9 ms·
FBI: FISA Section 702 'absolutely critical' to spy on, err, protect Americans
- 666satanhimself 3y ago[dead]
- EscapeFromNY 3y agoWhen it comes to the US, a lot of people treat "freedom" as a euphemism for war. (see: Team America) I wonder if "protection" will start becoming a euphemism for surveillance.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- smegger001 3y agothat would be double-plus-ungood.
- HPsquared 3y agoThat's a word to be avoided in branding, I think. The former German SS (Schutzstaffel) translates to "protection squadron" in English.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoIf? We're already there. That's the crux of this article.
- asveikau 3y agoTeam America was satirizing a specific moment in history, where they used fear of 9/11 to support an unjust war. That moment has passed. We may be vulnerable to that kind of crap again, but I don't see it right now.
- xbar 3y agoI am not sure. I feel more surveilled than I thought would ever be possible. My car watches me in my own garage, and the FBI can pull that data without telling me, without a warrant, just to learn my impressive laundry habits (I'll skip you the trouble, FBI: I use Gain and Downy and Borax, always on cold, tumble dry low).
- asveikau 3y agoAnd how is that related to using freedom as a reason to invade a sovereign state and suppress opinions not in favor?
- colpabar 3y agoSure, but to be fair, how many 9/11’s have happened since the first one?
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago9/11 was the extreme statistical anomaly. US Citizens have been historically safe from domestic terrorism for 50 years. ref: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/04/16/eight-facts-about-terrorism-in-the-united-states/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/04/16/eight... (2013 but the numbers are about the same. Odds of dying in a domestic terror attack vary between 1:12000000 & 1:40000000 or the same as picking the correct inch between DC and NYC). It is interesting this period of safety coincided with the release of the Pentagon Papers and the Church Committee that followed. One result of which was forcing the FBI away from domestic surveillance and refocusing it into a law enforcement mission. This lasted for about 40 years (after which the FBI officially abandoned it's LEO mission to pursue the power that comes with NatSec operations).
- monocasa 3y agoHow many have been attempted since then?
- drewcoo 3y agoThey happen annually.
- justinclift 3y agoNo. Team America was satirizing the general US approach of trampling over all other countries in the name of "The American Way". That's not really changed.
- asveikau 3y agoNot really. I haven't seen the thing since 2004. But I thought it was pretty dumb and ironically very US centric in its treatment of these topics. It wasn't a deep criticism. It also at the same time mocked celebrities for being against the war. For the record I was very vehemently against the Iraq war from day one.
- 20after4 3y agoMaybe you missed the deeper satirical message.
- asveikau 3y agoOr maybe it was a shitty movie. There's lots one could say about US foreign policy, but that was 90 minutes of fart jokes. It's weird what people try to venerate sometimes.
- justinclift 3y agoLots of people seemed to have really liked it. As an example, when I was staying at a backpacking hostel in Perth, Australia many years ago the entire lounge area was packed out by people (during the day!) when it was being shown. That was ~70 people, many of them who were walking by initially but saw it on and stuck around to watch it. In that backpacking hostel, there'd not been anywhere close to that number of people watching any other movie. So, there was definitely some kind of interest by people. :)
- sneak 3y agoThe US Department of Defense (renamed from Department of War) is currently waging offensive war in a half dozen foreign lands right now.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoWhich foreign lands?
- joecool1029 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_armed_conflicts_involving_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_armed_conflicts_involv... < look for present, it's probably more than a half-dozen. Falls under the same Authorization for Use of Miltary Force of 2001.
- HWR_14 3y agoThere are five conflicts under "present", none of which are offensive. Two are helping countries put down insurgencies, two are fighting piracy from Somalia and two are involved in civil wars in the Middle East. (They add up to six because insurgents and pirates are allies). Most of them are as part of a giant collation. Only the Syrian one is actually being led by the US. None of them are to conquer territory or any other description of "offensive war" I've ever seen.
- sneak 3y agoNone of them involve defending the US.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoMoving the goalposts. Original claim was offensive wars.
