2 ms·
A Solution to the Ship of Theseus
- Quinzel 3y agoInteresting perspective!
- 31337Logic 3y agoAgreed. Very interesting take on the matter. I'm not exactly sure I like the conclusion that identity is subjective, but at least it's coherent.
- jfengel 3y ago"Subjective" is kind of the wrong word. "Relative" is a bit clearer. Identity is relative to the situations in which you need it. Two situations with the same requirements will have the same identity criteria. It's not a matter of opinion (or rather, it could be, if that were relevant to the ontology). It's an objective fact. It's just that a macro-object is many different objective facts, and those facts interact with other facts in different ways.
- transfire 3y agoThats not really a “solution”. In fact, it is almost a given — it is essentially the point of the thought experiment. It forces us to recognize that identity is subjective. In some sense it is a counter argument to the Platonic idea of forms. It becomes really interesting however when you apply it to self-identity and question of a soul. Is there a “self” or is it an illusion? Perhaps there are some things in reality for which this ship analogy does hold?