6 ms·
The lubricant has been applied to the slope...
by jrockway 15y ago
The lubricant has been applied to the slope...
- drivebyacct2 15y agoOh here, let me try based on what I learned from the reddit/cp discussion that took place here, what, last week: - slippery slopes don't exist, they're apparently some sort of imaginary fallacy - If you argue that Tumblr shouldn't remove content at their own arbitrary discretion, that must mean you want people to have eating disorders and commit suicide. I will call you disgusting and imply that even having a discussion about censorship or suppression of content is akin to defending child porn, I mean, suicidal content. On a less sarcastic note, I really do want to hear how people are going to tell me this isn't a slippery slope. "“that actively promotes or glorifies self-injury or self-harm.”". My [imaginary] Tumblr talks about how I deprive myself of sleep working long hours, use marijuana for stress relief and recreation and how I don't like to wear my helmet when I ride my motorcycle, better find a new blog (or whatever Tumblr is) platform.
- blantonl 15y agoThere is no "slope" when it comes to private establishments. Just like McDonalds reserves the right to not serve you if you aren't wearing shoes or a shirt, Tumblr reserves the right to limit whatever content they see fit. Freedom of speech does not apply when participating on a private organization's platform.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoWhy does the term "slippery slope" only apply to public rights? Again, no one is making this a legal thing. No one here is saying that Tumblr is legally required to let me blog about my suicide. We're saying that it's concerning as a [potential] user to see a provider like this arbitrarily suppressing content.
- blantonl 15y agoFirst, who is "we?" And second, if it is a concern that Tumblr won't allow your content, why can't you develop (or find) your own platform? Just because these platforms have huge audiences doesn't mean they are appropriate for your individual message.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoSorry, I'm surely abusing the proverbial "we". I just feel that your attempting to discredit anyone who dissents as using "free speech" when this really (as you point out) isn't about free speech at all. For the record, I do use my own platform and don't really ever use Tumblr. The sorts of things I write about don't really attract the "repost"/"like" style of Tumblr and I don't think the audience would be relevant anyway. I can say that if I ever decided to start a photography blog or something where mass audiences and such were important, I would be much less likely to use Tumblr knowing that this is their policy. I guess I feel like your defending Tumblr from some sort of attack by me. Like I said, Tumblr is free to do whatever they want and their users can leave or stay. I just think this policy is a turn-off and I wouldn't be shocked if in 3 months we see "Tumblr bans tumbles(?) about drugs/rock-n-roll, etc" posts.
- potatolicious 15y agoI don't think this is necessarily a slippery slope. AFAIK (I may be wrong though) this isn't due to external pressure or some PR fiasco (coughreddit), this is something Tumblr has decided did not reflect their company ethic, and wants off their platform. The difference between this and reddit's last run-in with offensive content is that Tumblr has shown no weakness here, whereas Reddit more than proved that a sufficiently large PR catastrophe is all it takes to change site policy. What Reddit has encouraged is more boycotts and more PR shitstorms from 3rd parties hoping to affect change on the site. Tumblr, by acting proactively, has not opened these doors (yet). They are still their own arbiters of good taste, as opposed to opening the floodgates of mob-rule.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoInventing a new company policy in response to something you found distasteful and then enforcing that upon your existing user base screams slippery slope. Especially given there is even less of a brightline standard of what violates Tumblr's policy than when we were considering reddit. It's much easier (not to trivialize it) to determine if something is child-related and sexual of nature than the entire realm of things contained in "self-injury". As I implied in my other comment, things like "self-injury" are very arbitrary and vary person-to-person. (Not that I should have to disclaim this, but I don't think things like suicide or eating disorders are "good" or healthy).
- potatolicious 15y ago> "very arbitrary and vary person-to-person" Sure, but the point of this is that Tumblr is the ultimate arbiter of what falls into and out of the content policy. And honestly, I expect "Tumblr staff" as a group to be a lot more focused and a lot less fickle than the internet community at large. Compared to a reactionary response to external pressure, a la reddit, where you've essentially handed the reigns to third parties. By acting proactively instead of reacting to PR pressure, Tumblr has basically drawn a line where their content policy lies, and they shown that they will determine what does and does not violate it - not some angry blog, community vote, or other mob-based "democracy". Giving a small group of people editorial control is unlikely to lead to a slippery slope. Giving everyone editorial control certainly does, as special interests emerge and find out they can play the system.