6 ms·
The Tyranny of Structurelessness (1970)
- dredmorbius 3y agoA classic and well-deserved HN perennial. Past discussions: - 9 years ago, 120 comments <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7409611 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7409611> - 5 years ago, 20 comments <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17585104 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17585104> - 3 years ago, 19 comments <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24728477 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24728477> - 7 years ago, 54 comments <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11651406 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11651406> - 9 years ago, 15 comments <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7762486 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7762486> - 6 years ago, 2 comments <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15535834 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15535834>
- dang 3y agoThanks! Macroexpanded: Jo Freeman's the Tyranny of Structurelessness (Recommended by Mark Andreesen) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31829486 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31829486 - June 2022 (1 comment) The Tyranny of Structurelessness (1970) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24728477 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24728477 - Oct 2020 (19 comments) The Tyranny of Structurelessness (1973) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17585104 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17585104 - July 2018 (20 comments) The Tyranny of Structurelessness - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15535834 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15535834 - Oct 2017 (2 comments) The Tyranny of Structurelessness (1972) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11651406 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11651406 - May 2016 (54 comments) “Meritocracy” and the Tyranny of Structurelessness - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8495241 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8495241 - Oct 2014 (1 comment) The Tyranny of Structurelessness - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7762486 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7762486 - May 2014 (15 comments) RE: The “Tyranny of Structurelessness” - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7555013 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7555013 - April 2014 (7 comments) The Tyranny of Structurelessness (1970) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7409611 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7409611 - March 2014 (120 comments)
- civilized 3y agoI have often heard of this essay but never read it, because I thought I knew the basic idea. Reading it now, I see much more to it than the basic thesis in the title.
- mjb 3y agoThere are relatively few things I've read that I can definitively point to as having almost instantly changed my mind on something. This is one of them. Reading often offers a broader understanding or different perspective, but seldom a sudden flash on insight. Others short reads that have changed my mind in that way include: - "The Inner Ring" by CS Lewis (https://www.lewissociety.org/innerring/ https://www.lewissociety.org/innerring/) - "On Photography" by Susan Sontag (https://www.amazon.com/Photography-Susan-Sontag/dp/0312420099 https://www.amazon.com/Photography-Susan-Sontag/dp/031242009...) - "Black Souls in White Skins?" by Steve Biko (as far as I can see only widely available as part of the Collection "I write what I like") - "The Two Cultures" by CP Snow (https://sciencepolicy.colorado.edu/students/envs_5110/snow_1959.pdf https://sciencepolicy.colorado.edu/students/envs_5110/snow_1...) (This one is a lot like Freeman's in that many summaries seem to completely misunderstand the argument it is making, and many people assume it says something it doesn't). - "Ironies of Automation" by Lisanne Bainbridge (https://ckrybus.com/static/papers/Bainbridge_1983_Automatica.pdf https://ckrybus.com/static/papers/Bainbridge_1983_Automatica...) - "Risk Management in a Dynamic Society" by Jens Rasmussen (http://sunnyday.mit.edu/16.863/rasmussen-safetyscience.pdf http://sunnyday.mit.edu/16.863/rasmussen-safetyscience.pdf). If you read nothing else, check out Figure 3.