- sneak 3y ago
- AmenBreak 3y ago[flagged]
- hunglee2 3y ago[flagged]
- pyinstallwoes 3y agoThat’s probably where algorithms can shine, given its rules are public within. certain lagging window and inspectable. The automated bias is a good thing in that case because it’s at least predictable compared to human corruption in surveillance. AI kind of emerges as a perfect middle mediator between parties by being not of the same species.
- nathan_compton 3y agoI can't help but find this a bit disingenuous. People on Hackernews are posting publicly and voluntarily with the expectation of moderation. Reading hackernews comments would be, for the FBI, regular detective work. The issue here is the public's expectation of privacy in certain situations. In fact, no one (or very few people, anyway) dispute the need for states to surveil sometimes. The question is when and what oversight should be required. And in this case the the argument is that oversight was sidestepped.
- EMCymatics 3y agoI don't know what has been posted before this all I see is [flagged]. >posting publicly and voluntarily with the expectation of moderation I find this statement a bit difficult when it is perhaps a duty to participate in the public square or whatever square is used to embody the desires of common or public will. If people are deterred from this arena without cause and abuse then perhaps we have failed. This entire ecosystem rests on the belief of decency or fairness. I have yet to see it. >The issue here is the public's expectation of privacy in certain situations. In fact, no one (or very few people, anyway) dispute the need for states to surveil sometimes. The question is when and what oversight should be required. And in this case the the argument is that oversight was sidestepped. That is incorrect. During the oversight committee they identified there was a consistent mis-interpertation of the law (now corrected) from one side to the other under 702 which perhaps enabled unauthorized use (which perhaps was appropriate under other sections). It was up to (not just due to mis-interpertation) 30% of searches in error in the potential to be in the millions of incorrect searches. I dont see much oversight for other codes. We have possibly 10,000 people with access to obtain information and we are not close to consistent oversight given moving codes and authorizations. Congress has failed the bodies that keep us safe but not without some significant non-compliance. [1] Private access to information probably has great advantage over public ones. I believe we should consider carefully how we want to yield the power the public sector has given us. The potential for private and public conflict on this matter is significant. We should not shoo people away with differing opinions. If language models are the future for communication and teaching while they are learning with data off of 'public' and 'accurate' discorse we are very much in danger of having a future led by biases inherent in these models (from moderation and 'weeded garden' environments) that 'isnt a problem' to the people creating the future. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pIEqAjRKVyE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pIEqAjRKVyE
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- zug_zug 3y agoI think as a starting point maybe a good thing to agree on is that we want more transparency around alleged threats. Iirc this all started around 9/11 and there was this shroud of secrecy mentality that revealing anything, even whether the operation had even caught a single terrorist, was somehow going to empower terrorists. I think in hindsight that doesn't hold up to scrutinty. I think some good metrics to be made public before a renewal is considered should be: what crimes were being investigated (e.g. was this drugs, pornography, domestic election tampering, international spying, exfiltration of government secrets, money laundering?). And how many total cases? And what % of cases lead to a conviction? And also a way for everyday citizens to request an FOIA on whether they had their data looked at. There are world where I could see this hypothetically being put to good use, and if people know what they use this for becomes visible to the public I think it forces us closer to such a world.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> a good thing to agree on is that we want more transparency around alleged threats. I'll separate out digital threats here as evidence you are beyond correct. 1) Decades of taxpayers funding the hoarding of ~100% of threat data, away from qualified netsec experts, so that it could be reserved to protecting US Gov interests (noting that NatSec typically includes US Gov, Gov partners, major campaign donors and that's about it). 2) One agency head after another sounding klaxons w/o evidence (eg:Digital Pearl Harbor), to influence policy in a way that would ratchet up agency power.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoThey could definitely do a better job of communicating what they're doing, why they need to do it, risks, and their successes or failures. With that said they do communicate with Congress who are all directly elected by us. I think that we should also agree that secrecy is sometimes necessary.
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoif i recall correctly, a three-letter agency was spying on the congress comitee that oversees them. When was the last time a senior official of a 3-letter agency was fired/jailed for exceeding his authority? Did it ever happen?
