3 ms·
This paragraph captures the crux of the problem for me: > In addition, whereas previously there was an elevated standard for applying powers to non-targets, th
by lolinder 3y ago
This paragraph captures the crux of the problem for me:
> In addition, whereas previously there was an elevated standard for applying powers to non-targets, there is now actually a vastly reduced standard compared to actual targets. The ex-ante regulator TIB will need to be convinced that it is proportional to target organization X. However, any non-targets now no longer benefit from an elevated standard. The non-targets in fact benefit from no standards at all anymore.
They're going from a situation where it was considered an extreme measure to get a warrant to break into a victim's machine to a situation where it's now a given that all victims of the target organization are themselves targets unless the oversight body takes affirmative action to deny it in a specific case. If the concern were just about red tape, it would make more sense to remove the special protections that victims previously had and allow the warrant to be extended through the regular warrant process.
This automatic extension solution is a problem because it treats the rights of the victims as lesser than the rights of the suspected criminals. It treats them as collateral damage that can be safely ignored unless someone from higher up specifically decides it's a problem.