- shanusmagnus 3y agoThanks so much for this list! I'm always on the prowl for things to read that changed how people see the world, but explicit attempts to solicit examples have proved surprisingly unsuccessful. And here you just volunteered it :)
- a_bonobo 3y agoIf you're looking for more, i have some recommendations for longer stuff around personal growth and insights: - Erich Fromm, The Art Of Loving. It's about how love (romantic, interpersonal) is not rosy but hard, hard work. All of Fromm's writing is amazing, but this one (for me) had the most personal impact. Another great one is Fromm's The Sane Society. - Kishimi/Koga's The Courage To Be Disliked. It's classified as self-help, but it's more a pop-psychology summary of Adlerian Psychotherapy. We can choose not to be the product of trauma, or our surroundings. We may get pushed into negative corners by our upbringing, but then we get too comfortable in those negative corners to push ourselves out. The title alludes to a person who has no friends and has a negative image of himself, maybe he's that lonely because he is afraid of being rejected/disliked. He is lonely and miserable, but he is comfortable in the loneliness. It takes courage and hard work on yourself to move out of those holes. - Hillman/Ventura's We've had a Hundred Years Of Psychotherapy And The World's Getting Worse. In a nutshell, the problem is not always with the individual, often it's just the environment; mindfulness will only get you so far if the house is on fire. - Becker's The Denial Of Death. We know we die but we don't realise that. How do we generate meaning in the presence of death? There are 'good' (a life project, pushing societies' boundaries) and 'bad' ways (hedonism, drugs etc.). What are the necessary illusions we should create for ourselves to keep pushing?
- exp1orer 3y agoI love this essay. Anna Weiner's book Uncanny Valley has a great line about it as well: > "it's like no one even read 'The Tyranny of Structurelessness,'" said an engineer who had recently read The Tyranny of Structurelessness.
- xoac 3y agoThis is one of my favorite articles that I heard about here. Someone shared it many years ago. I've been in many organizations like the ones described and things play out the same way. Recommended.
- hgsgm 3y agoThis is for people who don't know why government exists and it's not purely oppression?
- rodgerd 3y agoIt's for people who see all the problems caused by formal structures, think "wait, if we got rid of those structures, we would have a better time of it", and don't want to learn the hard way. Also for those people who are in a flat/no-structure and looking for something that puts words to why things feel wrong.
- jimmaswell 3y agoIt applies to much more. No database schema means you have an implicit schema that's hard to work with for example.
- lll-o-lll 3y agoInteresting seeing agile development (SCRUM) articulated so precisely. > Occasionally, the developed informal structure of the group coincides with an available need that the group can fill in such a way as to give the appearance that an Unstructured group "works." That is, the group has fortuitously developed precisely the kind of structure best suited for engaging in a particular project. > While working in this kind of group is a very heady experience, it is also rare and very hard to replicate. There are almost inevitably four conditions found in such a group; 1) It is task oriented. Its function is very narrow and very specific, like putting on a conference or putting out a newspaper. It is the task that basically structures the group. The task determines what needs to be done and when it needs to be done. It provides a guide by which people can judge their actions and make plans for future activity. 2) It is relatively small and homogeneous. Homogeneity is necessary to insure that participants have a "common language" for interaction. People from widely different backgrounds may provide richness to a consciousness-raising group where each can learn from the others' experience, but too great a diversity among members of a task-oriented group means only that they continually misunderstand each other. Such diverse people interpret words and actions differently. They have different expectations about each other's behavior and judge the results according to different criteria. If everyone knows everyone else well enough to understand the nuances, these can be accommodated. Usually, they only lead to confusion and endless hours spent straightening out conflicts no one ever thought would arise. 3) There is a high degree of communication. Information must be passed on to everyone, opinions checked, work divided up, and participation assured in the relevant decisions. This is only possible if the group is small and people practically live together for the most crucial phases of the task. Needless to say, the number of interactions necessary to involve everybody increases geometrically with the number of participants. This inevitably limits group participants to about five, or excludes some from some of the decisions. Successful groups can be as large as 10 or 15, but only when they are in fact composed of several smaller subgroups which perform specific parts of the task, and whose members overlap with each other so that knowledge of what the different subgroups are doing can be passed around easily. 4) There is a low degree of skill specialization. Not everyone has to be able to do everything, but everything must be able to be done by more than one person. Thus no one is indispensable. To a certain extent, people become interchangeable parts. > While these conditions can occur serendipitously in small groups, this is not possible in large ones. I wonder if the originators of Agile were familiar with this work? At any rate I think it explains that dichotomy between the early developer push for agile - “we found this awesome thing that works!” - contrasted with the later wide-spread industry adoption and general hatred. I.e, the small group only works based on specific, unlikely, circumstance, and the concepts do not scale.
