7 ms·
> I’m a fan of charging market efficient rates for shared goods. Are you a fan of charging market rates for transit as well?
by cyberax 3y ago
> I’m a fan of charging market efficient rates for shared goods.
Are you a fan of charging market rates for transit as well?
- creato 3y agoSure, as long as you consider externalities like congestion. That would suggest charging for passage through congested areas (the subject of this thread), and subsidizing mass transit in congested areas.
- cyberax 3y ago[flagged]
- paulgb 3y agoI’m suspicious of that. LA is famous for low use of transit (relative to population) and is also famous for having bad congestion.
- cyberax 3y agoYou can screw up everything if you try hard enough. LA is an example of that. On the other hand, the Greater Houston Area has a similar population to NYC, yet it has 26-minute commutes versus 36 minutes for NYC.
- nimbleplum40 3y agoHuh? The Houston metro area has 7.5 million people. The New York City metro area has 20 million. If you want to look at the city proper (not a great comparison since city boundaries are somewhat arbitrary) then it’s 2 million for Houston versus 8 million for NYC. It’s not even close.
- Eisenstein 3y agoYou logic is completely backwards. Dense housing doesn't result in traffic congestion. If more people live closer together there is more population density, but as long as they can access commercial areas easily then they can do their shopping and work and recreational tasks without cars. When you remove cars then you suddenly have much more living space because a car takes up a large amount of room to store and there must be extra space for commuters and visitors. Are you seriously arguing that adding more space for cars makes cities less congested? For every one parking space you add you remove a large amount of useful space for other things.
- cyberax 3y ago> Dense housing doesn't result in traffic congestion. Yes, it does. And the relationship is causal. > If more people live closer together there is more population density, but as long as they can access commercial areas easily then they can do their shopping and work and recreational tasks without cars. What a bunch of bullshit. > Are you seriously arguing that adding more space for cars makes cities less congested? Not quite. Nothing can help hellscapes like Manhattan. They just need to be slowly de-densified, it'll take generations, but it will be done eventually. Cities should make sure that they don't rely on transit, and the rest will follow.
- nimbleplum40 3y ago> What a bunch of bullshit. How so? I live in lower Manhattan. I go to work, the gym, parks, restaurants, bars, movie theaters, etc. all without a car. > Nothing can help hellscapes like Manhattan. Lol. Don’t move to Manhattan then. Some of us enjoy it. Some of us prefer it over the suburbs. You don’t have to. No one is forcing you.
- josephcsible 3y ago> Some of us prefer it over the suburbs. You don’t have to. No one is forcing you. A lot of people say suburbs are bad and that we need to get rid of them.
- zip1234 3y agoFor sure, let's charge methods of transportation based on negative externalities such as how much space they take, safety, and noise/particulate pollution.
- cyberax 3y agoI'm all for it! It would suck for transit, though: 1. It has a higher CO2 footprint than small/medium EVs. 2. Transit forces people into smaller and denser housing, resulting in suboptimal living conditions. 3. Buses in particular result in excessive road wear&tear. It's really amazing that people say things like "car owners should not get subsidized" (by whom?), while talking about transit that is literally infeasible without massive subsidies.
- zip1234 3y ago> It's really amazing that people say things like "car owners should not get subsidized" (by whom?), while talking about transit that is literally infeasible without massive subsidies. If road usage fees cover less than half the cost of roads then clearly someone is subsidizing roads.
- alphanullmeric 3y agoSounds like roads should be paid for only by their users, and proportionally to their use. Then it would be irrelevant whether it’s a sedan or bus since everyone pays their fair share. But of course, such solutions are not acceptable to those that do not intend to pay their fair share.
- pessimizer 3y ago> 1. It has a higher CO2 footprint than small/medium EVs. This is too misleading to be unintentional. I don't know if you're comparing buses to small/medium EVs 1:1, but even if you aren't, the environmental footprint of replacing all bus services with EVs would be extraordinary. > 2. Transit forces people into smaller and denser housing, resulting in suboptimal living conditions. Transit doesn't force people into housing. It creates new housing options that previously were not tenable. Rivers don't create port congestion, rivers create ports. Not having enough ports, or enough rivers, creates port congestion. > 3. Buses in particular result in excessive road wear&tear. In proportion to human-miles, or is this a 1:1 comparison?
- superseeplus 3y agoTo be fair, that is how commuter trains in the NYC metropolitan area work. The fares are higher during rush hour to discourage people who can shift their schedule from traveling during rush hour.
- op00to 3y agoSure. Let's make sure we account for all the negative follow-on effects from personal car ownership including wasted space from parking, pollution, etc etc. Also account all the positive effects from transit - less wasted space for parking, less pollution, etc etc.