3 ms·
Why should I have to assemble my DVCS from parts before I would be able to use it? If I wanted Lego I would have got one. Because sometimes simplicity is a goo
by untog 15y ago
Why should I have to assemble my DVCS from parts before I would be able to use it? If I wanted Lego I would have got one.
Because sometimes simplicity is a good thing? I'm not a Mercurial user, but there are plenty of times when decoupling features is a good thing- look at Mozilla Communicator Suite (or whatever it was called) vs. Firefox.
For the record, I use git every day and I'm yet to need rebase. No, my projects aren't all that complex, nor do they have a huge number of branches. But I suspect that is the case for a lot of other people, too.
- guard-of-terra 15y agoI always make changes or even commit things to the wrong branch and then struggle to move those where they're supposed to be. If you don't use branches much (like most github users) you probably don't have this problem. We have version branches, so I do.
- josegonzalez 15y agoI'd like to see a reference for your comment "most github users don't use branches much".
- eropple 15y agoNot sure he's accurate when referring to Github users, but I think he's probably not far off for git users in general. I mean, most git users aren't the people hanging around here. I don't see a reason to expect that more than "the simplest thing that could possibly work" to be commonplace. When I use git (I tend to use hg more because it's more friendly for Windows projects, where I often find myself), I generally work on master for personal projects where I'm the only committer. It's easier for that use case. Branches are primarily valuable, IMO, when you have multiple people bashing on it at once.