- tsunamifury 3y agoAfter reading this essay I became convinced several different government institutions realized they could tank any grassroots movement by inserting a crazy and letting it go from there. This was of course proven to be the case with the Black Panthers where most of the violent agitators turned out to be FBI agents. This fundamentally changed my view on flat organizations, realizing they were vulnerable to predators with such simple tactics.
- zmgsabst 3y agoAt a society level, people seeking to undermine a community or nation can manufacture consent around radical astroturf movements, eg by having mass media propagandize in their favor while minimizing their crimes. This has been noted as a failure mode of democracy — as people won’t risk their individual reputations to challenge radicals garbed in “noble” causes, until the situation is already dire.
- michaelchisari 3y ago| flat organizations Flat and structureless are not necessarily synonymous. It's certainly possible to have a highly structured yet flat organization with clear roles and non-hierarchical decision-making.
- tsunamifury 3y agoReally? Because Adam Curtis spent something like 3 films and 10 hours to argue otherwise and not without a lot of examples. When there is no authority, predators become the authority.
- dredmorbius 3y ago"Flat" != "no authority". Flat structures may, or may not, have a head. What they don't have is deep hierarchy. Mind that this has its own set of benefits and disadvantages. Fewer deparmental turf battles, but very broad spans of control and/or highly autonomous roles. An ant or bee colony is a flat structure with a strong central control, at least reproductively: the queen. This isn't an ideal comparison, of course, as the individual workers don't take orders from the queen (or anyone else), but instead respond largely based on instinctual behaviours and pheremone signalling (in the case of ants at least, I'm not certain of bees). Flat structures may lack any leadership, or have various rotating or ad hoc leaderships. These are more akin to the structureless organisations Freeman writes of.
- GolDDranks 3y agoThis essay was frequently linked amidst the recent discussions on Rust leadership. The current situation seems to be rather unstructured, and it was pointed out that this is not a desirable thing. https://without.boats/blog/if-you-can-keep-it/ https://without.boats/blog/if-you-can-keep-it/ https://graydon2.dreamwidth.org/307105.html https://graydon2.dreamwidth.org/307105.html
- barbariangrunge 3y ago> Forbidden > You don't have permission to access this resource.
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoProbably the HN hug of death. I was able to read it by following the link at one of the other locations it had been posted on HN previously, eg: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7409611 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7409611
- barbariangrunge 3y agoThanks. Its a really good article so far, I got halfway through before I had to leave for work
- dredmorbius 3y agoThere are several well-known archival services online which will typically serve otherwise unavailable content: - Internet Archive: <https://web.archive.org/web/20020309071211/https://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20020309071211/https://www.jofre...> - Archive.Today: <https://archive.is/M3teQ https://archive.is/M3teQ>
- zczc 3y agoOther sources: https://dnda.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/project_muse_528558.pdf https://dnda.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/project_muse_528... https://thecheapestuniversity.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/tyranny.pdf https://thecheapestuniversity.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01...
- rowanG077 3y agoCouldn't find a better article arguing for static typing.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoIt might have some things to say about agile development, too - and why big-A Agile doesn't look like the "agile" described in the Agile Manifesto.
- simulo 3y agoDavid Graeber on "Tyranny of Structurelessness": "[Many] completely misread Freeman’s essay, and interpret it not as a plea for formal mechanisms to ensure equality, but as a plea for more transparent hierarchy."
- ogogmad 3y agoThat's a more controversial and interesting take than "an informal structure in an organisation is not necessarily better than a formal one".
- stared 3y agoIt is his interpretation presented as if it were an objective truth. As far as I read the essay, Jo Freeman advocates both equality and transparency. In particular, she makes strong points that equality is impossible without transparency.
