow to adapt. I think it will be natural that eventually they will try to wrest control, at least within their own jurisdictions. Maybe the age of a more open and global internet will end, and balkanization is inevitable.
- boffinAudio 3y ago> unfettered Internet Unless you point out America's war crimes, crimes against humanity and heinous violations of human rights at scale. And then you will be fettered.
- autoexec 3y ago> It can be annoying as hell, but does mean that we don't react well to authoritative control. I think this is more a fantasy we Americans tell each other, but it isn't true if you actually look at how we live. Police rob, rape, and murder Americans with impunity. Corporations knowingly poison Americans while spending fortunes trying to hide that fact, and they get away with it (only having to surrender a small fraction of the money they made doing it). Still, the jails are filled to overflowing as America locks up more of her own so called "freedom loving" people than any other nation on planet. Americans are obsessed with punishment and we cheer while people are locked away and their lives are ruined. It doesn't matter what they did, or even if they did it. We've got a government full of people nobody is happy with, and we're only given two parties to choose from anyway. Our constitution is a joke, with our most fundamental rights violated routinely. Fair and speedy trials are rare, while excessive bail, excessive fines, and cruel & unusual punishments are commonplace. The fourth amendment is broken on a regular basis and while three letter agencies just ignore it and do whatever they want, police use things like parallel construction to side step our rights as a matter of policy. It's been a constant struggle to retain the first amendment in any way that matters, and the establishment clause may as well not even exist. For all of our "Ain't no one gonna tell me what to do!" attitude there's very little protest about any of it and Americans pretty much shut up and roll over while they're taken advantage of and their rights are violated. "the US is pretty much a proponent of an unfettered Internet." sounds nice, until you remember that even when clear corruption is discovered (https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/05/biggest-isps-paid-for-8-5-million-fake-fcc-comments-opposing-net-neutrality/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/05/biggest-isps-pai...) and assholes like Ajit Pai screw Americans we all just let it happen. America is a race to the bottom where we pay more and get less. I wish Americans really did value freedom and resist authoritative control like we pretend it does. The closest we seem to get is a kind of ignorant belligerence. Americans will burn books and shun mask wearing while patting themselves on the back for being such independent rebels but we continue getting screwed over and over again where it actually matters without truck convoys rushing to fight oppression or mass protests in the streets. I'm not accusing anyone, or blaming them for taking it on the chin. I'm just as guilty as anyone else there, but I do wish we'd stop pretending Americans cared about or valued things we clearly don't. I doubt we'll fix anything while we're busy pretending we're something we're not.