- tomohawk 3y agoThe past several years have shown that while the intentions of FISA are probably good, it is too easy to abuse. The FBI and many high government officials have abused FISA again and again. Crossfire hurricane is just one obvious instance. The FISA court has admonished FBI officials for the abuse, but that's about it. If they're going to have FISA, there needs to be real penalties for abuse. Loss of position. Prison time. There needs to be real consequences for breaking the laws on this. Otherwise, it need to go.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoThe state won’t subjugate and punish itself
- xbar 3y agoIt's been this way for decades. Consider Feinstein's permanent, steadfast, and sweeping support. She asked completely a performative set of "questions" about its abuse in 2017, along with a lot of pro-702 data. Mostly, she was chock full of softballs under the false pretense of being concerned about privacy, that obviously led to no improvement. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w8Fa-G6pGmI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w8Fa-G6pGmI Laws like 702 of FISA and the Patriot Act seem to be 2 of the 1,000 cuts against the legitimacy of government.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoThe FISA process is seeing a lot of much needed scrutiny because of perceived political persecution towards Republicans and Trump. I think it'll be a good thing whether or not Republicans intentions are selfish or noble.
- drewcoo 3y agoFISA originated as a response to Nixon's snooping, as an attempt to secure Americans' privacy against potential threats from (rogue elements of?) the government. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Intelligence_Surveillance_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Intelligence_Surveilla... I agree that Ted Kennedy had good intentions in 1978. The stuff today is out of control and completely contrary to the original intent.
- 3y ago
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoTo any HN community that was here prior to the Edward Snowden releases: Prior to 2013, we had enough evidence (Mark Klein, etc) that US Gov was actively conducting bulk warrantless surveillance of Americans (not suspected of a crime). Back then, was there a dominant HN vibe about domestic spying (eg: yawn, apologist, anger)?
- eastbound 3y agoThe mood back then was that domestic spying didn’t exist. As in: Imagine the scale it requires, you’re stupid if you believe, what, that the NSA tapes all of our records?!? Put your tinfoil hat back.
- jerkstate 3y agoI dunno, there's always been a greybeard contingent here that's been in or around telecom or otherwise know about Operation Shamrock, Echelon, room 641A, and so on, before Snowden.
- fnordfnordfnord 3y agoYeah and it was pretty common to be voted down and called a crank over it too.
- pessimizer 3y agoHence, "greybeard." Even when people are talking about something that they know to be true, they ground themselves in derogatory stereotypes about the people who were right.
- jerkstate 3y agoDo you consider “greybeard” to be a derogatory stereotype? I sure don’t..
- 3y ago
- cyanydeez 3y agoForgive me, but it's hard to believe 2 years ago a far right supremacist president tried to overthrow democracy and we are supposed to believe the FBI is using this to protect Americans?
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoI think the two aren't closely tied to each other. Here are >15 years of stories that show an fairly unbroken line of this particular abuse. https://www.google.com/search?q=site:techdirt.com+"fbi"+"702" https://www.google.com/search?q=site:techdirt.com+"fbi"+"702...
- dwringer 3y agoTbf he did fail, was prevented from going himself in person, and over a thousand of the people that he got to go have all been arrested as a result now.
- anonymousiam 3y agoThe FBI has been mum, but some sources indicate a large FBI presence among the Capitol rioters, and some incitement by them too. If true, this would be typical FBI behavior. https://www.freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/2022/08/11/whitmer-kidnap-trial-jury-rogue-fbi-informants/10296330002/ https://www.freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/2022/08/11/w... https://www.techdirt.com/2010/11/30/fbi-celebrates-that-it-prevented-fbis-own-bomb-plot/ https://www.techdirt.com/2010/11/30/fbi-celebrates-that-it-p...
- pclmulqdq 3y agoI don't know why this is particularly contentious or controversial. The FBI played a huge role in the Chicago 7 incident in the 70's, which hit progressive democrats. They did the same thing with many other progressive movements in the 70's and 80's. Incitement of riots using informants and undercover agents is a time-honored tradition for the FBI.
- djfobbz 3y agoYou are living proof that propaganda works. Thanks for confirming.
- EMCymatics 3y agoI wonder how we are protecting the public square for or against private interests?
