4 ms·
> No one credible is saying china intentionally released the virus or built it with the intention of building a weapon. To add to this, most countries have tur
by godelski 3y ago
> No one credible is saying china intentionally released the virus or built it with the intention of building a weapon.
To add to this, most countries have turned away from infectious biological weapons because they are near impossible to control. The the release of them might harm your enemies, but at a serious cost to yourself. It is like trying to cut off your enemy's leg by cutting off your own arm. It ends up kinda being like MAD except you're also the aggressor. The threat of a infectious weapon is not from other nations, but from a terrorist organization (which of course dramatically reduces risk). Not to say that this can't happen, but it is well known enough that were a contagious disease to get out, it would be more likely accidental. It would also be odd to release the disease into your own community first. I'm not saying it was or wasn't a lab leak or bioweapon, but if we're discussing weapon vs accident, there's good reason to believe a weapon is unlikely. Gain of research has significant value outside weapons and this also shows you why the weapon arguments against GoF aren't of high concern to those that are close to the work. Contagion weapons are the weapons of those with nothing left to lose (which aren't big/rich countries, even in dire circumstances).
- startupsfail 3y agoCan the lab be sued out of existence for damages? It is quite clear that they did amplification research as they’ve planned. And had inserted the furin site into the coronavirus . And they’ve mismanaged the research and they’ve let the virus to spread. This had caused a lot of damage, in particular the deaths, economical damage, long-covid damages, mental illnesses and diminished IQ (covid brain fog). There’ve been some positive sides: diminished air travel, diminished carbon emissions, transition to work from home, more pedestrian zones in the cities, mRNA vaccine technology. But the negative side from the pandemic is still overwhelming. Arguably this lab should be sued out of existence for damages.
- irjustin 3y agoThat requires corporation of a foreign government that isn't friendly.
- antonvs 3y ago> And had inserted the furin site into the coronavirus A claim was made about that, but it’s far from settled. One could argue it has been debunked. See “SARS-CoV-2 furin cleavage site was not engineered”: https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2211107119 https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2211107119 > And they’ve mismanaged the research and they’ve let the virus to spread. That’s speculation. Irresponsible speculation, in fact, which has been pushed by people who should have known better. But they pushed it for jingoistic reasons. > Arguably this lab should be sued out of existence for damages. That’s an emotional reaction which you’re not examining rationally. If you remove the confirmation bias you’re applying to the evidence, there’s simply no substantial basis for the conclusions you’re reaching.
- junofan 3y agoIt’s speculation because nobody’s been allowed to investigate the lab thoroughly.
- foobiekr 3y agoEngineered is a very careful word choice. None of the properties they call out are things you would not expect from research involving gain of function by evolutionary means.
- startupsfail 3y agoThere is a lab that had planned and did the research. This is well documented. The virus spread had started nearby. There is nothing else that you need to know. There is evidence that the Chinese authorities were suppressing information about the leak (information about that virus had leaked accidentally, by an ophthalmologist that saw cases spreading in his hospital). Yes, it is not clear exactly, how the furin site got there. Was it a long series of mutations and a recombination with another virus in a lab animal? Was it spliced? We’ll never know, unless the scientists responsible would decide to tell how it had happened. But I’m not particularly emotional about that virus. If you read the above, you’ll see that I see positive and negative after effects. Viruses and mistakes happen. But it’d be a good idea to make a point and get rid of that lab. Failures like that should not be rewarded with continual existence.
- sh34r 3y ago> Can the lab be sued out of existence for damages? It's in China, not America. Come on now. The CCP might remove the lab from existence, but they're not gonna do it with a lawsuit.
- startupsfail 3y agoThere is certain amount of justice present in China. They can do it internally. It’s not like they haven’t suffered internally from it.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoThe citizens of China have suffered, but that doesn't really matter to the CCP. Covid has been great for strengthening their central government and all of the technology tools of suppression.
- startupsfail 3y agoI think you’ve been watching too much western propaganda. Nothing is as black and white and China is a complex country.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoSure, but what are your thoughts on the Covid drones of Shanghai: "The drone's female voice also tells listeners, "Control your soul's thirst for freedom. Do not open your windows and sing.""
- oilchange 3y ago> To add to this, most countries have turned away from infectious biological weapons because they are near impossible to control. Most countries ( small to mid-tier ) lack the expertise, will or reason for it. But most major countries are working on biological weapons. If you think the US, Russia, China, UK, France, Germany, Japan, Israel, etc aren't running bio-weapons labs, then you are being too trusting at best or too naive at worst. Or maybe I'm just being too cynical. > The the release of them might harm your enemies, but at a serious cost to yourself. Never prevented intentional disease warfare throughout history. What makes you think leaders aren't willing to hurt their own countries to hurt their enemies? More importantly, what makes you think these countries will develope bio-weapons, but not vaccines for them? > The threat of a infectious weapon is not from other nations, but from a terrorist organization (which of course dramatically reduces risk). Every major terrorist organization is or was created, funded and controlled by major nations. > Contagion weapons are the weapons of those with nothing left to lose (which aren't big/rich countries, even in dire circumstances). And yet, all weapons labs in history were created by big/rich countries. You so desperately want a world without bio-weapons that you are blinded to the contradictions in your argument.
- jcranmer 3y ago> But most major countries are working on biological weapons. If you think the US, Russia, China, UK, France, Germany, Japan, Israel, etc aren't running bio-weapons labs, then you are being too trusting at best or too naive at worst. Or maybe I'm just being too cynical. https://acoup.blog/2020/03/20/collections-why-dont-we-use-chemical-weapons-anymore/ https://acoup.blog/2020/03/20/collections-why-dont-we-use-ch... covers this in some detail (it's geared towards chemical weapons, but biological weapons are the same boat). In short, chemical and biological weapons just aren't useful. For any platform you put it on, conventional explosives will do more damage. For major militaries, there's no point in using them, which is why the "big" military powers have all signed up to the anti-chemical weapons and anti-biological weapons treaties, but not the anti-nuclear or anti-cluster munitions or anti-landmines, etc.
- oilchange 3y ago> For major militaries, there's no point in using them, which is why the "big" military powers have all signed up to the anti-chemical weapons and anti-biological weapons treaties If chemical and biological weapons aren't useful, why does one need a treaty to ban them? Makes one wonder? Is there are treaty to ban feathers as weapons? The fact that there is an anti-biological weapons treaty is proof enough that countries are working on biological weapons, just like the anti-nuclear weapons treaty is proof that countries are working on nukes. The ability to think is a far greater tool than reading silly blogs. Take it from someone who has read too many silly blogs and watch too many silly youtube videos. Also, pretty much every treaty ( international and intranational ) has been broken. Some even say treaties are meant or created to be broken.
- George83728 3y ago> [...] infectious biological weapons because they are near impossible to control. You mean contagious, not infectious. Biological weapons which are infectious but not particularly contagious, such as anthrax, are much easier to control and have been the focus of most biological weapons research. Biological weapons are banned and aren't, used not because they don't work, but because other things work better and with less political fallout. And FWIW, very contagious pathogens could be used as weapons for strategic effect if you had reason to believe they would hurt your economy less than your enemy's. For instance, if you believe your authoritarian government will allow you to flatten the curve but liberal governments will have a disordered response that precludes this. I'm not saying they did it, but the possibility isn't patently absurd.
- P_I_Staker 3y agoCOVID proved that. Who would try to use COVID as a weapon? I guess if you're at war, maybe there'll be less back and forth travel.