3 ms·
I had to find it online. The point of the story appears to justify murder as a legitimate means to enact change. Hard disagree here. I think a movement that tu
by JKCalhoun 3y ago
I had to find it online. The point of the story appears to justify murder as a legitimate means to enact change. Hard disagree here.
I think a movement that turns to murder as a means of gaining power will continue using murder even should it achieve its goals.
Someone in the past pointed out to me that the American Revolution is an exception to that. I don't disagree but so many other examples in history would seem to support my view.
- throwanem 3y agoIt is a very interesting reading of American history in which murder as a tool of statecraft ended with the American Revolution, or indeed at all.
- nemo44x 3y agoYeah it’s sort of the foundation of NRx/Dark Enlightenment in that the Enlightenment and it’s progressivism (the dominant force in Western government the last few hundred years) has resulted in the most violent and destructive governments the world has ever seen. Even when not violent it’s incredibly coercive through its system of creating dependent states and of course justifying it because a democracy happened. Going back to the American revolution it was in essence a battle between the Tories and the Whigs with the rebels and a great deal of the British leadership being Whigs and making “the progress” of Americas founding inevitable.
- throwanem 3y agoYeah, it's sort of the foundation of NRx/Dark Enlightenment to take historical events broadly agreed in all credible quarters to have taken place, and then spin the goddamnedest nonsense anyone ever heard out of them. Not that you'd know it by Moldbug or his imitators, but is possible to criticize American hegemony without playacting Jane Fonda at the Reichskanzlei.
- shmde 3y agoFrom the story ---------- The professor elevated his nose and said sternly, “I don’t believe in violence. It’s immoral.” “It’s unethical ever to use violence,” said the bosun. “I’m terrified of violence,” said the lady passenger. -------------- They are literally talking about people like you in the story lmao. The ship is further going north and they know they are gonna drown if they don't have a violent revolution against the captain and throw him out of the ship(killing him) so that they can turn the ship around. > "The point of the story appears to justify murder as a legitimate means to enact change." Well what the hell do you do in this scenario(in the story) ?? Have a non-violence protest and risk losing lives ?? Or throw the captain off the ship and steer it south ?? Violence/Murder is 1000% justified and is the answer in this story's scenario. “Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable." - John F. Kennedy
- inglor_cz 3y agoI, on the other hand, consider the story to be too simplistic. It reads like an abstract concept hammered out by a smart person far from any actual life-threatening situation, which is what it actually is. The captain and his mates don't necessarily need killing, even though a revolt might be desirable. Even in plenty of actual ship mutinies, the rebels didn't outright kill the overthrown officers, only imprisoned or marooned them. And that was in the context of the death penalty hanging over them if they failed. Violent revolutions in general have the small problem of bringing other violent psychopaths to power. Kaczynski might not mind, but I do. It was a well-known problem in actual pirate crews as well, and pirates actually had some interesting rules (including a fairly modern division of powers on board) to prevent the most violent psychos from taking over their ships and introduce some measure of consensus into their internal politics. His caricature of "weaklings abhorring violence" does not address the succession problem at all, and even if the original officer crew was bad, another officer crew self-selected of willing murderers could conceivably be worse by being both professionally incompetent and ready to torture their opponents etc.
- mdp2021 3y ago> far from any actual life-threatening situation, which is what it actually is Not clear. Several legitimate interpretations of "going North" into current situations are factually «life-threatening».
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoThere are entire fields dedicated to this question. Do violent revolutions ever work? But then, have any peaceful ones worked? History is full of violent revolutions that continued to be violent as you say, but even less peaceful revolutions that worked. Of course, you can also argue that all government is a form of violence, the police are the only ones allowed by society to enact violence to protect property. If the state actions diverge from the population ideals enough, then to some extent the population is already at war with the state.
- 11235813213455 3y agoFrench revolution 1789 maybe too? (Even if currency democracies start to be too disconnected to people again, I'd prefer direct democracy like in Switzerland) Arab spring protests too 2011 There are many examples actually, and there will be more and more with the current rate of environmental destruction. I can already forecast people blocking airports in the future if the governments don't anticipate and regulate drastically civil aviation
- sudosysgen 3y agoHuh? The Arab Spring movement was mostly coopted by Jihadists. The French Revolution was followed by decades of Terror which led to more dictatorship and death, and even after that the death and dictatorship merely moved over to the colonies.
- 11235813213455 3y agoFrench revolution happened for a reason, not saying it's necessarily better after, but it's an example where the pressure on people was too high, and they used violence to change things