- cornflake23 3y agoSo long as it first, and only applies to the plebes, most of whom are too caught up in just surviving, these arguments will just remain as doublespeak. Problems in any institution are systemic to large degrees. From hiring to training and culture. Those take time to change too. Checks and Balances, the Supreme courts etc are just the tail end of the endemic issues. Add the military-corporate-oligarchy complex and you have what we got here. And in spite of saying all this, I too am juggling with high rent and trying to secure a future for my family. Ie no “time” to do anything but offer just words. I suspect many are in situations like me.
- deviantbit 3y agoSecret courts have no place in the United States. The constitution guarantees you the right to defend yourself against an accuser (5A). You are not allowed to be in that court when you're accused. Also, the government is prohibited from unreasonable search and seizures (4A). When they get a court order, you're not allowed to defend against. FISA has never been before the Supreme Court, as you need a defendant. Since the court is secret, and no defendants allowed, it is never going to the supreme court. If you're accused, and go to trial, FISA evidence remains secret, and discovery is never given to your attorney. When you're on the receiving end of this, you will beg for your rights. The government has unlimited power, and resources to destroy you.
- jazzyjackson 3y ago> FISA has never been before the Supreme Court, as you need a defendant. Since the court is secret, and no defendants allowed, it is never going to the supreme court. Golf clap for the chum who yanked this loophole
- supernova87a 3y agoDo you take the position that there is no role / need whatsoever for a court in the United States that needs to hear confidential matters having to do with law enforcement, where to reveal it to the subject would compromise the investigation? I think your desire to paint it as some evil government bogeyman + some philosophy that everything should be open is over simplistic and honestly a little naive in how a country needs to defend itself. Now I am no fan of all that the FISA court has allowed. There are legitimate criticisms of how the lack of transparency has allowed some rubber stamping of investigations without good adversarial oversight. But to fundamentally assert that such a court should not exist is a bit ridiculous. You might as well suggest that every time before knocking down the door of a drug dealer, the drug dealer's attorney must be notified and get a chance to argue against the search warrant in front of the issuing judge, because in a couple of cases, they knocked on the wrong person's door.
- ch4s3 3y agoThat you think the government should be in the business of kicking in doors without due process over mere chemical intoxicants is telling. It is anathema to the founding ideals, and historically illiterate with respect to alcohol prohibition.
- activiation 3y agoSecret courts violate all laws....
- supernova87a 3y agoFor those interested in a genuine intellectual debate about it, I offer the following point. Do you believe that there is no role / need whatsoever for a court in the United States that needs to hear confidential matters having to do with law enforcement, where to reveal it to the subject would compromise the investigation? If you do believe there is the role for such a court, then the question is not whether it should exist, but how well it is overseen / checked, and what mechanisms there are to make sure it operates on correct information and has an advocate for the parties that are not allowed to participate in its decisions. If you believe that there is never a need for law enforcement decisions to be made that cannot be revealed to the accused party, then that is a separate (and in my opinion, impractical/unreal) point. We might as well ban judge-issued search warrants unless the person whose property is being searched gets a chance to hear the evidence and object.
- joshspankit 3y agoThere’s a very good reason we have the process of investigate > accuse > bring to court and in those cases the accused party is detained while the facts are reviewed and the matter decided. Judge-issued search warrants are done as a part of the investigation and the investigation itself is secret.
- ccooffee 3y ago> If you believe that there is never a need for law enforcement decisions to be made that cannot be revealed to the accused party, then that is a separate (and in my opinion, impractical/unreal) point. Well, uhh, thanks for inviting a "genuine intellectual debate" and then out-of-hand dismissing any disagreements as "impractical/unreal". We already have the grand jury which is a secret process and can deliver so called "sealed indictments" which prevents the indicted party from knowing they have been indicted. Grand juries have significant oversight and a long history of legal oversight. FISA "courts", on the other hand, operate in an intentionally ill-defined legal space. To me, FISA courts are just as nonsense as the "unlawful enemy combatant" Bush-era policies. "This system is not _technically_ against the law because we built-in enough loopholes to prevent any actual legal oversight" should not be a valid argument for upholding a corrupt status-quo. I don't accept the premise that some information is _too dangerous_ to be heard by a grand jury. We already have legal processes to limit exposure, including many trial processes that are done without the jury being present.