3 ms·
>The rich already pay a disproportionately large amount of taxes How do people come up with these ideas? Related to their income and overall wealth they pay d
by coldtea 3y ago
>The rich already pay a disproportionately large amount of taxes
How do people come up with these ideas?
Related to their income and overall wealth they pay disproportionate embarassingly little.
The "disrpoportionate" also includes well paid employees in the top 10%, but not the real 0.1% "owning" class. And above a few million worth, the actual money earned per year is usually obscured by all kinds of schemes, of which only the salary and capital gains tax ends up taxed (if that).
And that's without even considering the millions (pun intended) of ways they have to avoid being taxed but still have access to their money, from estates and "charity" foundations they control, to offshores, passing spending as expenses to their companies, special tax cuts, the ease of moving abroad for "tax reasons" at will (no biggie if you have the power to be accepted whether you go, the ability to pay the set amounts to acquire a foreign passport/nationality, to move with trivial for you costs, and so on), and of course access to teams of much better accountants...
- hellojesus 3y agoAssuming US: Tax is based on income. If you find a way to avoid income, you don't have any income to be taxed. There are certainly ways to game the system, but those ways mean one isn't realizing income. Seems relatively fair to me. After all, the gov isn't supposed to be a welfare machine,and stealing from others is generally regarded as theft.
- coldtea 3y ago>Seems relatively fair to me. It's legal. It's hardly fair. It means the working/middle class masses get to pay the burden of taxes (including sales taxes, and others) disproportionately to their income and wealth - and of course, the money taken from them is orders of magnitude more impactful on their everyday life than if we half of Bezos income (or even half his total wealth) was taxed away. >and stealing from others is generally regarded as theft. Only as long as you're not rich. If you're its normalized and has lots of legal avenues available to you to do that, same how unfairness is codified in laws like the above, in which "if you find a way to avoid income, you don't have any income to be taxed", which was made the case precisely because the rich have ample easy means to "avoid income".
- hellojesus 3y agoApart from being illegal constitutionally at the federal level, what does a wealth tax truly do? 1. Forces wealthy to liquidate assets. Impact: stock prices go down, real estate markets get excess supply floods, etc. 2. Forces income through taxable sales. 3. Theft I fail to understand how taxing wealth is not stealing. Any time a wealthy person wants to utilize wealth to consume a product, someone somewhere is paying taxes on it. The closest that gets to not being true is when wealthy use their stock as collateral for loans and then get to take interest write offs, but the bank is still going to pay income tax on the interest income they receive. Wealth means nothing until it is utilized, and all ways in which it's utilized are taxed.
- tzs 3y agoYou and he are talking about different things. Let's take a concrete example: me and Donald Trump. In 2018 Trump's federal income tax was over 100x what mine was. But as a percentage of our respective incomes he paid 4.1% and I paid about 10%. He's talking about the amount, you are talking about the percent of the taxpayer's income.