- DiscourseFan 3y agoI think its fair to say that trying to just rip up "structures" with no respect for the unconscious structural organization of people in society will naturally lead to a re-enforcement of previous hierarchies. But I'm slightly more radical than the author here, in claiming that there is a way to do it, but one that requires constant critique and constant shifting positions of power in the structures generated. It's quite neurotic to try and ceaselessly force structure into a social world to have some sort of stability--structures can never quite capture the full life of a social world and are always resisted for that reason.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoSo organizations need structure, but structure can never be the "right" structure? If so, then what you need is to have structure, but to deliberately make it a non-rigid structure. Make your structure jello, not concrete.
- classified 3y ago> People would try to use the "structureless" group and the informal conference for purposes for which they were unsuitable out of a blind belief that no other means could possibly be anything but oppressive. Negations are really hard. I'm sure the above sentence has one too few or one too many.
- tpmoney 3y agoParses cleanly for me. “People use informal organization even when it is inadequate because they believe all organization is always oppressive”
- leoc 3y agoThis is really a good essay and surely deserves a high profile, but it's disappointing that it, and some bits of angst about Valve's internal situation, seem to be the only discussions of organisational structure that get widely shared these days. Back from about the '70s to the early '90s it seems that there was quite a lot of management-theory/theory-of-the-firm research into different organisational structures and how they affected innovation, ability to change and other desirable or undesirable characteristics of organisations. And it didn't just stay hidden in academia, as the results got a fair amount of coverage in newsmagazines and the like in the early '90s. (Which is how I heard about it: I'm no expert.) As you might expect, the findings on relatively "structureless" orgs seem to have been pretty compatible with Freeman's observations. But there was also research on many other unusual forms of structure and hierarchy, for example the "matrix management" which famously got implemented at Dow Chemical in the 1970s https://hbr.org/1978/05/problems-of-matrix-organizations https://hbr.org/1978/05/problems-of-matrix-organizations . But for some reason interest and attention seems to have completely faded out, at least at the popular level, by about 2000 or so. So the Valve situation gets reported on as if it's some kind of unprecedented novelty, and not an example of a sort of situation whose outcomes had been hashed out pretty thoroughly a decade or more earlier.
- shanusmagnus 3y agoOn a similar journey, just came across sociocracy as one such trying to keep the flame alive [1]. What was interesting for me was to recognize the pieces of such a structure informally existing, in a giant mega-company I worked for. In a vast bureaucratic ecosystem, way down at the forest floor interesting things can happen that the canopy dwellers have no idea about. Of course, being informal, it can only go so far, as the OA describes. [1] https://www.sociocracyforall.org/sociocracy/ https://www.sociocracyforall.org/sociocracy/
- BillyTheMage 3y agoWhat a thinly-veiled piece of authoritarian propaganda, lots of bad arguments in there. I did enjoy this [1] refutation of the article though. I agree with the article I linked in that people who think The Tyranny of Structurelessness is insightful are mostly bookish socially-incompetent people who want to force the rest of us to live sterile rule-bound "lives" (if you can even call that life). - [1] https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/jason-mcquinn-a-review-of-the-tyranny-of-structurelessness-an-organizationalist-repudiation-of https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/jason-mcquinn-a-revi...
- Tomat0 3y agoI'm impressed at McQuinn's capacity to say so little with so many words. This barely addresses the main points of the article, instead repeatedly throwing insults and labels without warrant, hoping something will stick. Nothing's been refuted.
- stilist 3y agoI don’t think it’s a very persuasive rebuttal. I infer that McQuinn is a libertarian, which explains the issue: it amounts to ‘well [as a white man who automatically has power in every social situation I encounter] I haven’t had any problems, unlike those weak-willed dorks’ and bad-faith implications that Freeman supports capitalist structure.
- krunck 3y agoWhether there is structure or no structure, you must always be on guard against the power seekers. They are the universal problem. You must question them, challenge them, and never take your eyes off of them.